We've recently been subjected to ad nauseum to Gate Pa battle bumff via messrs Mikaere, Wilson etc.
The short Tauranga military campaign can be summarised succinctly as follows:
The NZ Government sent a substantial military force of Colonial and imperial troops to Tauranga in January 1864 to counter Maori insurgency.
On April 29, 1864, the NZ Government forces stormed the fortified Gate Pa site, being initially repulsed by Maori Kingite forces, who realising their days were numbered, scarpered overnight (a full retreat), finally being caught up with by government forces and roundly defeated at Te Ranga on June 21, 1864.
Gate Pa/Te Ranga statistics put government troop losses at 44 and Maori insurgent losses at 145, demonstrating who was victorious.
This campaign effectively finished the NZ wars, as far as Tauranga was concerned.
The following illustrates the overkill of current Gate Pa publicity:
Pythagoras' Theorem -24 words; Gettysburg Address - 267 words; US Declaration of Independence -1321 words; Magna Carta (including signatures)- 3856 words; History of NZ Wars – James Cowan (1870-1943), an authorative, definitive and reputable work: Chapter 42, Gate Pa and Te Ranga, pages 421-440 - 19 pages.
The five-part, 12-page Battle of Gate Pa lift-out, produced by the Pukehinahina trust - 60 pages and probably 30,000 words - seems disproportionate to the significance of the events.
Two weeks of revelry for something that has not previously been commemorated, when compared with our Kiwi National Day - one day; and Anzac remembrance Day - half-day - is way, way out of kilter.
R Paterson, Matapihi.


2 comments
AD NAUSEUM INDEED
Posted on 04-05-2014 10:07 | By crazyhorse
New Zealand history especially to do with any thing Maori is an ever changing, evolving or as the historians who now write their "version" like to call it, "revisionist", written to suite the times,get used to it Mr Paterson your fighting a losing battle if your looking for "truth". I have recently been studying Hongi Hika, this man would make the worlds worst serial killer look like a fairy but as history "revises" it seems he is a saint, a hero ,a martyr,misunderstood, (quote)'When Hongi Hika conquered new terrain,” says Professor Paul Moon of AUT University, 'he was motivated by utu. Only by utu.” Armed with 15 muskets, clad in steel armour, THIS MAN KILLED, ATE, TORTURED,ENSLAVED thousands of Maori, but, with modern updated "history" he will be come a NZ hero, I feel a full pardon for this man coming up, maybe another claim to the Waitangi tribunal,NAUSEUM!.
Lessons From a Battlefield
Posted on 05-05-2014 10:48 | By Jean S
I recently went to the ‘Battle of Gate Pa' walkthrough at Greerton Hall. The information was presented in a fascinating blend of historical facts from the time, narrated videos, reflections and large scenic backdrops which brought period artworks into colourful life. An understanding and empathy was generated with the combatants of both sides. Portrayed were England's slums and the internecine wars among Maori; the abundant supplies of foods and weapons of warfare. A theme that came through strongly for me was the reluctance of British soldiers and Maori warriors to fight each other but politics, greed, mis-placed power and underhand dealings swept even the missionaries and Christian Maori into a tornado of blood, death, and mistrust. The folk song Blowing in the Wind says it succinctly…..”when will we ever learn”. I pray that current events in the Ukraine will not sweep us all into another maelstrom of killing.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.