Regional Council staff are combing through the hundreds of pages of the Rena decision this week removing a misspelling of ‘Motiti' as in Motiti Island.
Motiti is officially spelled without macrons, something made clear to the Regional Council 18 months ago in a direction by Environment Court Judge Jeff Smith, in accordance with the wishes of the island residents.
Motiti's outstanding natural character is without macrons.
Regional Council communications advisor Sue-Ellen Craig attributes the re-macronisation of Motiti throughout the Rena decision and the council's Regional Policy Statement to a computer error.
'We don't know how that happened because as a council we are aware that Motiti doesn't have macrons.
'I can guess that it was probably done on a computer that had the automatic macron thing, and it's added them all in. That's been amended and the document's been changed, and an apology's been sent through to the chair of the Motiti Rohe Moana Trust.”
The Regional Council was given 10 days to check the Rena Decision for facts before it was sent out to the parties. It's thought the macrons were added by whoever typed up the decision for the commissioners.
'I'm not sure how that happened,” says Sue-Ellen. 'It's a document that was generated by the commissioners before it came into us and for us it was important just to get it out so everyone was aware of what that decision was.
'In theory everybody is aware of it and it happens before anything gets released, and I know that IT has also taken off that automatic macron thing that everybody has on their computers, but it doesn't stop it like that for the commissioners. I don't know who typed that up for them.
'It's one of those things. Sometimes it's really good to have them come on automatically but other times it's not.
'So that's why it was released and little errors like that are being corrected so that there's a final document.”
The spell checking began Monday morning, and is not expected to take too long. The revised one will be uploaded to the website once all the changes have been made to it.
The official spelling of Motiti without macrons was confirmed in an order of the Environment Court dated November 13, 2014, which was a result of Maori interests taking the regional council to court over its degrading without consultation, of the Astrolabe reef's outstanding natural character in the Regional Policy Statement. The character of the reef and other nearby features was also restored.


14 comments
Overit
Posted on 04-03-2016 10:49 | By overit
Oh my God.
Hmm
Posted on 04-03-2016 11:39 | By Politically Incorrect
Funny, I seem to recall several rantings on the waste of time and effort 'macronisation' would cause. Oh look, time and money wasted on removing a macron that shouldn't even be there. Why do people in power always strive to make life more difficult than it needs to be?
gosh
Posted on 04-03-2016 11:39 | By dumbkof2
what a world shattering thing to happen
Good grief...
Posted on 04-03-2016 11:56 | By Me again
and how much is that going effect us!!! For goodness sake move on.
jmac
Posted on 04-03-2016 12:27 | By JohnMac
If any person has their name spelt wrong they will of course move to correct it and the same applies here. If it is wrong then make it right. These documents and records relate to legal action and should be correct.
an early April fools joke?
Posted on 04-03-2016 12:42 | By Captain Sensible
Yes, we must strictly adhere to the traditional maori alphabet and spelling... what they used before the europeans arrived. Is this an early April fools joke?
@JohnMac
Posted on 04-03-2016 13:09 | By morepork
You are correct. But it simply shows what an expensive nonsense it is. It also throws more confusion into the ring regarding macron use. It's like the name "Death" being separated to "De'Ath" or Hyacinth Bucket insisting on "Bouqet". Macrons are supposed to help with correct pronunciation. If the people concerned don't want them, then they have a right not to have them, but they can't expect everyone to know by telepathy what their preference is. If there HADN'T been an Academic move to macronise Te Reo, a whole lot of time, energy, and money could have been saved.
What's that smell?....
Posted on 04-03-2016 16:03 | By Jimmy Ehu
Good god!!, it's a money making macron, how bloody stupid, surely the people complaining have been able to view the first document and say something then, and I thought we were done with the macron thing.
what next
Posted on 04-03-2016 17:02 | By Lone Star
OMG when will these people stop. Someone in this Trust is making a lot of money under the pretence of representing the islanders.
Easy easy
Posted on 04-03-2016 20:48 | By Humpdy Do
Open the document. Press Ctrl H (find-replace) In the find box type Motiti with the macron In the replace box type Motit without the macron Press 'Replace All' Within 0.001 seconds all the Motiti's with macrons are all replaced by Motiti's without macrons. Any problems, just ask a 9 year old to show you :-)
English or Maori?
Posted on 05-03-2016 08:56 | By Bay Citizen
Most of the discussions around macrons and "correct" pronunciations miss the point. When I speak, I am (usually) speaking English, not Maori. This includes place names just as well as other words. A degree of Anglicisation is perfectly acceptable, just as we write Cologne for Koln (and don't bother with its umlaut) or say Paris rather than "paree" like the French. If Maori place names are used in an English context, then we are speaking English, and ought not to pretend we are speaking Maori for that one word in a desperate attempt to be PC.
What Rubbish is This
Posted on 05-03-2016 11:42 | By carpedeum
For goodness sake - is there not a better way to spend your time and our money!!! Maori was a not even a written language when the settlers arrived . PURE PC RUBBISH
Bay Citizen.........
Posted on 05-03-2016 12:13 | By groutby
...I understood some of your comment, the rest I took to Google for a "please explain"..:)..and yes, in particular the last sentence..you and many others will have noticed radio and in particular television announcers pronounce a place name in such a different way I don't even think Te Reo speakers will know what or where it is!..usually I suspect after the compulsory and regular Te Reo lessons held by their employer..
Groutby...
Posted on 06-03-2016 10:39 | By Bay Citizen
Ironically, you provide a good example of this bizarre mix of English and Maori by your use of "Te Reo". In English, one might ask "Do you speak Maori?". To say: "Do you speak Te Reo?" is just as wrong as if one were to ask someone: "Do you speak francais?"
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.