Former HRT employee wins $17k compo

An organisation involved in building one of the biggest cycle trails in the country, was forced to fork out thousands of dollars after a romantic relationship went wrong.

Carol Susan Baker, was awarded $17,500 in compensation after she was assaulted by her ex-boss, Peter Maynard, former manager of Hauraki Rail Trail Limited.


She also said she was unjustifiably disadvantaged as the company failed to provide her with a safe work space.

Baker started work in Thames for Hauraki Rail Trail as a marketing manager in January 2012, according to an Employment Relations Authority [ERA] decision.

"It is common cause that she obtained that position because she was in a romantic relationship with Mr Peter Maynard who was then the governing director of Hauraki Rail Trail, at that point a reasonably new start up business," the decision read.

Baker began living with Maynard around the same time she was employed and when the relationship ended in June, 2012, she wanted to stay on as marketing manager.

On the weekend of June, 16-17, 2012, Baker alleged Maynard broke into her home to recover property that belonged to Hauraki Rail Trail.

Maynard said there was no need for him to break in as he had a swipe card; he was found not guilty in a criminal court.

The following week, on June 22, Baker said Maynard assaulted her in her home, a crime he was found guilty of.

"As I have already made clear, it is not necessary for me to investigate the allegation of whether or not there was an assault; Mr Maynard was charged with assault and found guilty of assault by a jury."

Baker stopped working for Hauraki Rail Trail following the assault, and although there was an attempt by the company to mediate the issue, the decision ruled in Baker's favour.

"Where the employer's agent assaults the employee that constitutes such a grave repudiation of the normal incidents of employment as to constitute an unjustified dismissal.

"...no right thinking employee could reasonably be expected to continue in the employment."

The former employee also asked for lost wages of $41,600, which was denied in employment court.

"I am not persuaded that there can be any award for lost wages... if an employee cannot work by reason of ill health then it is not possible to visit the consequences of the wage loss on the employer. It is apparent that Ms Baker was prevented by ill health from working for the period in question.

"But of course, if, as in this case, it is difficult to escape the conclusion that it was the employer who created the ill health in the first place, or at least contributed to it, then that must sound in compensation."

Hauraki Rail Trail were also ordered to pay Baker $71.56 for costs associated with taking the matter to the employment court and $1,750 for legal costs.

- Stuff

0 comments

Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.