Appeal dismissed for GBH convict

A man sentenced to eight-and-a-half years jail for the brutal beating of his flatmate in Whangamata has had his appeal in the Supreme Court dismissed.

Following a jury trial in Tauranga District Court in August 2014, Shane James Old was convicted on one count of causing grievous bodily harm and assaulting a police officer with the intent to obstruct him in the execution of his duty.


Photo: File.

On November 14, 2014, he was sentenced to prison by Judge Peter Rollo.

Old turned to the Supreme Court after the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal against his conviction of causing grievous bodily harm.

In a ruling released this week, the Supreme Court granted Old an extension of time after he filed his application several weeks out of time.

While the court granted the time extension, Old's leave to appeal the Court of Appeal decision was dismissed.

The jury found Old guilty of beating his schizophrenic flatmate so severely that the victim later had no memory of the attack that happened on Waitangi Day, 2014.

The victim suffered a severe brain injury as a result of the attack and also suffered post-traumatic amnesia as a result of the injuries he received.

The Supreme Court ruling stated the victim had been found by an associate badly beaten in his bed.

'The victim told the associate he had been beaten by Shane Old. However, when asked by another associate what had happened, he replied that he could not remember anything,” the Supreme Court ruling says.

'The victim then told police he had been beaten up by Old and said he did not want anything done about it.”

Whilst in hospital, he gave a detailed account to another police officer of what happened, again saying Old assaulted him, and completed a written statement to the same effect the following day.

The victim suffered significant head injuries as a result of the assault.

At trial, the victim said that while he could remember waking up in hospital, he could not remember anything else, including the assault and making his statements to police.

The victim's statements were admitted into evidence.

On appeal, Old contended that the statements should not have been admitted. He argued that because of his mental condition, the victim was 'unavailable” to give evidence within the meaning of section 18 of the Evidence Act 2006.

Accordingly, the four statements in which the victim identified Old as his attacker were hearsay statements and should have been ruled inadmissible because the circumstances relating to them did not provide reasonable assurance that they were reliable.

The Court of Appeal rejected this contention.

It noted the victim was the first witness for the prosecution. He had been cross-examined at some length by defence counsel, who had obtained valuable answers.

In particular, when asked in the course of the cross-examination whether he believed that Old assaulted him, the victim replied: 'No. We'd been…. friends for too long for him to have done that”.

It's on these grounds that Old sought leave to appeal his conviction.

However, the Supreme Court was not satisfied it was necessary in the interests of justice to hear and determine the appeal.

'In relation to the first ground, we do not consider it raises any issue of general or public importance,” says the Supreme Court, ”nor do we consider there is any risk of a substantial miscarriage of justice.

'As the Court of Appeal recognised, a person may suffer from a mental disability that they are 'unavailable” to give evidence. The victim is in a different position, however.

'While he had little or no recollection of the details of the assault, he was able to give evidence on other relevant matters.

'Moreover, his statements identifying Old as his assailant were made shortly after the assault to three different people.”

As to the point that the prosecutor improperly cross-examined the victim by putting leading questions to him, the Crown notes this appears to be a new point and submits the Supreme Court will not usually grant leave on a ground not raised in the Court of Appeal.

'In any event, we see nothing in the point as the prosecutor was clearly entitled to put the written statement to the victim and to direct the victim's attention to particular parts of the statement.

'This does not amount to improper cross-examination.”

0 comments

Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.