Convictions against a man who beat his flatmate so badly the victim was unable to properly give evidence against him, have been upheld by the Court of Appeal.
Following a jury trial in the Tauranga District Court in August 2014, Shane James Old was convicted on one count of causing grievous bodily harm and assaulting a police officer with the intent to obstruct him in the execution of his duty.
On November 12, 2014, Old was sentenced by Judge Peter Rollo to eight and a half years jail with a minimum period of four years.
The jury found Old guilt of beating his schizophrenic flatmate so severely the victim later had no memory of the attack that happened on Waitangi Day, 2014, in Whangamata.
The victim suffered a severe brain injury as a result of the attack and also suffered post-traumatic amnesia as a result of the injuries he received.
In a statement made to police the following day, the victim identified Old as his attacker.
'Shane just attacked me. The first thing I remember him doing was kicking me in the head with his steel capped boots,” his statement reads.
'We were both sitting and he stood up and kicked me while I was sitting. I didn't get a chance to react. The kick went into the top left of my head. I went on the ground. I stayed conscious. He picked up a broom from the front door. I couldn't see how he was holding it. I just remember the bristle end hitting me in the face twice.”
In his evidence at trial the victim said he remembered waking up in hospital but nothing else.
When asked about how he got his injuries he said he supposed he had been beaten up but did not remember it.
He did not remember talking to any police officers. When he was shown the statement he had signed he recognised the signature as his but could not remember making the statement.
Old decided to appeal his conviction on the basis that the victim's physical or mental condition meant he couldn't be a witness, which rendered the statement clearly identifying his attacker as hearsay.
The Court of Appeal ruled the victim was a witness. At trial he was the first witness called by the Crown, and was cross examined at some length by defence counsel. He could not remember being attacked or who had attacked him. But he was able to answer other questions put to him, both in chief and in cross-examination.
The Court of Appeal ruled the statements were not hearsay and there are other precedents in New Zealand law where people with a deteriorating mental conditions, such as Alzheimer's or dementia, have given admissible written statements when at trial they were unable to remember.
A claim that police did not properly identify the attacker through formal procedure wasn't upheld because it would have served no useful purpose. The victim identified someone they knew very well.
'There was very little the defence could do in the face of victim naming his housemate - Mr Old - as his assailant,” ruled the Court of Appeal.
'All the defence could really do was attempt to raise a doubt by implicating someone else. The only other possible assailant was the friend who found him. The jury was able to observe the sharp and emotional response when that was suggested in cross examination.”



0 comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.