A 10 year high in expulsion rates is concerning the Western Bay of Plenty Regional PPTA chairman.
Jason Smythe the social statistics of young people are of concern to our country.
Western Bay of Plenty PPTA chairman Jason Smythe says more needs to be done to help youths.
'In fact, one of the first tasks the prime minister assigned to his chief science advisor, Sir Peter Gluckman, was a report exploring the factors underlying adolescent behaviour and indicating where there may be evidence-based opportunities for changes to policy and practices that might help to mitigate its negative outcomes.
'The resulting report was entitled Improving the Transition: Reducing Social and Psychological Morbidity During Adolescence.”
He says there is a link with the 10 year high in expulsion rates and the Gluckman report.
'The report lists the poor outcomes for young people as teenage pregnancy, abortion, binge drinking, bullying, teenage crime, suicide and mental health problems.
'The key message behind Gluckman's findings is the need for tried and tested programmes to be implemented in early childhood and adolescence instead of using programmes that operate out of blind-faith.”
Jason says PPTA spoke with Gluckman he told them there was no silver bullet nor a wand to be waved to magically stop New Zealand youth featuring so prominently in statistics.
'He advocates a 'sustained and consistent approach that does not get caught in partisan politics”.”
PPTA have called for better invention strategies so students get the support they need before it comes to suspension and expulsion.
'This is consistent with the New Zealand Post Primary Teachers' Association / Te Wehengarua (PPTA) belief that there should be a long-term strategy for education in New Zealand, this strategy requires political consensus.
'We challenge political parties to work together to develop a collaborative national process that supports constructive educational change.”
Jason says the Ministry of Education's stand-downs, suspensions; exclusions and expulsion rates do not in themselves identify the causes for the behaviours, which are often wider societal issues.
'Once the ‘punishment' is over, the reintegration into their original school, or moving to a new school, can cause challenges for students, teachers and schools given that resourcing is so tight and avenues of help are so few, if they exist at all. There are some serious concerns for the country to grapple with.
'The level of stand-downs, suspensions, exclusions and expulsions will vary amongst schools as each year the student cohort changes, bringing their own demands and challenges.”
He says the varying levels also reflect the different approaches and philosophies of individual schools in this region.
'Gluckman had no response to a question about the self-governing structure of New Zealand schools working against neither system-wide responses nor the Tomorrow's Schools model.
'The report in itself is a positive step for New Zealand youth but the question remains whether key stakeholders can work cooperatively toward creating a new reality for young people.”



13 comments
Bring back corporal punishment
Posted on 22-10-2011 16:44 | By KiwiSteve
If out of line students get 'six of the best', I bet less will have to be stood down, suspended or expelled! - and I reckon the cops will be dealing with less youth crime as well!
Tough and Ruthless or Rough and Toothless...
Posted on 22-10-2011 18:53 | By bigted
Teachers have become 'toothless tigers'. Having no authority in the classroom means students can behave as they wish, without consequences. Contrast that with some cultures where being at school is a priviledge!
Maybe, just maybe
Posted on 23-10-2011 00:06 | By tibs
Perhaps the teachers could play a part in teaching the pupils to be better people. I have no doubt that they enjoy teaching all the liberal, "it's your right to..." stuff but I figure they may go short on teaching the obligations that go with those things. All rights, but no responsibilities.
Here we go again!
Posted on 23-10-2011 13:40 | By peterin
And there it is, another ill-informed opinion from someone who clearly has little or no involvement with the education sector, yet assumes more than they are entitled to. When was the last time you were at the chalk-face tibs? Teachers spend their life teaching and modelling correct values, attitudes and ethics. We practically bring some of these kids up due to the short-falls of certain parents.Yet another role added to responsibilities of the classroom teacher. If you are going to 'figure' anything, I suggest you pluck up the courage to visit your local schools and then make an informed decision.
Muzza
Posted on 23-10-2011 15:54 | By Muzza
Yep, everyone including the likes of Tibs a bloody expert because they once went to school so know what it takes and what to do! Studies show that the quality of teaching is an important factor, but what is even more vital is the quality of parenting. Meanwhile those Asian students, with strong supportive families who value educational attainment, come to our schools in NZ and do well.
Punishment of Sorts and Respect
Posted on 23-10-2011 15:55 | By tabatha
The day Tomorrows Schools was introduced the NZ education system started to go down hill. Peer appraisal of teachers by their collegues in the same school let some of the excellent teachers go, also the day corporal punishment went and nothing very concrete was put in its place caused ill discipline. Heard recently where a reliever was told to go and get f.... No follow up happened. Parents need to be held to account. Made to come and get child from school and supervise them, shame if they have to take time off work, might wake them up to their responsibilities. A phone call to parents by the errant child and explain over the phone in front of the teacher can bring wonders, but teachers are ham strung and not allowed to force full issues to gain the respect they had. Possible Saturday detentions could help where the child has use a few hours of their time cleaning up around the school. Yes someone has to supervise but I bet the number of problems will lower when parents who want to go away or the child wants to play sport can not until the detention is complete.
ITS MY RIGHT TO ...
Posted on 24-10-2011 13:35 | By ANNA KISSED
Attitude is the core of the problem, it is not the teachers job to educate a child in good behaviour, good manners, respect for ones self and of course others. The job begins and ends in the home and no where else. However now we find messed up homes and of course all the troubles there are dilivered to the classroom on a 'to hard' basis by parents. Kiwisteve, yes you are right 'six of the best' in a public forum is what is needed to connect to two dots on the page for little Jonny; the dot that says do wrong, disobey etc and the other dot that says 'pain'. This plague is the start of it all, you instill into children the idea that they can do what they want whennever they feel like it, take what they want whenever. End result everyone else pays. It is so simple Tibs, with privoledge comes responsibility, the later should be taught and learn first 'before' the next part 'I want ...' happens.
TEACHERS
Posted on 25-10-2011 17:23 | By WORMTONGUE
I am worried about the teachers becasue the environment at schools is getting tougher to manage, definitely more stress in the work place to deal with every day. Kids with some really bad problems at home like drugs and more. It is not in a teachers realm to remdy that, these are parenting problems that are repeating through the generations. Perhaps a good answer is that teachers need to have a different job to start with to harden them up a bit so as to deal with these things alot better.
HARDEN UP JIUCE NEEDED
Posted on 25-10-2011 23:14 | By SCOTT NUFFIN4U
Teachers generally have a real problem and it is important to remember when any of them are talking, none of them have actually ever left school since say 3-4 years old. That means that they are basically "social believers" and in fact nothing better than the teachers of "I want brigade". Yes Wormtobgue send them all out to get a real job first so they then appreciate the reality of life, then let them teach us kids!
ALL THEY NEED IS DISCIPLINE
Posted on 26-10-2011 03:51 | By PLONKER
And of course a little bit of respect for others, once learned that then a lot of problems will settle out. I agree that the only option now is to expell kids and all that does is put them out on the street to do more of what they were expelled for, how silly is that! Not an answer at all but the only one available.
THRE IS NO
Posted on 26-10-2011 15:09 | By SCOTT NUFFIN4U
If there was then there would be a reluctance to repeat offend. Simple concept of conforming is that it feels better than not conforming. With some kids who learn quickly to grasp fully the idea of "I want" who need to learn that ignoring all others for that has a price to pay, that price will end up being a short and swift kick in the butt. Sadly that concept has long since left the room, the results speak for themselves now for all these "do gooders, woofle, hippy types who just need to grow up a bit, well actually a lot!
LIFE OF A TEACHER
Posted on 27-10-2011 00:10 | By PLONKER
The obvious here is that they never have left school, they then act accordingly and without a grasp of really matters. If all you say is "naughty Jane ..." then Jane will ignore you right.
TIME A SCHOOL
Posted on 30-10-2011 17:26 | By YOGI
Is a clear indication of the mental age and of course the maturity level that allows one to then be able to leave school.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.