Woman shocked at pill practises

A Tauranga woman is questioning why un-used medications cannot be re-distributed after finding herself with a bag full of prescriptions which now have to be destroyed.

But a Bay of Plenty District Health Board spokesperson says while recycling medicines might seem a cost-effective way of reducing the pharmaceutical budget, there are a number of reasons why medicines must not be recycled.


Bethlehem resident Mirella Veneziano with some of her late husband's un-opened, un-expired medicines that she'd like to re-distributed to someone else.

Bethlehem resident Mirella Veneziano has many un-used and un-expired prescriptions for her late husband Guido Veneziano, who died of lung cancer on September 8, 2013.

'When my husband was sick, during this time a considerable supply of prescription medicine was given for him and for myself - as I was also feeling poorly,” says Mirella.

'Naturally, not all have been used; some are still un-opened, some never used and some partially used, but left in their original container. Not one is expired or expiring any time soon.”

Mirella recently approached a nurse to ask where she could take them, thinking they must be able to be re-distributed to people in need.

'The answer was ‘Bring them to a pharmacy, which will arrange for the medications to be destroyed'.”

She could not believe the answer.

'This is a big waste of money, mainly money from the government, because all the medicines are subsidised.”

Moving to Tauranga five years ago, Mirella says her native country Italy has non-profit associations, which are authorised to collect un-opened, un-used medicines to re-distribute to people in need, and to people in undeveloped countries.

'My question is: Is this true? The disposing of perfectly unopened, unused, good medications, here in New Zealand? Or I had been given the wrong information?

'I really believe that the medicines are still in good condition and could be saved by being distributed to the needy and to the poor people in undeveloped countries.”

A Bay of Plenty District Health Board spokesperson says there are a number of reasons why medicines must not be recycled.

'They include storage conditions. After the medicine has left the pharmacy its conditions of storage cannot be guaranteed. Incorrect storage may cause deterioration of the medicine. In addition, contamination may have been introduced through handling of loose solid dose forms such as tablets.”

The stability of the medicine is another factor, because once it has been removed from the manufacturer's packaging, there is usually no stability data available; and batch numbers and expiry dates are often omitted when medicines are repackaged, they say.

'While this is not usually an issue on dispensed medicines, as these are prescribed for specific persons, conditions and for set time periods, if recycled that important information would not be available.”

The spokesperson also points to identity of the medicine.

'Often, it is difficult to establish beyond reasonable doubt the identity of a medicine; especially as often occurs, when medicines are transferred into other containers once the patient gets them home.

'The medicine specified on the label therefore may not be the medicine in the container.”

Lastly, it is believed there could be issues with recalling re-distributed medicines.

'Manufacturer's medicines' recalls are difficult enough to trace to the public level without introducing the problem of recycled medicines.

'The World Health Organisation ‘Guidelines for Drug Donations' requires that unused medicines returned to pharmacies are not donated for use in developing nations, even in emergency situations – on the grounds of lack of guarantee about safety, quality and continued efficacy.”

9 comments

Destroyed?

Posted on 15-10-2013 09:09 | By panda

A few years ago I had some leftover medication. I asked the pharmacy what to do with them and I was told to just put them in the rubbish bin! They said thats how they dispose of them! I was shocked. All them drugs going into landfill....it's a disgrace!


Shocking

Posted on 15-10-2013 11:02 | By freedomkiwis

Well.......... I think I have the answer as to the why. I wouldn't be surprised if the only reason they don't get recycled (even to third world countries in need) is probably because there is no money in it for the drug companies. Lets face it, our medications change quite often usually because another one comes on the market, with a bigger commission attached to it for the Dr. I think it's a travesty that these can't be given to an impoverished country in need. I'd be inclined to try and connect with a dr.doing VSA and send the drugs to them directly.


Better safe than sorry

Posted on 15-10-2013 11:49 | By tjs01

There is no way I would want other peoples pills. There is no way you can prove they haven't been tampered with. I don't want second hand meds.


throw them away anyway

Posted on 15-10-2013 13:23 | By the kurgan

and get on the medical marijuana, way cheaper, it works way better and the side effects are happiness.


a sensible sadness

Posted on 15-10-2013 15:13 | By sojourner

Sad but true: I have returned unused, unopened, and therefore safe to use meds to the chemist too. I also think that it is a waste of money to just throw them out. Yet, at the same time, I would be hesitant to take medication that has been who-knows-where before me, and probably wouldn't. All it takes is a needle to prick through the packaging to add something to the pill or tablet that can harm or kill. It simply is not safe.


a waste but what to do??

Posted on 15-10-2013 15:48 | By rotovend

msaybe the question is apart from the obvious what a waste why are people getting new prescriptions before they have used up what they have, possibly because meds are so cheap in this country they are taken for granted and I too would be dubious about taking tablets not specifically for me and as for medical dope that's another issue all together as with all drugs theyre are side effects


Not Surprised

Posted on 15-10-2013 17:16 | By Jitter

No wonder Pharmac's bill is so large. I cannot see why unopened sealed medications up to six months old cannot be put back into stock. This is just a criminal waste. They could certainly at least be sent overseas to impoverished countries.


@[email protected]

Posted on 15-10-2013 17:39 | By Colleen Spiro

This lady's husband passed away.....also quite often medication is often changed, so the previous one becomes redundant. I think it is very sad unsealed tablets cannot be used in poorer countries or even here.


You aint seen nothing!!

Posted on 15-10-2013 22:53 | By s83cruiser

This lady has a few packets of pills that have to be thrown away. That's nothing, Meds are thrown away by the wheelie bin full from the Pharmacy at the Tauranga Hospital. Not 1 but several at a time. Used by dates are a handy way for the manufactures to ensure that they have guaranteed turnover. The world is paranoid about "Use by dates" and "best before dates" even vacuum packed sealed and sterile equipment is thrown away from the hospital because it has a "Use By Date". Many thousands of dollars worth a year throughout the country binned because it has a use by date. Nothing wrong with it just out of date. Manufactures love the USE BY DATE guaranteed turn over.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.