Man‘s airway catches fire during voicebox surgery

The country’s health watchdog has issued a report relating to a case where a fire ignited in the man’s airway during an operation, during which he sustained burns to the side of his face and shoulder.

A man sustained burns to his face and shoulder after a fire ignited in his airway during surgery.

Though he survived the 'horrific event”, his daughter 'firmly” believes his life was shortened and quality of life 'dramatically changed” as a result, and 'the memories of his burnt face still haunts us”.

On Monday, Deputy Health and Disability Commissioner Carolyn Cooper​ found an otolaryngologist (ear, nose and throat specialist/head and neck surgeon) breached the patients' rights code in care of the man, aged in his 70s​.

In February 2020​, the man underwent surgery for recurrent growths on his voicebox.

He'd had 10​ previous operations for related issues, including one occasion where his oxygen levels dropped during surgery.

To manage this risk, doctors arranged to use special ventilation and oxygenation therapy, known as THRIVE (Transnasal Humidified Rapid Insufflation Ventilatory Exchange).

Its use carries a safety risk, given oxygen combined with ignition and fuel sources can cause fires, the report states.

The device's oxygen concentration was reduced to 30 per cent​ before each time it was used.

However, at the end of the surgery, when the laser had been turned off, the surgeon noticed a small area of disease and began to treat it using a high frequency electrical current to cut tissue (called monopolar suction diathermy).

The anaesthetic team were unaware that the surgeon had started using diathermy so had not reduced the oxygenation levels, the report states.

A fire ignited in a portion of the man's airway circuit – thought to be have been caused by the diathermy, combined with the oxygen concentration.

As soon as the fire ignited, the surgeon yelled 'fire!” and smothered the flames with wet towels that had been placed around Mr A's face.

The primary anaesthetist turned around and saw flames emerging from what appeared to be Mr A's mouth, the report states.

They immediately turned off the oxygen supply to the device's circuit.

While there were 'obvious” burns to the man's head, nose, lips and left shoulder, no airway burns were identified.

He sustained burns to an estimated 3-4 per cent​ of his body – classified as a minor burn.

He was intubated and sedated, and transferred to ICU, and remained in a medically induced coma for eight weeks, the report stated.

The man subsequently developed laryngeal cancer and died in 2022​.

Mr A's daughter says the stress of the event had taken a toll on the family.

'To the medical community this is just a [‘what will we do better next time' but] to us it is devastating.”

Cooper expressed her 'sincere condolences” to Mr A's family, acknowledging the 'significant challenges” they faced following his surgery, and 'significant impact” it had on his quality of life in his remaining years.

Cooper accepts that all precautions were taken during surgery, and that surgeon 'diligently” applied appropriate risk management strategies.

However, she says, it appears the surgeon 'didn't apply the same precautions” when using monopolar suction diathermy in a high-oxygen environment.

Cooper found the surgeon in breach for failing to 'adequately” communicate his use of diathermy with the anaesthetist, and failing to comply with the THRIVE guidelines.

Had the surgeon explicitly communicated with the anaesthetic team before using diathermy, it may have 'reduced the risk of a fire occurring”.

Cooper commends the surgeon for his 'rapid response” and actions once the fire ignited.

'I also accept that it was the surgeon's intention to improve the patient's quality of life, and that he did not intend to cause him any harm.”

Taking into account the apology provided, and changes made, Cooper did not consider other recommendations or actions necessary.

-Hannah Martin/Stuff.

0 comments

Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.