The proposal to make New Zealand a smokefree country by 2025 is being met by a mixed response with a Tauranga smokefree therapist suggesting there is a long way to go and such a plan is 'unrealistic”.
On Thursday, Associate Minister of Health Tariana Turia proposed stricter legislation around the sale of tobacco and measures prohibiting the display of tobacco in shops.
New Zealand Heart Foundation has welcomed the move and medical director Dr Norman Sharpe says it's about catching up with the rest of the world.
'It's a positive and progressive move,” says Norman.
'We're catching up with countries that have already put these measures into place.
'Australia has been working on a retail display ban for some time.
'We don't want to punish people who smoke, but it's about changing the environment our children grow up in and the retail ban will certainly help that.”
Tauranga nurse Monica Walker founded Smokefree 4 Good. It is an organisation that helps people give-up smoking.
She says making New Zealand smokefree would be 'unrealistic” and 'very, very hard”.
'We have a very strong addiction to deal with.
'No matter how high the price goes, people are still smoking.
'The hardcore smokers who don't want to give up will find other means to buy cigarettes,” she says.
Dr Sharpe agrees but says that shouldn't stop the government trying to do something about the number of smokers in New Zealand.
'They will find other ways to get cigarettes. It'll happen, but this is about de-normalising smoking behaviours.”



15 comments
Punishing Smokers??
Posted on 06-11-2010 12:38 | By copyman
Smokers are punishing themselves by stuffing up their lungs etc. The residue of cigarettes is smoke and everyone in the immediate vicinty cops it. I like drinking beer and you know what the residue of that is. Am I allowed to spread it around on everyone?? David Mansford.
Great Idea...
Posted on 06-11-2010 14:07 | By bryceh
What a stupid response from copyman!! Although i am a smoker, I completely agree with the plan and support it! In fact the government could realise the goal much sooner if they BANNED tobacco completely. The problem is though that they wont do that because of all the tax money they will lose out on! To compare smoking with drinking beer, is pathetic. Drinkers cause more problems in society than smokers do, and any scientific study will confirm that!
Addition
Posted on 06-11-2010 14:10 | By The author of this comment has been removed.
I also said it's a good incentive! Any effort will help to a certain degree but it would be better if the govt spent the funds they're allocating to smoking cessation programs on treatments and methods that actually work. Monica Walker
Lip service, the appearance of trying ...
Posted on 06-11-2010 14:26 | By Murray.Guy
Local Authorites, Central Government pay lip service only. A few graphic pictures on a packet of cancer destroyed lungs, up the price and increase their GST take, put at risk shop staff - all the easy stuff. Throw money at companies that produce patches, advertizing. I've tried unsuccessfully to date for Tauranga City Council to put in place a bylaw that makes it illegal to smoke (put at risk) in areas adjacent to or within 'fixed seating' areas (EG: Stadiums), childrens playgrounds. I gave up smoking myself (finally, NOT because of the damage to my health, but mindful of the example I was showing to our communities youth, my own grandchildren, and the potential impact on THEIR health. My main issue with smoking is that other are expected to 'pick up the tab' when ill health results, others are expected to tolerate or have to move when their air and nose is offended. We could do more that secured better outcomes for ALL, smokers and non-smokers, that cost a helliva lot less, but for the fact that it's easier for polititions to spend other folks money that do their job, make the sometimes unpopular calls!
Unrealistic indeed!
Posted on 06-11-2010 15:43 | By optimistic1
It would indeed be a wonderful thing to live in a smoke free country, but really, how realistic is that..if you choose to make it illegal to smoke cigarettes because of the damage to health, wouldn't the next step be to ban alcohol as isn't that too damaging in the wrong hands. I don't see how a distinction can be made between the two. How can politicians take away a person's right to smoke if they choose to. Don't get me wrong, I would be incredibly happy to live in a smoke free country, I just can't see how it could ever be implemented.I was a smoker for 30 odd years, tried many times to quit. Two and a half years ago I met Monica when she was running a competition on the radio to win a free session on her magical stop smoking machine. No cigarette has passed my lips since that day. As someone who has tried every method available to quit, this is the only thing that worked, and I know that I will never smoke again. I believe that what Monica offers should be subsidised by the government, as it is 100% more effective than patches or gum. Both my daughters and I are very thankful to Monica, she literally changed my life overnight.
Hmmm
Posted on 06-11-2010 16:19 | By Politically Incorrect
Why don't they just incrementally increase the legal age to buy cigarettes? Every year, put the age up a year. That way, no one who currently smokes is 'punished', but accessibility to those younger folk who may be thinking of starting becomes less and less. No outright ban, just phase it out.
Catching up with the rest of the world???
Posted on 06-11-2010 16:25 | By SpeakUp
Oh yeah? Well, in many countries legislation pushed through by the smoke-free Nazis has been reverted back to accommodate individual freedom. In Holland and Germany for example smoking in pubs is permitted if the premises are below a certain size and if the pub operator allows it. To make New Zealand smoke-free smells of totalitarianism. Not even Hitler, a non-smoker and Vegetarian tried to push such dictatorial agendas. STOP TO REGULATE EVERY ASPECT OF PUBLIC AND PRIVATE LIFE! We don't need politicians to tell us how we should live. If Tariana's Maori buddies can't make wise individual decisions for themselves then why doesn't she go and preach to them? NB: I am a non-smoker.
I absolutely agree
Posted on 06-11-2010 23:06 | By optimistic1
that tobacco advertising should be banned..but cigarettes are a multi billion dollar industry, and we all know money talks. Absolutely, make the age 20 to buy cigarettes 25 if they can get away with it..if it makes it hard for some, then so be it. Its heartbreaking to see a young child smoking..it should never happen..thankfully my teenage girls don't smoke. I'm so glad that Im no longer a slave to the dreaded weed (the legal kind that is ;)
Baypark Sat night!
Posted on 07-11-2010 14:53 | By Murray.Guy
Guessing 10-11,000 folk in the stands at Baypark overnight, with a huge proportion being families, teenagers. Hands up those who truly believe those affected by smokers should have to move out of the stands to avoid the smoke. Hands up those who support the right of an adult to enjoy a cigarete, but not at the cost of the health of those around them. Definetly past time to ban smoking in fixed seating 'public areas'.
ex retailer
Posted on 07-11-2010 16:20 | By tmc
I sold my retail store 10 years ago and the government was threatening to make stores cover up displays then. 10 years down the track and they are all still highly visible. Get them out of sight (hopefully out of mind) and as Monica suggests, spend some of the tax earned on cessation programs that actually work.
I agree
Posted on 07-11-2010 16:24 | By judy kaye
Make it harder Now to buy tobacco. I look forward to Smokefree by 2025. I wished i had never smoked... It is truly sad to see young people smoking.
Regulating private life
Posted on 07-11-2010 19:12 | By bileve
The damage of alcohol abuse versus the damage of cigarette smoke is comparatively drastic, I would say. Yet, both are private choices. Which choice though does drag others with them completely out of the blue and much too often? I guess, everybody would agree that this can be answered with alcohol abuse. I wonder when we can receive an honost statistic about the profit of alcohol versus the damage it causes. Nevertheless, I agree to the human right to choose one's private lifestyle. I like the option of free choice once broad education and not once-sided ones can be offered. Tax-earned money can be spent on multi-levelled and free education programs on health issues, such as smoking, drinking, and food. And I am not talking about obesitiy issues, I am talking about the lack of nutrients in the soils due to export demands. So, I advocate free choises along with free education and much less advertising on tabacco, alcohol and food.
what a joke
Posted on 08-11-2010 10:12 | By Donnaw
I find it extreamly amusing that people think that someone is not going to smoke just becasue the govt puts a nasty picture on a packet or hides the displays....come on people....this is a addictive drug, you dont see meth advertised, yet there are so many people addicted to it! I too am a smoker and would do intend to give up, but i am addicted to it, plan and simple....im not going to quit smoking just becasue someone says i should, the only reason i will give up is when i am ready and commited to it. i also find is amusing that we are no longer allowed to smoke in pubs etc (which i agree with), but when you go out, its so hard to find an outside seat because it is full of non-smokers, and as soon as you light up...you get a dirty look...but if you dont like it shouldnt you be sitting in a non-smokeing area. The taxes we pay on smokes should go back into helping people quit, so their children dont grow up watching mum and dad smoke thinking this is okay...monkey see...monkey do!
Something to Consider
Posted on 08-11-2010 11:43 | By RangiB
I am smoker and I think that what the government is trying to achieve is a excellent positive step towards a better future for everyone. I have attempted to quit a number of times and have always failed, however I am planning to quit again and quit for good this time. Like with any substance abuse what really needs to be addressed is the underlying factors as to why people smoke no different than an alcoholic or someone that smokes cannabis. It's those underlying factors that tend to keep people hooked. For me one of the biggest reasons I've always given in is because I've always been scared to gain weight and have people judge me for gaining that weight, hearing those snide remarks or the looks some people give you and that doesn't make it any easier. Too many in our society judge people by their looks and for me and the place I am at right now and my decision to quit is that "I honestly don't give a stuff what people think" I'm doing it for me and I know I'm worth it!! I'd like those that are planning to quit and can relate to what I'm talking about to stay strong and try to remember that you are worth something no matter what people say or do to you. How many of us enjoy overcoming obstacles and feeling pride in ourselves for overcoming those obstacles, smoking is just another one of those obstacles. Try to learn to love yourselves people and you'll be surprised at what you can achieve.
smoke free
Posted on 08-11-2010 12:04 | By tuhuamaid
I agree with Monica Walker. Time, money and effort must be put into proven, permanent methods for smoking cessation. One session with Bioresonance therapy at Smokefre4good worked for me. I had my last cigarette, after 40 years smoking, just before the therapy. Patches and gum do not help the smoker quit as they are still "needing" and absorbing / ingesting the nicotine.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.