Chinese tourist appealing sentence

A Chinese tourist convicted of killing a Tauranga motorcyclist in an accident in which she lost control of her vehicle should serve her full sentence.

This is a call from many people in New Zealand following news that Jieling Xiao is appealing her 17 month jail sentence.


Jieling Xiao leaves Napier District court in May after pleading guilty to dangerous driving causing death.

New Zealand First leader Winston Peters says the court needs to stick to its decision.

Xiao was sentence to prison after pleading guilty to a charge of dangerous driving causing the death of Rhys following a fatal crash in February.

Xiao was on a 12 month working visa in New Zealand and had never driven on an open road at more than 50km/h when she drove into the path of Rhys' motorbike on the Napier-Taupo highway, killing him.

According to the summary of facts, Xiao's erratic driving before the accident had alarmed other motorists. And Xiao's passenger said she had felt unsafe during a trip with Xiao the previous day.


Rhys Middleton was killed in a crash on SH5, near Napier.

'The family of the deceased motorcyclist Rhys Middleton are concerned Jieling Xiao will have her sentence downgraded to home detention after a hearing on Tuesday,” says Winston.

'At her sentencing in June, she was jailed for 17 months after she admitted driving erratically before the crash, over-correcting and hitting Mr Middleton on State Highway 5 near Eskdale.

'As Mr Middleton's father has said, if Xiao is given home detention she could be deported to China within 28 days.

'The court needs to stick by their decision and Xiao, who was here on a working visa, must serve out her sentence.”

15 comments

Weak system

Posted on 15-08-2016 14:56 | By Hot stuff

17 months is crap anyway , let alone even thinking of downgrading to home detention If it was one of my family members she had killed she would be safer in jail than out . These judges need to get harder and stop being pussies


No appeal

Posted on 15-08-2016 15:08 | By Peaches

Why should she get to appeal, after all you know your were driving erratic before the accident, and pleading guilty.You killed a young man, "get real"Do your time you deserve it.


Take ownership

Posted on 15-08-2016 15:55 | By The Sage

This will be causing the Victim's family more grief and sadness. Show some respect and at least bite the bullet and be quiet. Disgusting.


Caribe

Posted on 15-08-2016 16:06 | By Bermacar

There is no way the sentence should be reduced. She cut short the life of a young man and it sounds like she doesn't really care anyway. Too many bad drivers out there. They deserve the sentences they get - which are too lenient anyway.


Hmmm..

Posted on 15-08-2016 16:15 | By maildrop

I can't help thinking she got 17 months because she is a foreigner. She is clearly a crap driver and shouldn't have been on the road but she was and that is because of a weak system. She didn't do it deliberately, yet the sentence is consistent with people who cause death by drink driving or being deliberately reckless. If you go overseas and don't have the skills to drive, yet they allow you to, the blame has to be shared. If you allow a monkey to fire a gun, don't expect it to shoot straight. 17 months is harsh in comparison to Kiwi killers, but the zenophobes will win out, led by the Master, Winston.


On the other foot...

Posted on 15-08-2016 16:15 | By penguin

She has admitted guilt and has been sentenced. She must do the time or we, yet again, could be the laughing stock and be seen as a soft touch. Now, if the boot was on the other foot and a Kiwi had killed someone in China, I bet the consequences would be greater!


Tougher sentence!

Posted on 15-08-2016 16:47 | By takeabreath

Judges in these sorts of cases disgust me with their weak and pitiful sentences - my Father was a pedestrian who was hit by a car and killed, it devastated our family. The Police did a fantastic job of investigating the accident and found the driver at fault. The driver got himself a fancy lawyer and received a sentence of a $2000 fine...I kid you not. The Police do their job and the judges handing out sentences make a mockery of the law. I hope this woman receives a harsher sentence - it never brings a family member back, but if you break the law you should be punished accordingly for it.


Daanz

Posted on 15-08-2016 16:51 | By AP

She needs to serve the full sentence!she killed a fine young man. There should be no other option available to her. After 17 months she can go home to her mummy and daddy. Rhys and his family do not have that option.


Unbelievable

Posted on 15-08-2016 19:03 | By overit

Well said Penguin. In Australia if its neglect she would get charged for manslaughter.Wake up judges. And what is the sentence for friends and family of Rhys.


I'm not sure.......

Posted on 15-08-2016 23:49 | By groutby

.of the charge, but "careless use of a motor vehicle causing death" would be about right surely?..As a 'local" or a visitor to our country, we are all under ONE law...the same, no more no less. This person killed, yes KILLED another human..convicted as such and even with only 17 months,has questioned ( no doubt with the suggestion of her legal aid lawyer)this sentence. In another country, the tourist would come under the law of THAT land, and any incidents dealt with under the local laws. Maildrop, she deliberately drove back onto the road after leaving it..without skill, knowledge or any thought whatsoever...please do not give us any more excuses for poor decision making, and moreso responsibility for our actions..I have no doubt that it was not pre-meditated, but it happened and consequences must be upheld.. again at taxpayers expense..but then, how expensive is it for the Middleton family?


Appeal

Posted on 16-08-2016 03:18 | By Kenworthlogger

Show no mercy....,


Manslaughter

Posted on 16-08-2016 11:03 | By Mackka

There is no consistency in the sentencing for this type of 'crime'. Few get jail, some get a fine, some get home detention, community work , licence disqualification etc. It is 'manslaughter' and all drivers who use a vehicle carelessly and kill a person should receive a term of imprisonment of at least 2-3 years. Sentencing now depends on how much money you have or have not got and a good lawyer or otherwise.


how

Posted on 16-08-2016 12:43 | By Capt_Kaveman

about starting at the root of the problem, how was she allowed to drive here? this has to stop


I wonder...

Posted on 16-08-2016 13:51 | By Kaimai

I wonder what the sentence would have been if it was a judge's son or daughter, or maybe an MP's son or daughter that had been killed - just wondering?


Kaimai

Posted on 17-08-2016 04:19 | By Kenworthlogger

Or a truck driver? They would be given a jail sentence for 7 or 8 years...


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.