Bald tyre fines ‘last resort’

The likelihood of vehicle owners receiving instant fines for bald tyres is slim, as Tauranga City councillors look to begin discussions on the controversial plan next week.

Parking wardens were originally due to begin checking vehicles for bald tyres as an extension of their normal duties on April 1, instantly fining motorists $150 per dangerous tyre.

Tauranga City councillor Catherine Stewart believes giving motorists fines for bald tyres is a job for police, not parking wardens. Photo: Tracy Hardy.

The proposal, announced by TCC on March 19, was met with widespread outcry and debate from Tauranga City councillors and the general public.

As a consequence, Tauranga City Council announced on Monday the proposal is on hold until a long-term solution can be made.

TCC communications manager Frank Begley says the decision is due to upset with the proposal.

'We are now waiting for confirmation of what the elected members want to do. 'There is no further change at the moment, our parking officers are going about their business as usual.”

Councillors are scheduled to formerly discuss the issue at the next City Vision Committee meeting on April 15.

But Deputy Mayor Kelvin Clout is confident they can make some decisions before then.

Any early decisions would be made without Mayor Stuart Crosby and councillor Matt Cowley, currently on a 12-day trip to Yantai in China and Hitachi in Japan.

'It's not the sort of thing that requires special council resolution so we don't necessarily have to wait for a formal solution,” says Kelvin.

'I'm pretty sure we should have something that we can let everyone know what our position is well before the 15th.”

Kelvin says the general consensus among councillors is to avoid fines.

'Issuing fines would be a very last resort, that's kind of where we're leaning toward.

'There is a legitimate safety concern, but by the same token we don't want to be living in a police state, so it's getting that balance right.”

Councillor Catherine Stuart says meetings will discuss key concerns expressed by the community.

These include the role of parking wardens, what councillors believe the community expects, whether fining for bald tyres is a job for police, she says.

'My personal thought is that is if parking wardens see a really bald tyre they should put a note on the screen, but I don't think they should be fining people, that's a police job.”

Catherine is pleased the proposal was put on hold, and says to enforce it without proper discussion would not have been democratic.

'Firstly without elective members' influencing the decision, and secondly without the community knowing the rational and reasoning behind it.”

The proposal was to coincide with New Zealand Police's TWIRL campaign, which began on April 1.

13 comments

Tyre Awareness

Posted on 04-04-2014 11:45 | By mutley

Right now would be a great time to promote Tyre Awareness Week see the link: http://tyresafety.org.nz/how-to-check-your-tyres/#tread-depth . This would be much more use than the endless griping on about the fine and posturing by Politicians on the matter. The real story should be educating the motoring public on how to be better drivers.


Parking wardens

Posted on 04-04-2014 11:50 | By Jimmy

Should have ONE job, to ensure a car is parked legally and paid for, NOTHING ELSE, ONLY check paid parking spaces, stay away from the free spaces, and stop pretending that they have authority of police enforceable fines.


Just dump it

Posted on 04-04-2014 11:58 | By Chris

We haven't needed this policy in the past and we don't need it now. Council needs to accept that this idea was WAY overstepping their role, and they need to quietly back away from this policy entirely.


If you don't want a ticket, have safe tyres

Posted on 04-04-2014 12:26 | By Annalist

I can't believe the rubbish spouted about this fair proposal that can only improve road safety for ourselves and more importantly our loved ones. Why should law abiding people pay to have properly maintained cars while others get away with dangerous ones? I'd be outraged to think that some poor child crossing the road was struck by a car with braking with bald tyres if that could have been picked up by any form of check? The reasoning behind a proposal to ticket bald tyres is obvious, safety. Let's hope sensible councillors get behind it and leave the publicity seeking ones to oppose everything as they usually do.


Concerned citizen

Posted on 04-04-2014 12:51 | By shanksnz

As the traffic wardens would not be allowed to use tyre depth gauges their judgement would leave them in a pic carious situation if they got it wrong


Police underfunded

Posted on 04-04-2014 14:01 | By Papamoaner

The police have been crippled by under resourcing by successive governments. It is a deliberate move to duck-shove minor enforcement onto local bodies, thereby making ratepayers fork out for enforcement. That said, extrapolating some of the arguments on here, we should not report bank robberies because that is the job of the Police. Get real guys, if you don't have bald tyres, you have nothing to worry about, but if you do, then you deserve to get clobbered. As for parking wardens, they are a necessary evil and it takes a certain kind of person to really enjoy doing it apart from the odd one who has little choice because it is at least a job (of sorts)


Don't Go There Girlfriend

Posted on 04-04-2014 14:17 | By Disappointed

This is not just about bald tyres. It is about the arbitrary granting of authority to council employees who do not have the expertise nor the experience needed to overcome even the most basic of legal challenges. More importantly for this city however is the ongoing punitive mindset of local bureaucrats that is making the downtown area a most unattractive place to spend time.


@ANNALIST

Posted on 04-04-2014 15:48 | By Colleen Spiro

Why don't you analyse the fact that we pay to get a warrant and a rego......yes we pay for that....if they were REALLY INTERESTED IN SAFETY......Leave a ticket giving you time to get it fixed, and waive the fee. Better still don't do it at all....In OZ they do not have warrants.....GO FIGURE!


PARKING

Posted on 04-04-2014 15:53 | By sangrae

I agree with jimmy the wardens should be doing just that and nothing else,parking legally and paying the appropriate amount they are parking wardens only,not policeman come on councilors be brave and set the example.


Sigh of relief I would imagine...

Posted on 04-04-2014 17:20 | By groutby

For the wardens who were being asked to enforce this idiotic idea for gathering more revenue. Let's hope the idea gets scrapped and leave it to the people duly trained for this job. Let's not forget who requested this, as I understand it the TCC CEO (and faithful followers I imagine)is behind this...so...what's next for him to do and then hide behind?...he gets paid by the City...the ratepayer....US !!.


Solution v. Problem

Posted on 04-04-2014 21:12 | By penguin

Solution v. problem Quote:...”the proposal is on hold until a long-term solution can be made..” A solution is normally associated with a problem. So far the council has not identified the problem. Therefore, one can only assume that the idea came from someone experiencing a sudden, illogical rush of blood to the head!


Off Tauraunga City Centre

Posted on 04-04-2014 22:11 | By surfgirl_4573

I rarely go to Tauranga City Centre. It's simpler and easier to just free park at Bayfair or Palm Beach Plaza. This tyre fine is pathetic and fraught with repercussions. Will they have calipers for accurate measurement or will there be grounds for legal argument.


its not that hard

Posted on 08-04-2014 15:52 | By fraserb

just have a safe roadworthy vehicle. simple. @annalist - true that Aussie don't have WOF checks but it is your responsibility to keep your vehicle up to safety standard, just as is the case here between WOF checks. tyres wear, just check them occasionally. personally I think any vehicle found not up to standard should be seized and crushed, no arguments, no appeals.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.