Tauranga man's appeal denied

A Tauranga man serving a prison sentence for assault has had his appeal dismissed.

Lexton Joe Tai was at a house party in Tauranga in January when an intoxicated man showed up unannounced and started causing trouble.


File photo.

The court's summary of facts show the man tipped over a table and as his aunty was cleaning up the mess, he said to her, "Yeah, clean my s*** up".

Tai claimed the victim then removed his genitals from his pants and waved them at several people in the room, saying, "You can all suck my d***”.

It was at this point Tai punched the drunk man in the face. Tai hit him in the forehead with a spirit bottle, causing lacerations to the victim's head.

Two people grabbed Tai and pulled him away from the man and told him he had done enough. Tai broke free and kicked him in the mouth.

The summary of facts shows Tai's victim lost numerous teeth and suffered severe trauma to the inside of his mouth as a result of the kick.

Tai told police he had been drinking and taking drugs on the evening of the incident and, as a result, couldn't remember anything.

Tai pleaded guilty in the Rotorua District Court to a charge of injuring with intent to injure and was sentenced in March by Judge Josephine Bouchier to two years and four months in prison.

He appealed the sentence on the grounds the judge's starting point was too high, the judge erred in failing to take into account the victim's conduct, erred in failing to apply a discount in respect of remorse and a sentence of home detention would have been appropriate.

The appeal was heard in the Tauranga High Court this month.

- Stuff.co.nz

2 comments

good job

Posted on 17-05-2016 15:02 | By NotNat

with a fowl mouth and disgusting actions hope he was charged too indecent exposure at least?- missing teeth are the least of his worry's. Grown men behaving like grown men at its best. my opinion is that, assuming this is a one time offence, maybe home detention is appropriate given the circumstances. Hope ALL parties involved have learnt a lesson and not just the man who has been charged.


Hmmmm

Posted on 18-05-2016 05:04 | By How about this view!

Why do we have so many "get out of jail free" cards in play? Two people behaving in a sub-human manor, both should be locked away from alcohol for a lot longer than two years and with no parole for "Good behaviour"!!!


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.