A Tauranga doctor who claims he was bullied in the workplace is to receive $7500 from the BOP District Health Board after it was found he was unjustifiably dismissed.
The Employment Relations Authority has ordered the DHB to pay psychologist Dr Paul Hirini for breaching its obligations in investigating the complaint he was bullied.
The report released today says the DHB didn't take reasonably practical steps to keep the doctor safe while the investigation was underway and suspended him unfairly during the course of the investigation.
'He wasn't given an opportunity to comment on allegations about him before they were put to the New Zealand Psychologists Board,” says ERA.
Dr Paul Hirini started working for the BOPDHB in March 2009 in the specialist Infant, Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service at Tauranga Hospital.
He was part of a multidisciplinary team which included a team leader, a nurse, an occupational therapist, a social worker, and a psychiatric registrar.
On January 18, 2012, Dr Hirini submitted a report saying he had been bullied in the workplace.
The doctor said the bullying was in response to an opinion he gave on a case file during a team meeting earlier that day.
Dr Hirini accused a member of the team of being aggressive and belittling him.
The Authority says the team leader not only failed to curtail the occupational therapist's behaviour, but also supported it.
'The REF[report] said the threats and criticism were part of an overall pattern of bullying, but no other incidents were identified.”
In a second report was filed in February 2012 saying the behaviour comprising the ‘overall pattern of bullying'.
The allegations centred on behaviour by the same two team members.
Dr Hirini reported feeling excluded from the team when returning from a sports injury. He also cited an unfair number of crisis duties in that period.
All parties met to discuss the allegations and both team members denied the accusations during an interview in April.
They then accused Dr Hirini of being aggressive and having intimidating behaviour towards them.
In a letter dated May 16, 2012, Dr Hirini was provided with details of their allegations.
'He was informed he was suspended while an investigation was conducted, although the parties later agreed he would work from home,” says the ERA report.
Concerns were expressed about aspects of Dr Hirini's case management. The BOPDHB sought to meet on May 4 to discuss these concerns.
Dr Hirini declined to attend the meeting until he had better information about the nature and content of the concerns, and sought access to his case files so he could work on updating them.
On May 4 the BOPDHB advised Dr Hirini he was to have no further contact with patients until after the meeting.
Dr Hirini then resigned as a result of all of the events.
ERA member Rosemary Monaghan found Dr Hirini was constructively dismissed due to the number of breaches made by the BOPDHB and that dismissal was unjustified.
He sought reimbursement of lost wages and $20,000 for compensation to his injuries.
ERA ordered Dr Hirini be reimbursed for three months loss of wages and paid $7500 for injury to his feelings.
Costs are reserved.



3 comments
The Don
Posted on 04-12-2013 15:24 | By don archer
What gets me is that the Dr. gets suspended while they investigate the unproven allegations against him, but the others were not suspended when there were allegations against them! Why was that?
?
Posted on 05-12-2013 08:46 | By Capt_Kaveman
sounds like a weak claim to me, god if i was paid even A $1 for every insult to my feelings in the workplace id be a millionaire by now
Agree with Capt Kaveman
Posted on 11-12-2013 12:31 | By The Sage
I'd like to get $1 for every insult I have had in the workplace. This guy is meant to be a qualified Psychologist and would have, I would think, have training in dealing with problems. If he can't sort his own out how would he help someone else? He needs a bottle of Harden Up Pills.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.