Elections: will stood down councillors run again?

Both Dawn Kiddie and Steve Morris are happy with their current work roles. Photo. Daniel Hines/SunLive/File.

Of the councillors stood down from Tauranga City Council a year ago, only three have plans to run again should elections take place in October.

It comes as a debate churns in Tauranga over this year's local elections, with some regional figures fearing the work of Commissioners could be undone by the return to power of elected officials.

Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta announced the appointment of the commission in December 2020, in response to what she deemed significant governance problems from elected officials.

When that commission, made up of chair Anne Tolley, Stephen Selwood, Bill Wasley and Shadrach Rolleston, got to work in February 2021 the eight Councillors still in place became so only in name.

Andrew Hollis, Kelvin Clout and John Robson stood at large, whilst Steve Morris, Dawn Kiddie, Larry Baldock, Bill Grainger and Tina Salisbury represented their respective wards.

Salisbury was also acting Mayor, after Tenby Powell stepped down in November 2020, calling for Government action in the process.

Jako Abrie, representative for Pyes Pa, also called for central intervention when he stood down in October 2020.

Two months later, Heidi Hughes resigned four days after Mahuta announced the commission was to be appointed, in order to avoid a costly by-election.

Powell believes the commission should remain beyond October, whilst the business community has also spoken with praise for the commission. Local ratepayer groups have, however, been critical of the commission.

When asked by SunLive, Mahuta made it clear her intention is for a return to elections in Tauranga, once a commission exit strategy was finalised.

A date for those elections was not given. October is the most likely scenario, but any delay beyond that point could see the next local elections for Tauranga held in 2025.

She did, however, make clear that there is no option to restrict the councillors she replaced with commissioners from running again.

Nanaia Mahuta. Photo: RNZ.

'There is no legislative basis to prevent individuals from standing in a local election beyond those set out in the Local Government Act 2002,” she explains.

'The community of Tauranga will have the opportunity to determine and vote for the candidates they consider will provide the best governance and oversight in the interest of Tauranga.”

However, concerns over elected officials returning to office may be something of a moot point.

Only a handful of the officials who previously made up Tauranga's last elected council are looking to run again in October, with others non-committal and some ruling themselves out completely.

Robson says he's looking to stand but would like to see the proposed representation review thrown out. The current proposal is for single-member wards, Including a Maori ward, involving nine councillors and a Mayor.

Appeals are currently being considered and a final determination on how council will be structured must be made by April 11. If the single-member system is thrown out, Robson plans to stand as an at-large candidate.

Andrew Hollis plans on running again. Photo. Daniel Hines/SunLive/File.

Hollis, who ran for a seat in the Western Bay last year, says he is 'quite likely to run again” and remains a ratepayer in Otumoetai, the ward in which he intends to run.

Baldock says his running is 'possible” and would be for the Tauriko ward.

Others seem less likely.

Clout will consider running but is still awaiting the Commission exit strategy and Mahuta's full plans for October. He is also relishing a new career in real estate.

Morris and Kiddie are also enjoying their current work commitments. Both stopped short of ruling out a return to Council but seem content with their current situations.

Salisbury says she is not able to comment at present as she was not aware of any formal decisions about October's election process.

Heidi Hughes has no interest in running again. File Image.

Hughes replied with a frank, and rather upbeat, 'no” when asked by SunLive if she would be running again whilst Grainger also has no plans to return to local politics and did not wish to comment any further.

Abrie was approached for comment.

15 comments

They are ALL free to run

Posted on 14-02-2022 12:20 | By an_alias

Commission, local bureaucrats and business have NO say on democratic elections. ALL can stand in a FREE democratic election. Sunlive and local business have no say on that unless we are to move to China style politics. Is that what you want ?


Hmmm

Posted on 14-02-2022 12:36 | By Let's get real

The problem is that ratepayers can only vote for the people that put themselves forward for election. We currently have a great example of what happens when people are elected and have extremely poor or no management skills, but fit the current narrative of diversity and inclusion. Our government is a collection of firefighters rather than planners because they don't have the skills or experience. Undoubtedly all around the country we will see more and more ineptitude being funded by ratepayers trying to select the best fruit from the windfall.


Balanced management

Posted on 14-02-2022 12:54 | By Crowley

Knowing Dawn and Steven and a lot of the former councillors, I think they remain as committed as they always did to balancing the needs of the communities, instructions from central government and the ambitions of commercial interests with fiscal realities of those paying for it all.


Bring back democracy

Posted on 14-02-2022 13:40 | By Willie White

Absolutely we need democracy to resume and for the truth about events that led to this mess to be given some sunlight so the people can never be short-changed ever again. We need councillors with integrity like Dawn Kiddie


Do Tauranga A Favour

Posted on 14-02-2022 14:29 | By Yadick

and none of you stand. You each had your chance and proved categorically you are not team players, you are not leaders, you refuse leadership and direction. You each had your own agenda and that's all it was about. You categorically let Tauranga down. Some of you continue to somehow think you still represent us now - you don't. Divided we fall and you fell taking Tauranga with you. Putting it bluntly, in my opinion, there is no place for any of you on our Council when we finally get it back. We need new blood and the way forward for the voters is not going to be an easy gamble.


Elections

Posted on 14-02-2022 14:44 | By peanuts9

Just what we need, more of the same.


Looking forward to a return to local democracy

Posted on 14-02-2022 14:58 | By Katherine L

Will be great to see democracy back in action locally - I always found our Mount Councillors to be really great with the community's best interests at heart.


elections

Posted on 14-02-2022 16:36 | By dumbkof2

we don't need any candidates. we already have two who will tell us what we are going to get. even if we don't want what they tell us


Question

Posted on 14-02-2022 16:42 | By The Sage

Does anyone know if this lot have continued to be paid?


Amazing

Posted on 14-02-2022 21:09 | By Informed

Amazing that some people confuse that some of these people had the rate payers interests at heart. When in fact they ran the city into the ground. They don’t understand how to govern, they ask for the same information multiple times, they try to design everything themselves, they don’t understand infrastructure, they don’t meet with the community. Their only claim is keeping rates at a level where the city gets further and further behind. Not one of them could get a senior management position at McD’s let alone a large organisation. And if you read the article it’s clear they will all run again.


Tenby

Posted on 15-02-2022 08:17 | By waiknot

This is an interesting situation. I don’t believe all the councillors can be blamed for this fiasco. From what I have gleaned the main issue was the last elected mayor who didn’t understand his role. He acted in an authoritarian manor expecting the councillors to rubber stamp his decrees. Those councillors who stood up to him he considered disruptive, and attempted to sideline them.


Like Waiknot,

Posted on 15-02-2022 14:13 | By nerak

my understanding is Powell was the main disruptor with his appalling 'management' of councillors. I am sick of reading comments that blame 'all' past councillors for the situation we are now in. That is just not right.


@Yadick and Informed

Posted on 15-02-2022 14:16 | By nerak

It's become tiresome reading your comments berating the previous councillors. I expect both of you to run for council seeing you are both experts.


@ nerak

Posted on 15-02-2022 21:29 | By Yadick

So you'll obviously be running for Mayor . . .


Should they run again?

Posted on 17-02-2022 13:51 | By morepork

The real reason for the replacement of the Council was because we had a Mayor who was hopelessly inept and insensitive. To be fair, the people he had to work with were also lacking in basic skills for Senior Management. Probably, everybody had a misconception of what being a Councillor is about. Egos got involved and the result was ... well, you've seen it. I believe that people can and do learn from mistakes, so I think all of them should be able to stand again, if they want to. Personally, I wouldn't have a bar of 10B in ANY capacity, unless he actually lived here and showed this was not a practice run for Auckland or National Politics. But it's easy; don't like a candidate? Don't vote for them. The responsibility is with us, the electorate, not with the candidates.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.