Company fined for listeria contamination

A meat processing company, a director and an employee have been fined a total of $192,500 for selling listeria-contaminated meat to Hawke's Bay Hospital and others, including Tauranga Hospital.

Bay Cuisine has also been fined for intentionally deceiving regulators by omitting test results that revealed the contamination.


Photo: File.

The Hawke's Bay District Health Board discovered cold ready-to-eat meats supplied by the company were contaminated in July 2012, after several listeria cases had been linked to the hospital kitchen.

The outbreak claimed the life of 68-year-old Patricia Hutchinson on June 9 that year, and contributed to the death of an 81-year-old woman on July 9. Two other people were infected.

Cold meats were also supplied to Tauranga Hospital, but there were no links found between the contaminated meat and two listeria cases in the Bay.

Bay of Plenty Medical Officer of Health Dr Phil Shoemack confirmed to SunLive in 2012 that there were two cases of listeria infections reported to the public health unit.

At the time, Phil said after an extensive investigation the authority was confident the people contracted listeria, a food-transmitted illness, while in the community, not through food in Tauranga Hospital. Read more here.

Last month, Bay Cuisine pleaded guilty to five representative charges of selling contaminated food, one charge of suppressing test results and one charge of omitting to provide information to the ministry.

Production manager Christopher Mackie pleaded guilty to one charge of suppressing test results and one of omitting to provide information.

Company director Garth Wise pleaded guilty to one charge of omitting information.

The company and the two men were sentenced by Judge Bridget Mackintosh in Napier District Court on Wednesday morning.

Crown prosecutor Grant Burston said the starting point for a fine against the company should be at least $250,000, or half the maximum available.

The offending was amongst the worst possible as it involved deliberate deception of a regulator during an investigation into a listeria outbreak and prevented the regulator taking immediate action, said Burston.

The men faced a maximum fine of $100,000 or up to five years prison for the charges they faced.

Lawyer for the company and Wise, Jonathan Krebs, said there had never been any intention to sell contaminated product and the intention to deceive the regulator was not pre-meditated.

The decision to omit the results had been done in 'the heat of the moment”, Krebs said.

Listeria was only found at low levels in the omitted test results, and the fine suggested by Burston was 'simply excessive”, he says.

'All offences of deceit are not the same,” he adds.

Mackie's lawyer, Bill Calver, says Mackie had not been aware that any level of listeria meant it could not be supplied to potentially at-risk consumers such as hospital patients.

Calver says Mackie, who still works for the company, was a 'hard-working, conscientious man” who had 'let himself down”.

Judge Mackintosh says the level of listeria found in the omitted result was potentially hazardous for vulnerable people and that was 'pretty jolly serious”.

She said the decision to deceive had been intentional and the offenders must have known the risk their offending posed to those people at greatest risk of contracting listeria.

She fined the company $130,000, Wise was fined $32,500 and Mackie fined $30,000.

When the health board discovered a link between the infections and the hospital kitchen it sent 62 unopened plastic pouches of Bay Cuisine meat products to ESR for testing. All the pouches were found to contain listeria.

The company had had the contract to supply the hospital since 2002.

On July 9, 2012, the DHB requested copies of all test results Bay Cuisine had carried out for listeria.

Mackie replied by telling the DHB a batch of corned silverside had tested negative for listeria, when in fact it had tested 'presumptive positive”.

The following day an officer from the ministry, investigating the listeria cases at the hospital, requested test results. Mackie sent these on July 13 but again omitted reports showing that some products had tested 'presumptive positive”.

But analysis of text messages between Mackie and Wise show that on the evening of July 12, Wise had sent a text to Mackie suggesting that he 'hold back the presumptive listeria ones [results] as there is only three or four of them and we just send the good”.

A subsequent search of the Bay Cuisine premises by the ministry found the company had not provided the original, correct spreadsheet to the ministry. This spreadsheet showed positive listeria tests for meat products on June 18 and July 10.

Other charges to which the company pleaded guilty related to meats it had provided to various outlets between May and July 2012.

0 comments

Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.