Poor diabetes care claim refuted

The Bay of Plenty District Health Board is hitting back at Diabetes NZ claims that it is not delivering a good enough service for the region's diabetic community.

In a board-by-board critique of diabetes services in New Zealand, Diabetes NZ slates the BOPDHB for having only one specialist nurse and one part-time physician to care for more than 10,000 diabetes patients in Tauranga and Whakatane.


'The current waiting list is a minimum of six months, which will inevitably impact on the risk of complications, particularly kidney failure and the risk of eye problems,” says Diabetes NZ President Chris Baty.

'There is also no specialist care for the growing number of adolescent and young adult patients with type one diabetes.”

The lack of resources will also impact on diabetes education, insulin initiation and support to GPs who have to care for patients previously seen by a diabetes specialist, says Chris.

The statement is inaccurate, says Bay of Plenty District Health Board General Manager Helen Mason.

'The DHB currently has funding in place for a full-time diabetes specialist at Tauranga Hospital as well as three diabetes nurse specialists,” says Helen.

'Additionally, Te Puna Hauora has a diabetes specialist with a specific focus on Maori.

'Furthermore, we have increased funding for diabetes annual reviews which are contracted to the PHOs in the region.”

The DHB's recent efforts are clearly marked in the board's improved performance, says Helen.

It has moved up 10 places among the 20 DHBs according to the DHB's ‘detection rates and management success of diabetes'.

The BOPDHB ranks seventh out of 20 DHBs nationally for the 2010/11 financial year.

The Ministry of Health's ‘Modelling Diabetes' report shows that diabetes contributed to one in five deaths in Maori diagnosed with diabetes.

Surveys conducted by the New Zealand Society for the Study of Diabetes and Diabetes New Zealand illustrates that district health boards across the country are making significant cut backs to diabetes specialist services while the number of people with diabetes is increasing rapidly.

The agencies say most DHBs, GP groups and diabetes centres around the country are struggling to achieve nationally and internationally agreed standards of care, despite overwhelming evidence that such treatment is both beneficial and cost-effective.

'GPs and general practice teams are stretched by the workload of the cut backs and specialist treatment for diabetes patients with complex needs has been largely neglected,” says NZSSD Medical Director Paul Drury.

'This will have an increasing and inevitable impact on diabetes diagnosis and its long-term complications – kidney failure, amputation, blindness, premature heart disease and stroke.

'The inadequacy of such services will also particularly impact on the growing number of high-risk groups including our Maori, Pacific and Asian communities who disproportionately experience these outcomes.”

New Zealand is second worst among nations studied for life years lost to diabetes, according to a recent independent OECD report.

The life years lost survey does not mention other devastating personal effects of kidney failure, amputation, blindness and early heart disease – all of which are worst in our Maori, Pacific and Indo-Asian communities, says Paul.

'We absolutely need to invest enough in quality diabetes care – both at community and specialist levels – to avoid these largely preventable disasters.

'The DHBs are largely not responding to the size and severity of the problem, especially in the upper North Island.

'Many places do not have expert podiatry, nursing, dietetic or physician services, in others they are often limited and inadequate for the fast-growing number of people with diabetes.”

The average increase in prevalence is approximately 8-9 per cent per annum over the past year with the highest growth in Auckland about 14 per cent.

2 comments

Horrible care

Posted on 06-12-2010 18:53 | By dgk

I arrived in Tauranga over 2 years ago as a Type 2 diabetic on insulin. Have only just managed to get an appointment with their diabetes specialist....I'm told this is normal....


Brilliant Care

Posted on 07-12-2010 12:30 | By sally green

I have Type 1 Diabetes, and cannot thank the Diabetes Nurses enough for their care! They have kept me alive, despite continual setbacks with the service, and are always cheerful despite the pressure put on them by the health Service. I think people need to be a bit more sympathetic, and support what we do have, before we lose that as well!!!


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.