Dad denied over son's 'stolen' heart

A Tauranga man's persistent claim his dead son's heart was stolen by Tauranga Hospital is unlikely to ever be heard after his latest appeal was rejected.

John Mackenzie, 80, has been fighting for years to expose what happened to his son Kenneth's heart after he died in a motorbike accident in October 1987.

Kenneth Mackenzie died in Tauranga Hospital in 1987.

In the hours after the 20-year-old's life support was turned off his heart was removed without the knowledge and consent of his family.

Kenneth's heart was taken to Greenlane Hospital in Auckland, where one of its valves was successfully transplanted into a 16-year-old girl. It is unknown what happened to the rest of the heart.

John began making inquiries of Tauranga Hospital in 2002. In 2005, Tauranga Hospital senior pathologist Doctor Ian Beer informed John that standard hospital protocol in 1987 was for natural heart valves to be sent to Greenlane, but for the heart to remain with the body.

In 2005, John was also told by the National Donor Co-ordination Office in Auckland that his son's death was before heart transplantation began in New Zealand, and therefore families were not officially required to give consent. The rules for transplantations changed two years later.

But John believes hospital staff purposely went against the wishes of the family and removed the heart immediately after life support was switched off.

Since 2005 John has been trying to sue the Crown Health Funding Agency for damages, on the grounds of mental suffering, but every attempt in seeking government-funded legal aid has been denied.

He applied for civil legal aid, which was declined by the Legal Services Commissioner on the grounds the case lacked sufficient prospects of success. An application to the Legal Aid Tribunal for a review of the decision was also made, but the Commissioner's decision was upheld.

Evidence given at a High Court hearing in Wellington last year confirmed Greenlane Hospital at the time 'actively encouraged” mortuaries to send its heart valves for transplants, and 'it was not usual practice for consent to be obtained from next of kin”.

John believes Kenneth's heart was removed at once, although the court judgment by Justice Robert Dobson says it could have been done 12 hours later during an autopsy.

'Mr Mackenzie considers that all government agencies he has dealt with have deliberately obstructed his initiatives to get proceedings under way, because they appreciate the extent of the embarrassment and/or cost involved for the government if and when the courts recognise his claim,” says Justice Dobson.

Justice Dobson declined legal aid on the grounds where legal action was filed beyond the six-year deadline.

Yesterday, the Court of Appeal published a judgment following a hearing on July 8, 2013 supporting the High Court's decision rejecting the latest legal aid request.

'We have considered all of Mr Mackenzie's submissions carefully, but are unable to identify any question of law justifying the grant of leave of appeal,” says Justice Douglas White.

In the rejection, John's fourth, the judges say the chance of success in the case was considered so small that funding should not be granted.

Judges agree with the High Court on the basis the case was weak because too much time had passed since the event.

They say John is a secondary victim and cannot claim mental suffering when it was his son who was the "principal victim".

John has argued because his son was dead, the chance for him to sue was never on offer.

4 comments

Grateful

Posted on 24-07-2013 13:33 | By Raewyn

I would think this man would be happy that his Son was able to help someone else


Tragic

Posted on 24-07-2013 13:47 | By morepork

It is hard to read this without feeling for John, but it is important to remember that a young girl's life was saved by the action of the Hospital. Nowadays we understand better how human body parts can be "reused" and we can make choices as to whether we want to be donors or not. That was probably not the case in 1987. Some families will object on religious grounds but many of us are happy to have any "bits" of us that can be used to help others, after we have stopped needing them, passed on. I feel for John and I understand his pain over this. My advice would be to try and think of the young woman who was given life and how his son would feel about that.


Posted on 24-07-2013 14:06 | By rosscoo

sounds like the hospital trying to play god again instead of considering peoples feelings where is there Hippocratic oath


Disgusting

Posted on 27-07-2013 10:47 | By Lala

I find this is a horrible choice on the hospitals part, if the boy was not an organ donor then nothing should have been taken from him. The dad has every right to be upset since they butchered his son. And ofcourse the son cannot sue as he is dead so the father has every right to. I would have a hard time dealing with it if my son or daughter got their heart taken out without consent


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.