J Sage has many half-truths in his letter.
By the widely accepted definition of ‘indigenous' New Zealand has no such people.
For example, the Aboriginals of Australia or Bush Men of South Africa, have lived in their countries for many thousands of years, unlike Maori who were recent arrivals in what was really an empty country, and they leave it when they die.
Immigrants from Europe were mainly not 'arrogant” as Sage claims, just desperate to start a life free of the restrictions of their homelands.
Yes, some things did go badly wrong, now being recognised, including the impact on Maori of diseases that were totally new to them, and was the major factor that nearly led to them dying out in the late 1800s.
Maori were no more 'murdered” by these immigrants than Maori doing likewise to them. Sadly, Sage denigrates the name of Abel Tasman, who visited NZ and for his troubles a number of his crew were murdered by local Maori.
Understandably, he used his native Dutch language to name the country. I have no problem changing our name to Aotearoa, provided it is done through a binding referendum when the public at large expresses its wish.
P Hickling, Papamoa


3 comments
bad start...
Posted on 09-10-2020 10:21 | By KiwiDerek
If you're wanting to point out inaccuracies in J Sage's letter then it is perhaps dubious to start by a semantic argument trying to strip Maori of their "indigenous" status. Apparently they haven't been here long enough for your liking. This is a clearly a silly position - I suggest you look at a few more definitions of the word indigenous.
bad middle
Posted on 10-10-2020 08:39 | By R. Bell
the arrogance of Victorian British is undeniable. They generally viewed all races as inferior. That and the fact that the land confiscations denied Maori of the means to continue to prosper was at least equal in its effect on population decline. False equivalence is becoming a way of life it seems.
P Hickling Indigenous PakiHa
Posted on 16-10-2020 21:15 | By k Smith
P Hickling you need to know the meaning of your own language. R Bell & KiwiDerek are correct. Some of the contents of your letter are inaccurate. You also suggest that some Maori murdered some of Abel Tasmans men what facts do you have on this matter? Its a drop in the ocean compared to what the Pakeha did the past to the Maori, Black African slavery trade, American & Canadian Indians, Aborigines, all indigenous people and the main reason is so the British Monarchy can secure the land for themselves and have many slaves. K.Smith
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.