Murder trial witness cross-examined

A crown witness in a Tauranga murder trial has been questioned about why he changed his story at two police interviews.

Devon Williams was at a party on Mansfield Street on November 30, 2014, when a fight, which led to the death of Takena Tiep-Ranapia, broke out.


Emergency services on Mansfield Street on November 30, 2015.

The 19-year-old, known as Tarks, was found dead at a neighbouring property after he had been stabbed in the neck.

Hiakita Hori Eruera, 36, Hyacin Eruera 40, and Paul William Taki 37 are on trial in relation to the teenager's murder.

Crown Prosecutor Greg Hollister Jones says they charged together, because while Hiakita Eruera is alleged to have struck the fatal blow, his wife Hyacin and Paul Taki were fully involved participants.

Hyacin drove the two men from Mount Maunganui to Ohauiti and shouted encouragement from the car, says Greg.

The trio are alleged to have assaulted two young men near the intersection of Ohauiti Road and Welcome Bay Road before continuing to Mansfield Street, off Harrisfield Drive, where the Crown alleges Hiakita Eruera stabbed Tarks in the neck.

There are two sets of charges. Charges of wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and assault with a weapon relate to the Ohauiti Road attacks.

The Crown says Eruera stabbed one man several times and that Taki struck another on the back of the head with a metal object.

Hiakita Eruera and Paul Taki are alleged to have arrived at Mansfield Street with Eruera going inside while carrying a knife.

The Crown allege that he came outside the house after a short time and encountered Tarks, stabbing him in the neck before leaving.

Devon Williams was at the party, and during his first interview with police the afternoon after the incident, made no mention of Eruera entering the party with a knife.

But he did in the second interview which took place later in the evening.

Russel Fairbrother, QC, challenged the discrepancy, his recollections and asked about his state of mind and what he had been consuming.

He inferred the knife only appeared in the second interview because, between interviews, he admitted discussing what had happened with others.

'The agreement reached is that they saw Paris and her family as troublemakers that became your solid view after that?” asked Russell.

Devon says he didn't mention the knife in the first interview because he was scared.

When pressed about his signature on the witness statement, Devon says not telling about the knife was not lying.

'You think you can make this decision about what might be the truth?” asked Russell Fairbrother.

The police interviews were at 2pm and 7pm the following day and between those times Devon Williams talked to his mates about what happened, says Russell. When asked again where the information about the knife came from, Devon said: 'I seen it with my own eyes.”

He also admitted drinking a lot at the party, crashing out for a while – but for no longer that 20 minutes, though he admits not knowing the time and agreed he could only confirm if it was day or night.

The first police interview was helping police identify the party guests. Devon says there wasn't a large gathering. There were about a dozen or more people present with others arriving and leaving during the course of the afternoon and evening.

He was vague on details about what people were wearing, down played an alleged incident between the dead man and the daughter of the accused. He admitted being drunk and to smoking cannabis during the evening.

The Crown case is that the attacks were in reprisals for an alleged assault on the Erueras' daughter Paris, whom the parents dropped off at the party at Mansfield Street about 5pm.

Read more here.

The trial which is Tauranga's second High Court jury trial is set down for two more weeks. Justice Christian Whata is presiding.

0 comments

Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.