Cyst surgery leaves woman with colostomoy bag

The surgery in question took place in 2019.

A woman has been left with a permanent colostomy bag after her bowel was perforated during surgery to remove a 30cm ovarian cyst.

In 2019, the woman in her 20s underwent surgery for what she thought was the removal of a cyst on her right ovary.

On Monday, Health and Disability Commissioner Morag McDowell found an obstetrician/gynaecologist in breach of the patients’ rights code relating to the procedure.

During surgery, the specialist found the large cyst in the lower abdomen, which unexpectedly had arisen from her left ovary instead. An additional cyst was also discovered on the left side.

He removed part of the cyst, another senior gynaecologist removed the remaining part.

The woman had a background of Hirschsprung’s disease – a birth defect where some nerve cells are missing in the large intestine. In children, it can leave them unable to move stool through the intestine which can become blocked if left untreated. The woman had undergone surgery as an infant which left her with a “dense” scar on her left flank.

Given her previous surgery, she was hesitant about procedures on the left side of her body.

The cyst surgery concluded without any apparent issue at the time.

But two days later, she became “very unwell”, with abdominal pain, fever, and a fast heart rate (tachycardia).

A CT scan identified that her bowel was perforated (pierced), which had caused sepsis. Emergency surgery was done – removing part of the bowel, requiring a colostomy.

Ms A complained to HDC that she consented to have a cyst removed only from her right ovary and had not consented to left-sided surgery, or to the removal of any additional cyst discovered during surgery.

Expert advice as part of the HDC investigation confirmed there was increased risk of bowel injury owing to the woman’s previous left-sided surgery, due to scar tissue.

The surgeon was also aware this meant increased complexity of surgery, with an at least 19% risk of the complication, the report stated.

Morag found the specialist breached the code for failing to advise her of the increased risk of bowel injury.

The report states there was also a level of uncertainty prior to surgery about the origin of the cyst and, given the woman’s reluctance to left-sided surgery, she should have been advised about this.

Morag says she would have expected the specialist to communicate this, alongside an explanation that findings during the procedure could necessitate a change from the original plan.

Instead, the woman was not able to make an informed choice about proceeding, McDowell determined.

Following the surgery, the woman raised her concerns with the health board, writing a letter outlining her experience and the “profound” impact it had on her relationships, mental health, and inability to return to work.

“I felt what happened to me was unfair. I went in with right-sided pain and the intentions of having a large cyst removed on my right ovary, but I had left-sided surgery that I didn’t consent to,” she told HDC.

“Now I am left with a permanent left sided [c]olostomy. I did not receive any emotional support to help me cope with everything while I was in hospital. I’m still trying to deal with the trauma.”

The hospital where the operation took place undertook its own investigation and apologised to the woman.

The specialist found in breach has retired, and provided a written apology to the woman.

-Hannah Martin/Stuff.

0 comments

Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.