A Counties Manukau Police Action Plan relating to unlicenced Māori drivers was not discriminatory but ‘poorly written', says the Independent Police Conduct Authority.
Last year it was reported South Auckland police officers had been briefed not to ticket unlicenced Māori drivers, but to instead refer them to local Iwi and a community support panel.
Independent Police Conduct Authority chair Judge Sir David Carruthers. Photo: Cameron Burnell/Fairfax NZ
The authority conducted an independent investigation after a number of complaints stated the document was 'racist”, 'discriminatory” and gave Māori drivers preferential treatment.
Specifically, it investigated whether the wording of the action plan was appropriate, and if it was not appropriate, whether that was due to misconduct or neglect of duty by individual officers.
'The authority has found that while the wording of the action plan relating to unlicenced Māori drivers was not appropriate, and that the plan was created in haste and poorly written, this did not reflect the intention or application of the plan,” says the IPCA report.
'As such, it was not discriminatory. Further, this failure did not amount to misconduct or neglect of duty by individual officers.”
As written, the action plan indicated 'ALL Māori drivers”who were caught driving in breach of their licence conditions should be 'given compliance”, meaningthey would be given a certain amount of time to fix the problem rather than having to pay a fine or be prosecuted.
Authority chair Judge Sir David Carruthers says although the investigation found the policy was intended to be applied at an officer's individual discretion, regardless of race, the wording of the action plan was not appropriate as it contradicted this intention.
'The poorly written action plan did not override the fact that traffic compliance is available to any driver, regardless of race,” says Sir David.
Counties Manukau Police have since amended the wording of the action plan to accurately reflect its intent.



4 comments
Hmmmm
Posted on 17-06-2016 09:58 | By How about this view!
This just goes to prove that Maori claims of discrimination are all wrong after all. The problem is that facts and figures are just being misinterpreted and in certain cases the law doesn't apply to them at all.
What is it then?
Posted on 17-06-2016 11:03 | By waiknot
If it's not racist, discriminating, negligent or misconduct. Then it must be incompetent. The officer has clearly been promoted beyond his capabilities.
Yeah right
Posted on 17-06-2016 11:05 | By BullShtAlert
Sounds like one of those billboards for a certain brand of beer. Why isn't racism called out across the board? It is great to know the next time anyone is caught by the Police they will be given a second chance regardless of race. I can't wait to try it and see what actually happens.
Rastus
Posted on 17-06-2016 12:38 | By rastus
Nothing new here - about fifteen years ago I made a comment to a member of the law as to why there were so many unwarranted and un licensed cars in the Manakau centre car park - he told me that they had been instructed to give the cars a miss because they belonged to people who could not afford to warrant or register - you go figure!
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.