A Tauranga man found guilty of murdering a three-month-old baby will remain behind bars until his sentencing in August.
The defendant, who cannot be named, has admitted culpability in the infant's death, but denies the murder charge.
Crown prosecutor Anna Pollett says the murder charge is supported by the medical evidence and the opinions of the medical experts.
Bruising on the baby's face show the 14-week-old was slapped or punched, probably before the ‘unsurvivable' impact or impacts that fractured the skull multiple times across the back and sides of the head.
Suppression orders prevent the identification of the defendant and any details that my lead to his identification, which includes information about where he lived who he lived with and his relationships.
The crown case is linking the severity of the injuries with murderous intent.
In her summing up yesterday, Anna Pollett told jurors they had to be sure that at the time the defendant killed the baby he had to have that intent - or that he appreciated his actions would cause the baby's death and he went ahead regardless.
'Either one of these states of mind is murder.
'You could be very sorry afterwards; regretful remorseful. Intent is determined at the time of the fatal assault, not before not after.”
The baby had been crying loudly for 10 to 15 minutes, and the stressed defendant was heard asking: ‘Why are you crying? Why don't you stop crying?
Evidence from a person in another room of the house, says the baby made a loud cry and then was silent.
The only witness is a young person who reported seeing the defendant strike the baby and throw him on the bed.
The medical evidence of the significant high impact skull fractures come from the skull striking a hard surface, according to the medical experts' evidence.
The experts agree the impacts were severe, with not only multiple skull fractures, but with significant tearing of brain tissue in three separate areas, which indicates at least three significant impacts, says Anna.
Defence council Rob Stevens says it's a tragic case.
He says while the defendant didn't accept responsibility at the time, he has since admitted causing the fatal injuries.
He says it was a trial by jury and not a trial by expert. One doctor who had likened the severity of the head injuries to a high speed crash changed their position under cross examination.
'At the end of the day they are expert opinions, not facts,” says Rob.
He told the jury of seven women and five men that the Crown does not present any evidence that can support a decision to kill.
Justice Mary Peters is presided over the case.



4 comments
A Revolting individual.
Posted on 04-07-2017 08:22 | By comfortablynumb
Makes me feel sick reading this. Poor little infant, how could someone do this?This scumbag should not have name suppression at all. Why should the courts do him any favours? Lock him up in a secure prison for life and I mean life. I hope corrections conveniently lose the key and forget his is incarcerated. Let's hope the other inmates get to this nonce.
typical
Posted on 04-07-2017 14:19 | By CC8
THAT attitude is typical of someone who is comfortably numb. Disassociated from the issues and problem facing other people. As long as You are "OK" . the world is OK ? This person was NOT prepared for looking after a baby. He was not educated and/or supported by those with more experience and knowledge , AT ANY LEVEL.It all comes back to education , the LACK of it and the inability of educators to think outside the box to give appropriate knowledge to those they are paid to educate. Locking him up and throwing away the key is just the last part of the irresponsibility chain. OUT OF SIGHT OUT OF MIND....
CC8
Posted on 04-07-2017 17:46 | By comfortablynumb
Here we go.Typical liberal attitude . Ask yourself this question CC8 what if it was your child ? Do a leaflet drop I suppose to campaign for early release of this scumbag I think not !
What's more CC8
Posted on 04-07-2017 22:28 | By laugeo
I firmly believe it is people with your ideology that perpetuate these tragic events by constantly excusing individuals. Today, nobody is responsible for what they've done, it is always somebody else's fault and there are always a heap of weak minded liberals with a readymade list of who should be blamed for what you have done wrong! Society today says, never mind if you are not prepared mentally, physically or financially to have children, have them anyway, as many as you like. Don't concern yourself with your inability to parent (that'll be the school's fault) don't worry that that same inability will be passed to your multiple offspring ad infinitum. These terrible, tragic horror stories will continue until there is a way to identify and prevent those that simply should not parent. Do not lose sight here, an innocent baby DIED!
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.