Actions in police chase ‘unjustified’

Bay of Plenty Police accept an independent report into a police pursuit of a fleeing driver in Tauranga that found the decision to pursue was justified, but actions during the pursuit were not.

The Independent Police Conduct Authority report released today found actions of one of the officers during the chase after an assault and carjacking in Tauranga City were ‘unjustified' and did not comply with police policy.

Tepee Snow Laison and Conrad Rewita were convicted of stealing a car from the Kingsview car park in May last year.

It found acts during the pursuit, that reached 94km/h on the wrong side of the 50km/h Cameron Road, placed the 'fleeing driver, members of the public and police at risk”.

The report relates to an incident that began at the Kingsview carpark in Durham Street on May 10 last year.

Conrad Oscar Rewita, 31, and Tepee Snow Laison, 34, admitted and were convicted of assaulting two people as they returned to their car about 3.20am. The pair, both from Auckland, then stole the 1999 Toyota Corolla, with Rewita driving.

After failing to stop for police a pursuit began where the stolen car was driven down the wrong side of Cameron Road and was still being pursued by police when it crashed at the roundabout, seriously injuring Laison.

Rewita was subsequently found to have a breath alcohol level almost twice the legal limit, and was charged with driving with excess breath alcohol causing injury, reckless driving causing injury and aggravated robbery.

He was convicted and sentenced to four years and six months' jail in August last year.

The female passenger was convicted of aggravated robbery and was sentenced to three years imprisonment on the charge, and unrelated charges of shoplifting, driving while disqualified, driving with excess breath alcohol.

The IPCA finds the pursuit complies with the police fleeing driver policy in terms of its initiation and communications.

But it says not enough weight was given to the increased risk of pursuing the stolen vehicle at speed on the wrong side of the road.

'We have no intention of handing over the roads to those who think they are above the law,” says Acting District Commander for Bay of Plenty Police, Detective Inspector Tim Anderson.

'The prison sentences handed down to these particular individuals reflect the disregard they had that night for both people and property, not hesitating to use violence for their own gain.

'The public tell us that they do not want criminals on our roads and in our communities, and offenders can expect us to make full use of our resources to hold them to account.

'However, we are also committed to maintaining high levels of safety and will continue to identify opportunities to improve and enhance our training and the way in which we respond to these situations.

'We always welcome independent scrutiny into these situations as it is an important part of ensuring transparency and accountability, and to identify lessons that can help improve our practices, policies and procedures.

'Fleeing driver incidents always present a real challenge to police. They are unpredictable, fast-paced situations with officers having to make equally fast-paced judgements and decisions, all the while balancing the risks posed by pursuits with the need to protect the public from the offenders.”

On the night of the incident police were informed by a member of the public that his Toyota hatchback had been stolen from the carpark, and pointed out his car to officers, who had seen it being driven on Harrington Street, says the ICPA report.

Police then followed the vehicle, activating the patrol car's lights and siren. The driver failed to stop and overshot a corner at the intersection of Cameron Road and Elizabeth Street, putting him on the wrong side of Cameron Road.

Both the Toyota and the police patrol car travelled at about 94km/h, close together, on the wrong side of the road in the lane closest to the median barrier.

After about a kilometre the Toyota hit the roundabout at the intersection of Cameron Road and 9th Avenue, lost control and collided with a street light knocking it to the ground. The Toyota then hit a tree on the median strip causing it to spin twice into the two left hand lanes before coming to a stop on the correct side of the road.

The male driver was treated by the police doctor at the Tauranga Police station while the female passenger was taken directly to Tauranga Hospital with a ruptured spleen.

In releasing today's report, the first resulting from a new multi-disciplinary team approach to investigations being adopted by the Authority, the Authority finds that the officers had reasonable grounds to attempt to stop the Toyota, given they believed the car was stolen. They were also authorised to commence a pursuit when the stolen Toyota failed to stop and attempted to evade police by speeding along Cameron Road.

Following the pursuit the officers learned that the male and female had assaulted the Toyota owner and his passenger as they got into the car, before they smashed the driver's window.

IPCA chair, Judge Sir David Carruthers, says although police complied with the law and policy in commencing, and communicating during the pursuit, the officer driving the patrol car did not give enough weight to the increased risk created by a pursuit at almost double the speed limit, on the wrong side of the road, and at a close distance of only two-to-three car lengths.

'The Authority believes that the pursuit may have placed the fleeing driver under further pressure, leading him to take greater risks with his driving,” says Sir David.

As a result of the incident the officer has undergone further training. The Authority makes no further recommendations.

10 comments

new policy

Posted on 01-05-2014 13:52 | By hapukafin

maybe its time to review the police policy on car chases. [alleged] criminals try running away from the police to avoid capture.the police should be allowed to continue a chase until [the fleeing vehicle] is caught,it will to start with save a lot of other wasted police time trying to find the person.


Really?

Posted on 01-05-2014 14:35 | By BJRice

You want to reprimand a police officer for trying to get an [alleged] dangerous criminal off the road? How did his actions put them at risk? THEY chose to flee, THEY chose to put others at risk. I hope he gets promoted instead.


Pursue them

Posted on 01-05-2014 15:23 | By YOGI BEAR

I have no problem with the NZ Police using all means to chase down offenders such as this. The crims need to know that there is no escape by "running" away.


.

Posted on 01-05-2014 15:37 | By Point Blank

Too much pc bs when it comes to police pursuits, who cares if the offenders hurt or kill themselves... I don't, If you don't pull over and stop when asked to by police then you are the master of your own destruction.


Blame the cops

Posted on 01-05-2014 15:54 | By morepork

So, the fact this idiot is being chased increases the risk of him doing something even more stupid? The police wanted him off the road and they succeeded in doing this. Good on them. It isn't the police who are responsible for increased risk when they pursue somebody. The risk is COMPLETELY removed if the pursued car simply stops. Any damage or death resulting from police pursuit, should rightly be placed at the feet of the pursued, not the pursuers.


What about this?

Posted on 01-05-2014 16:09 | By morepork

We can all agree that high speed pursuits are undesirable (no matter whose "fault" they are). Here is a very sensible alternative: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/04/can-cops-legally-fire-gps-bullets-at-fleeing-cars-to-track-suspects/ The pursued car has to be stopped to remove the tag(s) and it would be possible to "pursue" it by radio link to officers in the vicinity, instead of actually chasing it.


Time to get rid of the cottonwool

Posted on 01-05-2014 17:04 | By FunandGames

When deciding whether members of the public are at risk in these chases, the saftey of the fleeing driver is of no concern to me. They have the option to stop,crash or kill themselves. It's their decision. It's only other members of the public and police saftey that should determine whether to continue the chase or not.


THE SCORE

Posted on 01-05-2014 19:25 | By FSTUART

Police 2 Scumbags 0


Who gives a rats ass about the safety of the fleeing driver

Posted on 02-05-2014 09:46 | By Annalist

I can understand the Authority being concerned about public safety but why are they concerned one bit about the fleeing driver? If they are so concerned about public safety what will they do to ensure these idiots are never allowed on the road again? Probably nothing. I'd like to see members of the Authority get involved in real frontline policing. By the way, just what do they get paid for their pronouncements?


Training

Posted on 02-05-2014 11:21 | By sheild

The following web site shows some driver training Police in London go through and offer this to the public. http://www.driving4tomorrow.com/ Ive seen from experience the New Zealand Police doing an amazing job when in a chase. The offenders chose to continue driving on the wrong side endangering other users The officer was given no choice. If that fleeing car hit someone else on wrong side of road who would have been at fault I have seen them stop a chase and offenders keep going even though no one was following. In this case the car was stolen the driver was drunk The Police deserve a pat on the back for getting them off our roads


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.