Employee jailed for $370K theft

Dionne Guinness, better known as Spotty, was the office lady at Sportcraft Marine for over nine years, and that was all the time she needed to siphon $372,000 from the company.

Today she was sentenced to two-and-a-half years in jail when she appeared in Tauranga District Court after pleading guilty to 11 counts of fraud.


Jamie Black says the team at Sportcraft Marine are like a tight-knit family. He feels betrayed by what Guinness (inset) has done.

The charges included four counts of theft by a person in a special relationship, three counts of obtaining by deception, and one count each of using a document for pecuniary advantage, using a forged document and altering a document with intent.

Guinness pleaded guilty to the charges in court last November and has been in custody ever since.

She was due to be sentenced in December, but this was delayed to allow time for her house to be considered to help pay back some of the money she owes.

Sportcraft Marine owner Jamie Black says they are devastated by Guinness' deception.

'We have a good team at Sportcraft and care deeply for our staff,” says Jamie. 'We are a company that is like a family.”

He says Guinness betrayed their trust in her.

'We treated her like family,” he adds. 'She had worked with us for nine years and had been stealing right off the bat. It was just small amounts here and there and they slowly got bigger.

'She knew things were tight financially and still stole from us when we had to lay two staff off. She stole when she knew we were struggling and she did not care about the other 11 staff and their families who could lose their livelihood.”

Jamie says he felt obliged to the staff and they are a good team that has kept the business going.

The theft was discovered last year when the Blacks questioned where a GST return had gone. Jamie was waiting for the return but never saw the money.

Their accountant brought to their attention some discrepancies in the accounts and revealed where some cheques that Guinness had been given to bank had gone.

Jamie described it as opening 'pandora's box”. Once they went to the police about Guinness' offending, much more was discovered.

'Police found she had taken around double of what we knew about,” says Jamie

'The incriminating evidence was a file that she had left in the office after she had left."

Jamie says they are like a family at Sportcraft Marine and to have her come to work and steal from them is devastating.

'We have never had an apology from her or her family,” he adds. 'We have been made to feel like she is the victim when actually we are the victims.

'We have a great team and a lot of good loyal customers, and it is through their help that we have been able to get through this and look forward to a good long-term future.”

In court today, Judge Christopher Harding sentenced Guinness to two-and-a-half years in jail.

He also made a reparation order for $300,000 to be paid within 60 days.

'I know this is not the full amount stolen and that there is a slim chance this will be paid in the timeframe given,” said Judge Harding.

Using a house that Guinness had bought a year ago was being disputed because she claims it is a leaking home and it would cost more than it is worth to fix it. The house is valued at $240,000 to $300,000.

Judge Harding didn't accept this, saying that there was no evidence to prove if the house was a leaky home.

He said: 'Chances of recovery are slim to none and that you (Guinness) are hopelessly insolvent.”

In making the order, Judge Harding hopes Guinness' house will be looked at in depth as a means of regaining some of the money stolen.

Speaking to SunLive after the sentencing, Jamie says they are disappointed with the outcome but are happy she has gone to jail.

'There is no remorse,” he says. 'If she was remorseful she wouldn't be fighting to keep her house.

'She is going back to university - that's all she does.”

The team at Sportcraft Marine will now turn their attentions to getting what money they can back and looking at ways to keep their business afloat.

11 comments

What?

Posted on 18-02-2015 16:39 | By Theway

Judge Christopher Hardin made a reparation order for $300,000 to be paid within 60 days! But Judge Robert Wolff ruled that no reparation could be made to Triac Lighting, Sound and Visual Hire when convicting Lesley Hunt for the same offence! Why the double standard???


Justice

Posted on 18-02-2015 18:24 | By Mitas

Yes it does not seem fair at all. I was at Court when Leslie Hunt was sentencing. And she doesn,t have to pay back a cent. Her car is up for sale and husband will be reaping in the profits once. Sold. As far as I am concern its thieft.


Sad Times

Posted on 18-02-2015 19:44 | By Twinkle Toes

I feel so sorry for the team at Sportcraft Marine. It's so sad you have trust in someone and they do this to you. I wish you all the best in your business and if I was rich enough I'd give you a helping hand.


stone cold theft

Posted on 18-02-2015 21:31 | By mount man

People like this should have to pay the full amount back. And have a longer jail term lock her up for the amount of years she stole from them.


Re: What?

Posted on 19-02-2015 04:21 | By Ziggy

I just read up on the Lesley Hunt conviction and I agree that it is difficult to understand why the two reparation orders are so different. It's like a lottery - one judge says it has to be paid back, the other says it doesn't. There must be more to it mustn't there???


Accountability

Posted on 19-02-2015 20:58 | By mugs

This is the 4th or 5th big staff fraud in Tauranga in recent years and is happening a lot more throughout the country. Surely management today implement safety measures to prevent this happening. The manager in this case stated it had been going on for 9 years! Surely management need to take some responsibility for allowing this to continue for years!


What about the family?

Posted on 20-02-2015 04:33 | By Ziggy

I just read on the herald that she wrote company cheques to family members. They must have known surely??!! Didn't friends and family wonder how an office administrator could afford a new car, new house and overseas trip including yaught hire. Those family members must have know, especially the ones that received cheques. In my book they would be just as guilty for not doing the right thing


What about the family

Posted on 20-02-2015 16:04 | By YEP

Just because you read it in the PRESS you think you have the whole story, well you are wrong and the POLICE investigation proves it. DON'T comment until you really know the FACTS.


@ YEP

Posted on 21-02-2015 15:25 | By theschizzle

The POLICE investigation would be the basis of the charges laid against the offender. Turns out that this offender plead guilty to the charges. What FACTS are too difficult for you to understand about that???


FIRE

Posted on 23-02-2015 10:00 | By YEP

The fire has gone out.


Foolish business owners

Posted on 24-02-2015 14:00 | By maildrop

Very important to have internal procedures and checks. Trust nobody with you money.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.