Horan unhappy with welfare reforms

Tauranga based New Zealand First MP Brendan Horan claims the National-led government's welfare reforms do nothing to promote the economy.

Brendan says the proposed welfare reforms will not help to lower Tauranga's high unemployment rate and instead the government should focus on creating jobs.


Brendan Horan.

'These reforms do nothing to promote the economy; the focus should be on creating more work opportunities.

'The Bay of Plenty has one of the highest unemployment rates and there needs to be an effort to create more jobs.

'There should be incentives with things like tax breaks to improve businesses in areas like agriculture to increase exports and manufacturing.”

Under proposed reforms, teenagers aged 16 and 17 years, and parents aged 16-18 years receiving the benefit, will have their basic costs paid directly to the provider.

They are also coupled with a training provider to help them budget, parent and undertake job training courses.

They will receive an allowance of $50 a week and have the chance to earn an extra $10 a week by participating in these training courses.

Solo parents on the DPB, widows and woman's alone benefit recipients will be required to look for part time work after their child turns five.

Women with children 14 years and above will be required to look for full time work.

Solo parents on the benefit who have a subsequent child will also be required to look for work once their child turns one.

Brendan says more emphasis should be put on up-skilling the population in areas like technology and communications, instead of cutting jobs in the public sector.

'The government is outsourcing jobs in Housing New Zealand, Air New Zealand is cutting jobs, it just seems like every week we hear of job losses.

'We need to be deeply concerned about the balance of payments and job creations.”

Brendan says the country is still a 'fair way away” from having enough jobs to be able to sustain such changes to the welfare system.

'I agree there are too many people on benefits, but there needs to be the jobs for these people to go to.”

Currently 13 per cent of New Zealand's population receive a benefit – 351,000 people, costing the state $8billion a year.

11 comments

Welfare reform a good start

Posted on 29-02-2012 09:07 | By Gee Really

On behalf of those whose taxes pay for out of control welfare, I'm happy that the government has started the process of weaning beneficiaries off the public trough. As for creating jobs, Brendan, are you suggesting my taxes go towards giving reduced taxes to favoured sectors. Feel free to use your own taxpayer-paid income to do so and see if it works. Or should we all buy gold franchises and add to the economy that way?


Suggestions

Posted on 29-02-2012 09:09 | By Thoughtful

Whilst perhaps the reforms aren't the final definitive answer to some of the welfare and unemployment issues they are nevertheless potentially a good start to correcting some of the perceived problems. Rather than knocking these and providing the usual meaningless general patter about what is required to fix the social issues how about Brendan & NZ First coming up with some realistic proposals - if indeed they have any!


No Jobs!

Posted on 29-02-2012 12:17 | By bringa

These solo parents are already looking for jobs and cant find any thats why they are on DPB. This welfare reform wont change anything for these people. They will still be looking for jobs and they will still be on the - now reduced - DPB. The problem is jobs, not the solo parents themselves who have gon thru enough strife in life as it is already!


A Good Start

Posted on 29-02-2012 12:19 | By Jitter

At least the goverment is trying to make changes to improve the current situation where many beneficiaries are ripping off the system. A start has to be made somewhere and although the suggested changes may not meet the agreement of everyone they will form the foundation for future chnages.


Hype

Posted on 29-02-2012 12:19 | By Steve Morris

Beneficiaries will be required to look for work, what the heck is wrong with that???? Surely the taxpayers who support them have the right to demand an assurance that those on the benefit are in training or trying to get a job? If they don't find one then their benefit doesn't change! The Government is NOT suggesting that those who can't find a job or who are physically incapable of doing work should have their benefit cut.


Well bringa

Posted on 29-02-2012 13:05 | By Jack the Lad

not all solo parents are tarnished by a few to many, but when you see young mothers with 3 or more children, some sired to different fathers, earning more on the benifit than I earn working, you have to wonder if they are breeding for money, one mistake fine, 2 I can possibly live with, 3 then they are on thier own. It has to stop!!!!!. We are all suffering with the economy the way it is, and jobs will only be created by improving it, if by making savings through cutting benifits, maybe things may improve, and this is at least a start.


Where oh Where...

Posted on 29-02-2012 13:31 | By marty78

are the jobs? As a solo parent I have already been affected by the reform. I have applied for numerous jobs and am usually turned down. Why? because I am either inexperienced or the job has already been taken. Today I applied for a Greenkeepers assistant and failed, because I did not have a genuine interest in golf!!! So there are those of us who are genuinely seeking employment and yet we are missing out, or missing something! I did not ask to be on a benefit and am ashamed to be on one, because of the stigma that comes with it.


Welfare

Posted on 29-02-2012 13:53 | By Oh Gosh

I am more than happy for my taxes to assist someone (male or female) to get out a violent relationship with their children (which is why the DPB came about) but not for single mothers to have child after child as a way of life so they don't have to work. On 30th November no one else should be able to apply for the DPB unless the fit the criteria of beaten person syndrome and have no family to support them


'The Few'

Posted on 29-02-2012 13:59 | By Calm Gully

It is always the few that spoil it for everyone - so IF you know of any, blame them. It would be nice if DPB was earned in someway, but being politically correct stops that. The government is working at reducing benefits, which will help all hard working taxpayers in the end. Gotta start somewhere, may it continue!


marty78

Posted on 29-02-2012 14:22 | By gregor

I am a retailer. Only one person has come in looking for work in the last year. That tells me people are not desperately trying to work. In Contrast in Australia in the same business I had one a week come in and make themselves known.


start somewhere

Posted on 29-02-2012 14:46 | By traceybjammet

dont be ashamed of needing some help be annoyed at the people who rort the system, less rorters means more funds for the people who are in need of assistance. we have to start making NZ a forward thinking society of people who dont expect the government to look after them and thier kids but those who need help can get the support they need working together is the key and resposibility for ones own decisions is needed not saying that people dont make mistakes


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.