Three Tauranga men who used a knuckleduster and knife to rob a Z service station of cash to purchase methamphetamine have been jailed for more than two years each.
Ari Jean Higgins, 22, was sentenced to three years and 11 months for his part in the robbery of the Cameron Road service station in June.
Kelvin Guttery, Ari Higgins, and Pukawa Shelford in Tauranga District Court. Photo: Luke Balvert
Kelvin John Guttery, 20, was sentenced to three years and 17-year-old Pukawa Allan Shelford received a sentence of two years and eight months' jail.
All three appeared for sentencing in Tauranga District Court on Monday after earlier pleading guilty to one count each of aggravated robbery and two counts of theft under $500.
According to police the three stole petrol from two other gas stations in Tauranga – at Tauriko and 15th Ave - before deciding to rob the service station on 11th Avenue on June 29.
Guttery and Shelford entered the service station about 10pm armed with a knuckleduster and knife. They demanded the lone 18-year-old female attendant open the till and fill a blue and yellow Puma backpack with cash.
They then took 20 packets of cigarettes and the $180 cash and fled the scene. All three were later arrested by police at a Jonathon Street address. Read more about the aggravated robbery here.
Crown prosecutor Jenna Heerdegen submitted a starting point of five and a half years imprisonment as the aggravated robbery was undertaken at one of the 'busiest” service stations in Tauranga.
'This has had an impact on the victim. She was a young female alone in the service station,” says Jenna.
All three of the men had shown remorse over the robbery and undertaken a positive restorative justice process, said their lawyers.
Shelford's lawyer Nick Dutch asked the judge that his client's age of 17 be taken into account in sentencing.
Judge David Cameron said there was a degree of planning and pre-meditation that led to the robbery, which left the attendant terrified.
'The victim was particularly vulnerable being a young female of 18-years-old,” says Judge Cameron.
'In my view all defendants are equally culpable; they involved themselves to some degree.”
Higgins received the longest jail sentence of three years and 10 months as the robbery took place while he was on bail and driving while disqualified.
Judge Cameron also added an extra month to the sentence for a drink driving charge. Two days before the robbery Higgins was stopped by police and found to have a blood alcohol reading of 211 milligrams per 100 millilitres of blood. The legal adult limit is 80 milligrams per 100 millilitres of blood. He was ordered to pay reparation of $227.15 for the blood analysis and disqualified from driving for six months.
Guttery was sentenced to three years and six months imprisonment and Shelford received two years, eight months taking into account remorse, previous good character and early guilty pleas.
All three are ordered to pay $172 reparation to cover the costs of the petrol stolen in the two drive offs and the amount stolen in the robbery.



3 comments
What is it with trio's?
Posted on 12-08-2014 13:55 | By GreertonBoy
Are these 3 trying to compete with the other 3 Don't people realise there are CCTV cameras everywhere? Crime is tending to pay less and less and the chances of getting caught are way too high to expect to get away with it? Grow up guys, get a job!
Dumb, dumb and dummer
Posted on 13-08-2014 14:26 | By The author of this comment has been removed.
These 3 have, for the sake of maybe $100.00 each have ruined their lives. This conviction means no overseas travel, no credit, no job, and no trust. If the drug P is that damaging who would go near it?
Nothing for the victim?
Posted on 04-06-2020 18:53 | By Omni
Being robbed at knifepoint will ultimately affect this young woman, very likely for the rest of her life. Where is her justice? These three young men should have had to write letters of apologies (acknowledging their selfish actions) and paid reasonable reparations to her also for the stress, no doubt hours of interviews and statements with police and the court system and for sleepless nights, stress and counselling she will likely need to help her recover from this horrific incident. Judges it' time to start thinking of the victims of crimes and making the criminals pay for their disgusting actions. Drink driving should also have received massive fines to go towards SAD or other drink driving education, not just one extra month on a sentence with free accomodation and fee feeds while they have a free ride and lounge around in a cell, thanks to the NZ taxpayer
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.