Doctors and nurses are playing increasing roles in prescribing, supplying or administering drugs that may hasten a patient's death, according to new research.
A University of Auckland study anonymously surveyed 650 GPs, with 16 reported to have prescribed, supplied or administered a drug with the explicit intention of bringing about death more quickly.
Photo: File.
In 15 of those cases, however, it was nurses who administered the drugs.
Researchers acknowledged the actions of the GPs would generally be understood as euthanasia, but the survey did not use that term.
In the survey, led by Auckland University senior lecturer Dr Phillipa Malpas, GPs were asked about the last death at which they were the attending doctor.
Of the 650 to respond, 359 (65.6 per cent) reported that they had made decisions, such as withdrawing treatment or alleviating pain, taking into account the probability that they may hasten death.
Some made explicit decisions about hastening death.
Of the 359, 16.2 per cent withheld treatments with the 'explicit purpose of not prolonging life or hastening the end of life”.
A total of 316 doctors gave pain medication taking into account that death might come sooner, but it was not the intention. Rather, the doctor may have taken the decision to make the dying patient more comfortable in their final hours.
Phillipa, who is a member of the End-of-Life Choice Voluntary Euthanasia Society of NZ, says the comparison between this and a 2004 study showed the involvement of nurses had increased.
'In the 2004 study, doctors and nurses were much more evenly represented,” says Phillipa, 'so I think that's an area that requires a lot more research.
'Because nurses didn't have a voice in this study, I feel that that's where we need to go next.”
She says it's positive to see that discussions with patients around decision-making in the end-of-life period had increased.
Those discussions centred on withdrawing treatments, withholding a treatment, or alleviating symptoms and pain with sedatives.
The figures showed that in around 43 per cent of cases there was discussion with patients.
In 45 per cent of cases there wasn't, with nearly three-quarters of patients considered incapable of having that discussion.
But in 38 cases, despite the GP judging the patient capable, there was no discussion before a decision was made.
Phillipa says that because sometimes it's a clinical judgment that the action was the best one for the patient, or a discussion might have done more harm than good.
Often the GP had discussed decisions with the nurse and the patient's partner or relatives.
The research follows a recent poll by New Zealand Doctor and IMS Health, in which about 13 of 110 doctors surveyed admitted assisting a 'terminally ill and suffering” patient to die.
This week Parliament agreed to hold an inquiry into euthanasia laws, following the death of right-to-die campaigner Lecretia Seales.



1 comment
Possibly prolonging misery?
Posted on 24-07-2015 16:45 | By Annalist
I hope one day we can choose the right to end our lives decently and free of pain when all medical hope is lost. Currently we seem to live well beyond our use by date and that is the real problem. It's not really that death is being hastened but that life is being prolonged at any cost by medical intervention.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.