Hospital failed patient who died

Tauranga Hospital failed to diagnose a hernia and bowel obstruction in a 78-year-old woman who later died, the Health and Disability Commissioner has found.

A report released by Commissioner Anthony Hill yesterday says BOPDHB failed to provide an appropriate standard of care for the patient who died of a hypoxic brain injury caused by cardiac arrest in 2010.


Tauranga Hospital failed to care for a patient suffering from a hernia who later died a report has found.

The woman was referred to the hospital by her GP on a Thursday in mid-2010 with vomiting, dehydration and a groin lump.

She was reviewed by a junior registrar (Dr D) and a medical consultant (Dr C) who diagnosed an abdominal malignancy.

The junior registrar reviewed the patient the following day and spoke with her GP asking why the cause of her vomiting had not been identified.

The report says the junior registrar's concerns were not passed onto the consultant and therefore not given to the weekend staff at handover.

'She was not reviewed for 27 hours, during which time her condition deteriorated and she continued to vomit, with her husband emptying the containers himself because nurses were not available often enough,” the report states.

The woman was diagnosed with pneumonia after being reviewed by a house officer on Saturday night.

As the hospital was full, she was moved to a surgical ward accepting medical overflow patients, but because the nurse was on a tea-break no handover was given.

The woman's condition rapidly deteriorated and nurses paged a house officer at 9.30pm but the woman was not seen until 11pm.

Around 30 minutes later, the woman went into respiratory arrest and suffered a cardiac arrest.

She was transferred to the Intensive Care Unit, and the next day the hernia was diagnosed during surgery. However, she had suffered a severe hypoxic brain injury during the cardiac arrest, and died a few days later.

The commissioner ruled the consultant failed to ensure he was adequately informed of the patient's history, and failed to consider a hernia with bowel obstruction as a possible diagnosis.

The registrar had failed to take an adequate history and failed to report that, and the GP's concerns about a possible hernia, to the consultant.

The Bay of Plenty District Health Board also failed to provide an appropriate standard of care, had inadequate clinical records and inconsistent and flawed clinical handover processes.

Bay of Plenty District Health Board chief executive officer Phil Cammish says since the woman's death, the board has made several changes to processes and rostering of senior medical officers.

'The HDC report fully outlines the causes and the remedial actions taken by the DHB to address those causes. Both causes and remedial actions are fully covered in the report and in its summaries.”

Both doctors and the board have been asked to apologise to the family for the shortcomings in care, as well as reviewing procedures and standards, the report says.

Medical Council of New Zealand will be advised of the finding, with a recommendation that it undertake a competency review of Dr D.

'Dr D was not a junior doctor but a registrar undertaking vocational training to be a specialist and had sufficient experience and competence to be considered qualified to undertake his role,” says Phil.

'Dr D no longer works for the DHB by his own choice.”

He says the DHB has addressed the recommendations made in the report and believes in having an open disclosure process for errors and promotes the ability for staff to learn and not repeat the same mistakes.

'A blame based environment does not do this and can result in the potential for errors to be repeated and further harm to be caused.”
Phil says in busy hospitals there are always time pressures from time to time.

'There are no staffing issues at Tauranga Hospital and over the three years since this event senior medical staff numbers have continued to increase in line with the extra services now available at Tauranga Hospital, and the increase in the population of the Western Bay of Plenty.”

5 comments

Hernia

Posted on 21-05-2013 14:00 | By marian

This happened to me as well, my dr sent me to a&e with a lump in my upper stomach and suspected a hernia last August, I was examined and was given pain relief,the registrar on duty said, if that is a hernia I will write u up in the medical journal!! And sent me home.thank god my dr sent me for a scan, and it was confirmed I had a hernia and was operated on in sept last year.always be pro-active, it may save your life.


typical

Posted on 21-05-2013 15:45 | By RichieR

that this hospital blames everyone but themselves for this. Take responsibility and why does this doctor who is also found guilty not have his name revealed. I for 1 would not want to have them anywhere near my family. On several occasions i have had family members in Tauranga Hospital and each one of them has had issues with getting a simply glass of water. My daughter was sent home extremely dehydrated from this place only to be returned again within a day to have fluid pumped back into her she was so severely dehydrated. Time someone actually gave a hoot and did some serious restructuring in this so called hospital.


What about the SUCCESSES

Posted on 21-05-2013 15:50 | By carpedeum

While feeling extremely sorry for the person and family of the perosn who died- please can you also remember the number of people who are SAVED from dying by Taurnaga Hospital ED- if you wrate all of theri names in a big long list it would cover PAGES AND PAGES- no on is GOD and noone is infallible ina ALL walks of life.Just think about the successes as awell. and NO I am not a Nurse or a Doctor there- just a Volunteer who helps out with a bit of hand holding/ bedmaking/cup of tea/moral support for patients and observe first hand- on a weekly basis- the great medical and human care that pateints receive


.

Posted on 21-05-2013 20:44 | By traceybjammet

hospitals are for emergencys and the main problem with most hospitals is valuable staff and time being taken up by people that should have just gone to a gp who should refer you for scans or tests not just to see another doctor in A and E Also always trust your gut feeling doctors are human and mistakes can be made


larynx cancer,not hernia

Posted on 25-05-2013 12:29 | By hapukafin

my Gp referred me to Tauranga Hospital with symtoms of hoarse voice and dry coughing,typical symptoms of laynx cancer which should be looked at with urgency after he wasnt successful in treating me.I was just told by the hospital we cant see everybody and go back to my Gp for further treatment with tones of racism .On a repeat refferral some 15 months later I was diagnosed with stage 3 larynx cancer instead stage 1 and now on etxreme treatment to save my voicebox.THe Tauraga hospital graded me as low risk without seeing me and I was classed that because I never smoked,It pays not to look after and respect your body if you want treatment.Go get drugged up and blow yourself up,run the cops ,crash your car and you will get all the treatment until you are 100% to go out and do it again.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.