Bay's tsunami shelter costs rise

The tsunami refuge platform planned for Papamoa's Gordon Spratt Reserve will cost an extra $734,000 because the land underneath it would turn to putty in the event of a major earthquake.

Tauranga city councillors are today being asked to approve additional construction costs for the $1,034,000 evacuation infrastructure.


The cost of Papamoa's tsunami refuge platform is set to rise. Photo: File.

As well as extra funds for the raised earth platforms, council is being asked to pay an extra $300,000 for three new escape bridge foundations.

The reason behind the extra costs relates to ground conditions, which is suffering from greater-than-expected liquefaction and lateral spread issues.

The Gordon Spratt Reserve VES (vertical evacuation structure) was brought forward in January this year, as it was believed it could be accelerated without incurring additional costs from other projects. The price was originally set at $566,000.

However, the ‘geotechnical constraints' were identified during the design and tender phase of the project, which was completed in November.

The same ground conditions were encountered during the NZ Transport Agency's construction of the Tauranga Eastern Link. Papamoa East is a layer of sand over a former swamp, and liquefaction would likely be a major problem in a decent-sized earthquake.

Any sufficiently large pile of dirt, such as a 6-7 metre VES platform, would risk sinking into the ground unless ground water is squeezed out from underneath first.

The same ground conditions and associated increased costs are likely to be found at the VES localities planned for Wairakei East ($390,000) and Wairakei West ($764,000).

The escape platforms, which would need to accommodate thousands of people, also need to cover more area than originally expected, with original evacuation planning carried out before the introduction of Special Housing Areas.

The increased population will need to be taken into account in the final designs for VES East, West and South.

Council's Long Term Plan (LTP) budget does not take any increase in costs associated with special housing areas into account.

Building all tsunami escape infrastructures was originally budgeted at $2.9 million, with $1.1 million to be spent over the first three years of the LTP and a further $800,000 in 2019. The rest is set to be spent in 2021.

Another option put to councillors today is to buy more land – an option that will be discussed in the confidential section of the meeting.

11 comments

OH DEAR

Posted on 03-12-2015 12:35 | By The Caveman

A little local knowledge goes a long way. 50 years ago the whole area behind the sand dunes along the beach was swamp and subject to flooding after any reasonable rain fall. The swamp might have been drained sufficiently to allow building of houses etc, BUT the underlying substructure is still swamp like with a water table just below the surface. Any substantial seismic activity is likely to cause liquefaction over a large area. A bit of a dirt mound possibly sinking in the "swamp" is the least of their worries.


Stupidity multiplied

Posted on 03-12-2015 13:21 | By Annalist

It was stupid to spend anything on a "tsunami platform." Those who choose to live near sea-level accept the very very very small risk, and if a tsunami is predicted head for the hills anyway in case the platform is too low??? I think it's the bible that says the wiseman builds his house upon the rock. Those who do so on sand accept the consequences.


Don't let facts get in the way!

Posted on 03-12-2015 15:28 | By Anbob

Recently completed TCC flood maps don


Due diligence.

Posted on 03-12-2015 16:09 | By Mackka

Does no one on the council know the meaning of 'due diligence' The very idea of a huge platform on shaky ground, to house thousands of people is ludicrous! Ask the Christchurch crowd what they think of the idea and you'll hear the laughing from here!


Water levels

Posted on 03-12-2015 17:27 | By Towball

Are predicted to rise by 0.8-1.8mtrs by 2020 & this was announced at a global summit meeting last year in which representatives from NZ attended . Has been acknowledged by parliament already & was on parliamentary tv for the whole nation to see. Suggest you stock up on sandbags & floaties.


Sucked in

Posted on 03-12-2015 18:33 | By Kenworthlogger

Looks like the council has been sucked in on spending money o tsunami rubbish because the locals want to have their cake and eat it too. PAPAMOA RESIDENTS ITS SIMPLE? TO BE SAFE FROM TSUNAMI DO NOT LIVE BY THE SEA AND IF YOU CHOOSE TO DONT WHINGE?


Tell me I am imagining this

Posted on 03-12-2015 20:26 | By ROCCO

The platform will be bloody useless and at a cost of $1 to $2 million the project is obscene as TCC could have installed 10 practical useful air raid sirens for $200000 Dah.Who the hell floats this garbage and why do Councillors gobble it hook line and sinker.


Time for a sea change

Posted on 04-12-2015 14:42 | By flashmedallion

What a waste of public money. Who ever heard of a Tsunami platform anyway. The council should be forward thinking - instead of raising up the land level we should be lowering the sea level in the immediate vicinity of Papamoa, which would be far more sustainable in the long term and would also make it easier to collect bottom-dwelling seafoods.


Platforms?

Posted on 05-12-2015 13:17 | By Crash test dummies

Yes a really dumb idea, just look at what happened in japan, the sea walls, plans and all failed because they under-predicted the effects of a Tsunami. The only answer is to get to high ground as fast as can. That is what mother nature taught its followers, in the 26/12/2004 Tsunami, very few animals died, they moved rapidly to high grounds and survived.


Money wasted

Posted on 05-12-2015 13:20 | By Crash test dummies

Stacking dirt, sand and whatever in a pile will only be washed away by the tsunami, that is if it has not already been demolished by liquefaction caused by the initial earthquakes that happen before the Tsunami arrives (remember Japan ...) most embankments, walls and so on were overrun, dissolved, wiped out. get real people, the only solution here is to look after yourselves and get to high ground.


News Flash

Posted on 06-12-2015 01:50 | By Crash test dummies

there are already massive Tsunami platforms already, the TEL and the soon to be fly overs + the existing ones provide a raft of options for the public to head upwards by a good margin. They are all higher than any dirt and sand infill scam that TCC is thinking about. TCC is just wasting more money and time entertaining more crazy ideas from within the back rooms of City hall. This crazy behavior is in the loony-tunes department, like they ever left?


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.