Loss of carpark in Tauranga 'will hurt businesses'

Downtown Tauranga chair Ashleigh Gee said the city had been through so much in the last few years. Photo: John Borren/SunLive.

Tauranga CBD businesses are urging the council to delay the closure of a key carpark as it will “hurt businesses”.

The Strand waterfront carpark - with 147 spaces - closed last week to be redeveloped into greenspace and a playground as part of an $84 million project.

Downtown Tauranga chair Ashleigh Gee presented a petition calling for the carpark closure to be delayed, at a Tauranga City Council meeting today.

“There is an overwhelming amount of great concern from the business community on the timing of the project.

“The city centre has been through so much over the last few years due to the impact from construction, and it is only just getting started.

“Running a business in a city that’s being torn apart and rebuilt is extremely tough.”

The $305m civic precinct Te Manawataki O Te Papa was under construction, main thoroughfare Cameron Road was being redeveloped and a number of other projects were underway in the CBD.

Gee, the owner of Miss Gee’s Bar and Eatery, asked the council to support businesses by allowing some “breathing space”.

The Strand carpark closed on October 30 to be developed into a greenspace. Photo: Alisha Evans/ SunLive.

More than 400 off-street parks had been lost over the last decade, she said.

Since The Strand carpark was shut, the newly revamped Dive Crescent carpark was full by 9am, Gee said.

“Our view is that the timing of the closure of this carpark will be the most crucial timing of the whole transformation project.”

The carpark had closed just before the peak summer season started, she said.

It was also the most easily accessible park in the city and considered a “safe option” for hospitality workers, Gee said.

“Visitors to the city centre are getting more and more frustrated as parking becomes harder and harder to find, leaving them less likely to return.”

She called for a well-lit central taxi stand, more mobility parking, and for the Cameron Road redevelopment to be completed to provide “relief to the city centre” before closing the carpark.

Oscar and Otto owners Catherine MacLoughlin and Hamish Carter loss 11 percent in sales since the carpark was closed. Photo: SunLive.

Oscar and Otto eatery owner Hamish Carter told the meeting the closure would “inevitably hurt businesses”.

“The carpark closure is likely to be the nail in the coffin for many businesses.”

The closure of The Strand carpark created another barrier to people coming to the city centre, said Carter.

In the past week they had an 11 percent drop in sales, he said.

“While 11 percent doesn't seem like a lot, I assure you, in the tight margin hospitality and retail sector, an 11 percent drop in sales is the difference between scraping by or having to cut staff numbers.”

Commission chair Anne Tolley acknowledged the disruption was really difficult.

“We understand it's frustrating.

“We have to get on with changing this city, bringing as many people into the city as we possibly can.”

Commission chair Anne Tolley said the council sympathised with businesses. Photo: Alisha Evans/ SunLive.

Council was contractually bound to continue with the carpark redevelopment, but would talk to staff, said Tolley.

The work included repairing the seawall, which needed to be done in summer, she said.

“Putting it off means it might never happen. So, no time is the right time.”

Disruptions from the development would continue for the next five or six years. The council was working with businesses on how to minimise the disruption and bring people into the city, said Tolley.

This included changing the paid parking end time from 5pm to 6pm and providing free weekend parking, she said.

A new carpark with 100 spaces was being built on Devonport Road, and earthquake strengthening was complete at the Spring Street parking building, Tolley said.

“To address some of the safety concerns, we've employed a full time safety advisor, who is on the streets every day.”

An artist’s render of the $84 million waterfront redevelopment. Photo: TCC.

Tolley also criticised the media attention the parking and safety issues had attracted.

“Publicly talking constantly about how there are no carparks, how it's not safe…only worsens the situation.”

Commissioner Stephen Selwood agreed: “I'm really worried by the message that is constantly being portrayed by Mainstreet [Tauranga] and in the newspaper that there's an ongoing parking crisis in the city, when all of the data is telling us the opposite.”

Council city development and partnerships general manager Gareth Wallis said they would work to try and change that perception.

There were less parks in CBD than three or four years ago, but Wallis said more had become available in the last six months.

The Strand carpark is expected to be under construction until mid-2024.

Public Interest Journalism funded through NZ On Air.

21 comments

No surprises here

Posted on 06-11-2023 17:16 | By Let's get real

Grass and empty display space, rather than commercial activity and evil automobiles. It's incredible to think that business owners are going to be paying for empty CBD space twice or maybe three times. Rates, rental fees and the loss of income for as many years as the banks will allow them to trade for. Does anyone believe that things will be completed in under five years, when watching progress along Cameron Rd and Bayfair...?


finish destroying one part of town before yoy start on another

Posted on 06-11-2023 18:22 | By rotovend

downtown Tauranga needs that carpark at present until they sort out everything else a green space, and kids park next to a train-line and the open water? Agree it should have been kept that way originally however it wasn't , so finish all the other roads killing off local business first, Oh and take the commissioners & councilors free parking off them as well


Tone Deaf

Posted on 06-11-2023 18:24 | By Fernhill22

The feedback that these commissioners have received about the Tauranga CBD from various sources like the media, businesses located in the CBD, and rate payers about there being no carparks, people worried about their safety, and the general demise of our city with all the road works going on along Cameron Road is certainly falling on deaf ears. They only hear what they want to hear and are completely tone deaf to what everyone else can see is happening. Their arrogant attitude, inability to read the room, and to listen to the people who pay their over inflated salaries is systematic to the whole problem.


Shutting the Carpark

Posted on 06-11-2023 18:34 | By The Caveman

will NOT bring more people into the CBD ! It will chase them AWAY - via lack of parking!!

Clearly the so called commissioners have no appreciation of what supports business, and I suspect that rental leases expire, they will not be renewed! Even more empty premises are coming !!


Ridiculous

Posted on 06-11-2023 19:18 | By Mr Dobalina

The area was reclaimed from the harbour sometime around the late '50's for car parking, in order to bring life and much needed parking to the area.
Sometime around 25-30 years ago the council redesigned the area at the cost of many car parks which was bad enough.
It seems the stupidity in council is only increasing.
Combine that with the white elephant disaster that is the downtown multi level car park building that the council signed off on which turned out to be flawed in construction and will cost millions to demolish, if it hasn't been already.


What planet is tolley on?

Posted on 06-11-2023 19:51 | By nerak

'Commission chair Anne Tolley acknowledged the disruption was really difficult.
“We understand it's frustrating.
“We have to get on with changing this city, bringing as many people into the city as we possibly can.”' Really woman, read that back to yourself. You are hell bent and determined to drive the last nail in the city coffin. Tauranga, where's that? Down the drain, that's where. People just do not want to go there any more. You understand NOTHING.


Just Hang In There

Posted on 06-11-2023 19:56 | By Yadick

Listen to the Commissioners, just hang in there for the 5 or 6 years, that we all know will stretch out to nearer 10yrs.
Interesting the Commissioners are not interested in the truth being spoken about. After all they have no worries, except what to do with all their hard earned money they make representing us all. Oh, and of course they have their own free carpark that they get to use any time, they of course drive to work, probably as single occupants in their vehicle. Correct me if you've seen it but I've never seen or heard of the Commissioners taking a bus to work, riding an e scooter or bike for work. I've never seen them out in reality supporting our hard working, struggling cafés but I've seen their extravagant morning teas and lunches they get delivered to them . . .


Problem Is . . .

Posted on 06-11-2023 20:02 | By Yadick

When we finally get the Commissioners out of here who replaces them? We'll probably get the same old do nothing cowboys or a pack of activists trying to jump onboard. Is it better the devil we know or the devil we don't? Scary food for thought. What do you think morepork?


Wait there's more.

Posted on 06-11-2023 21:36 | By Accountable

According to a recently released TCC publication The Strand will be pedestrianized apart from delivery vehicles from the Devonport Road roundabout to Harrington Street roundabout along with the closure of Hamilton Street from The Strand to Willow Street and the partial closure of Willow Street from Harrington Street to Spring Street. Vehicle access to Grey Street and Devonport Road will be from either Spring Street or Elizabeth street. These will be permanent closures. Stephen Sellwood and his family own a retail business in Botany Downs shopping mall in Auckland and he knows full well the need for easily accessible free parking and yet he believes that the Tauranga CBD businesses can survive and thrive without parking. I'll bet that he wouldn't be brave enough to invest his money in any retail or hospitality business in the CBD yet he expects everybody to stop moaning and live with it.


No kidding

Posted on 06-11-2023 22:25 | By The Sage

The commissioners strike again. Only Bureaucrats would close down car parks, in an already extremely disadvantaged CBD, at the busiest time of the year. Wake up!


Hmmm

Posted on 07-11-2023 09:40 | By Let's get real

I truly wonder what the vision is... Is it Utopia or Dystopia.... Almost certainly the latter in my opinion.


Deaf, blind and stupid

Posted on 07-11-2023 10:51 | By AuntyMinnie

How much more pain can Tauranga suffer? Anne Tolley and her cohorts have no heart or soul, no compassion and absolutely no understanding of what Tauranga really needs. I have lived in this wonderful place since 1976 and it is heartbreaking to see what the CBD is going through. Come on, somebody needs to get rid of these dreadful people and get a Council who cares, listens first, understands and then acts. Everybody needs to get on board and help the death of a great city.


It is all

Posted on 07-11-2023 11:28 | By Merlin

It is all about grass and plants and nothing that benefits ratepayersand businesses.Hope the new Government sacks the Commissioners. A petition should be started.


The Master

Posted on 07-11-2023 12:19 | By Ian Stevenson

Tolley and Co are the ones that are off the mark and out of touch with reality.

They have provided themselves with a personal carpark at TCC expense of course, so they actually are clueless 24/7 on the subject. "Tweaking" parking meter times does not do a thing for the mega hundreds of carparks lost in the last decade plus...

Lets not forget, that in the five years to 2016 there was a loss of 900+ carparks in the CBD, the Spring Street carpark was to eventually replace half of that, some 460? But typically for a TCC build project that was a disaster, no carparks as yet...

You would think that Tolley & Co would notice the "MES" that the CBD is in, because they have been there a couple of times in the last few years, perhaps?


The Master

Posted on 07-11-2023 12:20 | By Ian Stevenson

Based on the comments above, it is fair to say that the Commissioners and many more at TCC have no clue at all what is happening in the CBD, nor what has happened for the last 10-15 years either.


Really

Posted on 07-11-2023 15:43 | By Kiwi28

Just looked at the proposed artist impression of the new development, lots of grass some trees and a nice board walk, I understand the sea wall has to be fixed as well but really $84 million.
Everyone that I have talked to would have liked to see restaurants on the waters edge and all types of restaurants from fine dining to casual family restaurants as they do in a lot of other cities. Imagine sitting enjoying a meal with the family with a view, nothing nicer. But in saying all that if you take something away like a car park provide an alternative in the interim.


Well really!

Posted on 07-11-2023 17:32 | By AuntyMinnie

“Publicly talking constantly about how there are no carparks, how it's not safe…only worsens the situation.”

People need to know!!! Reading all the comments - you are totally ignoring the people of Tauranga.

You are out of touch. Please just go.


Artists Impressions

Posted on 07-11-2023 17:41 | By Yadick

Can the artist give us another impression? One that shows where all those people parked.


@nerak

Posted on 07-11-2023 18:27 | By morepork

This is the same Anne Tolley who "doesn't want people driving from the Mount to patronize bars in our CBD". Your final sentence is right on point. The Commissioners are implementing a broken, political, agenda from Nanaia Mahuta, namely: "cars bad; kill cars". It is based on the incorrect assumption that removing cars will solve climate change. It won't. However, once we all go electric (and the battery and transport technology reaches its optimum level (say, 10 years...)) we will be able to use cars without any emissions impact on the environment.


@Yadick (and everyone else...)

Posted on 07-11-2023 18:42 | By morepork

Scared by two Devils? The one you know and the one you don't? The whole point of a democracy is to let us choose (for better or worse) and if it is worse, then change it. That is called "answerability" and it is designed to keep those in power honest. Currently, we have an appointed administration that has demonstrated it has no real engagement with the people of Tauranga. They have no answerability and arrogantly extended their own term because it is such a good ride. Even if we got the worst of the devils we previously had, at least they would be OUR devils, AND they would be ANSWERABLE. We could remove them. I believe there are capable people in our community who can serve on an elected Council, and do a decent job of it, with transparency, answerability, and desire to serve. The Commission MUST go!


Public service.

Posted on 07-11-2023 18:58 | By morepork

Further to my response to Yadick, in replacing the current Commission, the real problem we will encounter is that the capable and useful people we would want on Council, are already busy making their own lives and businesses, and taking care of their families. It needs people who are not in it for recognition or money, but who care passionately about Tauranga and have a commitment to engaging with the community and LISTENING. People who will commit their energy and ability to the development of our people and our city. (Such people are true rubies and, although they are very hard to find, I know they exist; I've met some :-) ) I considered "Morepork for Mayor" but as a retired pensioner I don't have the necessary wherewithal to run, and I'm probably too old... :-)


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.