Public claims that Tauranga Hospital's Emergency Department's unprecedented number of patients are due to high GP fees are being refuted by the Primary Health Organisation.
Earlier this month, the Bay of Plenty District Health Board reported nearly 50,000 people presented to the ED last year – many deemed as better off visiting their GPs or a pharmacist.
WBOP Primary Health Organisation chief executive officer Roger Taylor. Photo: Tracy Hardy.
ED staff saw people for issues including constipation, irritating coughs, simple ankle sprains and some who had just run out of their medication.
All of which aren't emergencies, said Tauranga Hospital ED Clinical Director Dr Derek Sage.
Yet SunLive Facebook comments at the time stated this wouldn't happen if GP rates weren't so high and they had been able to see their GP.
One SunLive reader said: 'I think you would find that the majority of those people did not have a genuine emergency and are just using the place as their free doctor visit.”
Western Bay of Plenty Primary Health Organisation chief executive Roger Taylor says this isn't in fact the case, with doctors' fees not too high.
However, the PHO does appreciate that at times, some people find costs restrictive.
To work out doctors' fees annually, the Ministry of Health commission an independent economist to look at costs in primary health, such as nurses' salaries and medical equipment.
A percentage increase is then recommended so that general practices are allowed to increase their fees.
It's a percentage that in the last couple of years has been 'remarkably low” because of low inflation, says Roger.
'A number of general practices feel that that exercise has in fact not reflected the actual cost increase,” he says, 'because the actual inflation in health is far greater than the average rate of inflation in the economy.”
If the practice feels its fees are not adequate and is placing the practice under pressure, they are required to put in an annual return outlining this, which is considered by the PHO and DHB.
The DHB then have the option of referring it to the regional fees review committee.
The practice has the right to present figures, papers and arguments to the review committee to support its increase if this is above the national average.
It's a process that is remarkably vigorous according to Roger, and practices are often turned away.
GP fees across the Western Bay range between $6 and $44. Patients over 65-years-old at the NFK Family Health Services won't be charged, while at the Ngati Kahu Hauora this is just $6.
Patients aged 45-64 years visiting BayMed will be charged $44 and $43.50 at Central Med.
'It's an independent body that monitors practice charges to make sure they are reasonable,” adds Roger.
When asked whether it wanted to comment further on the issue and high ED rates, the BOPDHB referred any further comment to the PHO.


9 comments
GP rates
Posted on 14-07-2015 16:34 | By YOGI BEAR
Go from nothing to $60 or more for a little 15 minute shuffle in and out with haste. No wonder so many go to A&E, the price is the issue, the greed of GPS makes this happen, how can the price be so different. Then lets not get started on Surgeons raking a $1 million a year for part time job. The poor old taxpayer being slugged again.
Disagree!
Posted on 14-07-2015 17:00 | By jed
If you get a cold, sometimes you might need 2 or even 3 visits as the condition deteriorates. So, the $44 becomes $88 or $132. And, given the poor wages in Tauranga I bet people can be reluctant to visit the GP.
jed
Posted on 14-07-2015 17:42 | By YOGI BEAR
Agree, the number of visits is the thing, they always want more and more. It is all about more appointments so more money from the hard workers who cant afford always. Often stay home until really bad, not a good look really what ever way you look.
someone needs to face facts.
Posted on 14-07-2015 17:49 | By astex
Many people, after paying rent power and all other household costs have NOTHING left to pay any fees. The MP's need to face the fact that the numbers of poor, even "working class" is growing. New Zealand the way John Key wants it?
How many
Posted on 14-07-2015 19:37 | By tish
started off at the A&E at 2nd Ave and needed x-rays. They go home at 7.30 there so out of luck if you need one especially when you've waited over an hour before anyone assessed you. Or maybe sick at night, we have no doctors in town after 9pm and hugely expensive for a long wait in the waiting room, without even the "triage" they pat themselves on the back for supposedly supplying. It's a medical joke there.
Price NOT the issue ..
Posted on 14-07-2015 19:39 | By Murray.Guy
Any service that is free to the user will obviously be used (and abused) if the choice is paying. Washing machine died recently. Should have taken it to the ED as it cost $45 up front before anyone looked at it, then repairs costs. What's the hourly rate for your car mechanic, your lawyer?
ED Charges
Posted on 14-07-2015 20:07 | By Jitter
I believe the hospital ED should make a nominal charge to patients who turn up there instead of going to a GP just to help defray costs EG $5 or $10.No charge for emergency patients though.
ED Charges
Posted on 14-07-2015 20:07 | By Jitter
I believe the hospital ED should make a nominal charge to patients who turn up there instead of going to a GP just to help defray costs EG $5 or $10.No charge for emergency patients though.
It is no wonder
Posted on 15-07-2015 09:54 | By nerak
people balk at GP charges. A $36 charge for 3, yes three, minutes? No one can tell me GP charges are fair, or just, and the charge I mention cannot, in any way, be justified. And the patient returned to the practice 5 days later and saw his own GP, who prescribed correctly, not the young fella who was in a hurry to go home on the first visit. Not good enough, and we thought they are supposed to care. There's no care in a charge like that, it's not treating a patient, it's all about the money. Get your head out of the till, PHO.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.