Bob slams leaky school rebuild


Former Tauranga MP Bob Clarkson is claiming project managers are racking up thousands of dollars in unnecessary costs at taxpayer expense on leaky building rebuilds.
Bob points to Papamoa's Tahatai Coast School as an example.


Bob Clarkson.

"I have kept an eye on the rebuild and reclad of the school and have been horrified at what I've seen," says Bob, a builder and landlord.
"Timber is being replaced that is in good condition, and work is being done that is unjustified."
He says samples from a 25-metre long wall were tested at a laboratory and the results found the timber did not have any toxic mould.
"I nearly fell out of my chair - not only was there no mould, I found out the timber was treated. It did not have to be replaced.
"It infuriates me," says Bob. "Some lawyers and builders are cashing in on the tragedy of leaky homes.
"Controls need to be put in place to ensure the repair work is justified."

The Tahatai Coast School project mangers say they are unable to comment or reply to Bob's accusations without clearance from the Ministry of Education, the client. The Ministry has not yet replied.

Bob says he also knows of cases where timber is being taken out of leaky homes, is being treated and put back into other new houses.
Bob worked on the leaky building problem during his three years as an MP, and backs the new government policy, which he initiated.
But he says repairs need to be properly monitored "or else the rip-offs in the system will continue, the price to reclad or rebuild will exceed all expectation, and the government policy will fail."
Bob is also concerned at $12 million in repairs and legal fees he says it will cost to reclad 40 units at the Cutterscove Resort Apartments at Mount Maunganui. It should have cost about $3 million, says Bob.
Under the leaky building policy, the government and local councils will each pay 25 per cent of the repairs and homeowners will handle the other 50 per cent in costs. They can also take out a bank loan, under normal terms, with support from the government.
To avoid rip offs, Bob says the government should appoint independent consultants on a set fee to control the leaky building repairs.
The consultant would determine the extent of the problem, price the job and oversee the repair.
"The problem is a financial time bomb for the government and local councils. We have to break the leaky building food chain and keep the costs under control," says Bob.

4 comments

Right on Bob, watch out Christchurch

Posted on 29-09-2010 15:26 | By Murray.Guy

Bob is right on the button but sadely a lone voice in a wilderness of 'millionaire consultants'. A personal experience in this area was rectified slightly ubder a 1/3 of the consultants estimates. Look out Christchurch where the same attitudes and outcomes will prevail.


New Schools

Posted on 29-09-2010 20:08 | By annief

I agree - so why have one of the new schools that is being built in Papamoa at present being built by the same company that built Tahatai School. Look at all the problems with the leaky buildings - hope that doesn't happen in 10-20yrs with the new schools being built now.


Don't believe builders!

Posted on 30-09-2010 08:12 | By leaky

Although Bob the builder may be well respected in his area, those already bitten by the leaky bug know better than to listen to what experienced, but uninformed builders say. If Bob had the remotest knowledge of leaky building remediation, he would know that industry practice deems that timber 1m either side of damaged areas is replaced. This is simply because it is not practical to lab test every piece of timber in the building, so the precaution to replace timber near a known rotten area is the only safe choice. Bob should also know that you can't trust builders to build to plan, nor can we trust council inspectors to pick up faults. The engineers and project managers, in reality, are the only ones on site with proper qualifications, often out-qualifying even the council inspectors. So Bob, which part of 'doing the job properly' don't you quite understand?


Rebuild??

Posted on 10-10-2010 19:53 | By Andrew T

Bob, spot on I have seen the same happening every morning I drop my children off at a certain school in Welcome bay that is under repair. As a qualified builder myself I can see the open cheque book policy at work here. One classroom was dropped and rebuilt as it looked like it needed some work, but I have to say it was not needing to be put in the skip completely, Its crazy. As a builder with very little work myself it makes me sick to see what is going on, thanks for speaking up Bob


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.