Cop's force used in teen’s arrest unjustified

The incident happened following a crash in Taupō on November 5, 2020.

A Bay of Plenty police officer charged with assaulting a teenager has been acquitted and remains employed by the New Zealand Police Force.

The Independent Police Conduct Authority has found that an officer at Taupō (Officer A) used unjustified and unnecessary force during the arrest of a 17-year-old female (Ms Z).

During the late afternoon on November 5, 2020, officers attended a vehicle accident on the outskirts of Taupō.

The officers could not locate the driver, Ms Z, or her female passenger. Ms Z’s mother and grandfather travelled to the scene but were also unable to locate the pair, says a report released today by the IPCA.

About two hours later, Police found the young women hiding nearby in a dense bush. Officer A took Ms Z from the bush and proceeded to physically escort her to her family members who were standing nearby.

“Ms Z was being abusive and uncooperative towards Officer A when he forcefully took her to the ground and applied handcuffs,” says the IPCA report.

“Ms Z’s family members and another officer witnessed Officer A’s actions and reported that it was unnecessary.”

Later that evening, Ms Z was found to have a broken shoulder.

The Authority could not determine how this injury occurred.

“However, on the evidence of eyewitnesses, the officer’s actions in taking Ms Z to the ground were an unnecessary use of force when he already had her under control,” says an IPCA spokesperson.

“We found that, on balance, Officer A was unjustified in forcing Ms Z to the ground in the way he did.”

Police charged the officer with being a male, assaults a female and in September 2023 he was acquitted of the charge in the Rotorua District Court.

The Authority completed its investigation into this incident in February 2022 but delayed the release of its public report until after the conclusion of those court proceedings.

In response to the IPCA’s findings, Bay of Plenty District Commander Superintendent Tim Anderson says police acknowledge the IPCA’s finding that an officer used unreasonable force on a woman being arrested.

“The incident occurred in Taupo in November 2020 when the woman was arrested after crashing a car in a paddock.

“During the course of the arrest the woman was injured and suffered a broken collarbone.

“Police acknowledge the IPCA’s findings that the use of force by the officer during the arrest was not reasonable in this case.

“A Police investigation resulted in the officer being charged with assault; the officer was acquitted of the charge in the Rotorua District Court.

“The officer involved remains an employee of New Zealand Police.

“For privacy reasons Police cannot comment further on the officer.”

 

3 comments

Just one thought.

Posted on 28-11-2023 13:17 | By morepork

If the girls had come out of hiding and given themselves up, her clavicle would never have been broken. I don't believe it was done deliberately but any parent knows that teenagers can be intractable. It is regrettable, but it need never have happened if she had obeyed the Law. Sadly, female gender no longer causes an expectation of modesty, grace, or gentility. The girls are every bit as bad as the boys and cops have to act accordingly.


Overit

Posted on 28-11-2023 14:04 | By overit

Was the shoulder broken in the accident.


Do the crime..

Posted on 28-11-2023 16:30 | By fair game

accept what comes your way. Have to wonder how a 17 year old had access to alcohol and a car? A bit of Darwinism in Tauranga..


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.