Bay baby’s death undetermined

A Bay of Plenty coroner is urging further education on babies' sleeping positions following an investigation into the death of a three-month-old.

In a ruling released this week, Coroner Wallace Bain found the cause of death of the three-month-old Taupo child is undetermined.


The baby was put to sleep on her stomach with her head turned to one side - this is known as the prone position.

The baby, who along with the parents cannot be named, died in Taupo on August 24, 2011 after being found unresponsive by her parents three hours after she was put down from her 6am feed.

'I find that Baby A's direct cause of death is undetermined and described as sudden unexplained death in infancy against a background of prone sleeping on a pillow.”

During a hearing on February 14, 2014, Detective Gavin MacKay gave evidence about the police investigation into the infant's death.

Gavin told the court that Baby A was breastfed about 6am and then put back in her bassinet on her tummy with her head facing on one side and one a pillow.

'This was considered by the mother to be the normal sleeping position as it was the only way she could get the baby to settle and sleep,” says Wallace in his report. At 9.45am the baby was found in an unresponsive state, taken to hospital and was declared dead.

Gavin confirmed that when the mother was spoken to she said the only way she knew to get the baby to sleep was to put her down in a prone position and on a pillow. A prone sleeping position is a baby sleeping on its tummy.

'Police carried out a full investigation into the death and formed a view that Baby A was well cared for, breastfed well and had bonded with her mother.” Wallace says the parents were young and had their own problems, but were described as good parents.

'The sleeping prone position was an issue raised by Plunket and CYFS during the police investigation. They said current studies suggested sleeping prone is a risk for SIDS and the agencies recommended against it.

'The court recommends the Ministry of Health continue public health advice in relation to safe infant sleeping practices and safe sleeping environments, and in particular re-emphasising the dangers of prone sleeping.”

0 comments

Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.