A Mount Maunganui man has been sentenced to home detention for drunkenly stabbing a 16-year-old foreign exchange student in 2011, narrowly avoiding a more than two year prison sentence.
Max Andre Roberts was sentenced in Tauranga District Court on Wednesday on charge of wounding with reckless disregard following the altercation on November 27, 2011.
Police at the scene on The Strand.
Roberts pleaded guilty to the charges in February after a jury of 12 failed to reach a verdict at trial in 2013.
The charges relate to an incident which happened at about 3am on November 27, 2011 when Roberts threw a glass of liquid on the victim's friend before following the victim and his friend to a toilet block near The Strand.
It is while here Roberts insulted the Brazilian exchange student telling him he wasn't welcome and should go back to his own country.
He then punched him and hit him over the head with an empty beer glass causing it to shatter against his face and cut him causing 'his head to bleed profusely”, said setencing Judge Christopher Harding.
The student needed more than 20 stitches to a gash in his head and further stitches to his hands from the shattered glass.
'It's had an ongoing effect on him. It was the end of his exchange programme in New Zealand; he has returned home thinking the worst of his experience,” said Judge Harding.
Crown prosecutor Nick Belton said an appropriate starting point is between two years three months and two years nine months based on three aggravating features; the large and obvious cut to the face, the seriousness of the injury, and the attack with an empty beer glass.
Robert's lawyer Bill Nabney said Roberts was clearing drinking at the time and it was obvious alcohol affected his actions but he has been on onerous bail conditions since the event and has learnt his lesson.
'His issues with alcohol have long passed.
'A sufficient starting point is two years in prison but a sentence of home detention is now appropriate.”
The judge agreed with the crown on cut to the face and the seriousness of the injury but didn't accept that the glass was used as a weapon in the attack.
Judge Harding said Roberts had "clearly taken the opportunity to learn" sentencing Roberts to 11 months home detention, 150 hours community work and ordering him to pay $5000 emotional harm reparation to the victim.



2 comments
Joke
Posted on 20-03-2014 13:45 | By maildrop
Another Judge with a finger on the pulse. I wonder if he'd been smashed over the head with the glass whether he would view it as a weapon. No doubt all three elements of this so called sentence will be ignored.
Joke?
Posted on 22-03-2014 23:20 | By Anon985
This happened 3 years ago, when the alleged was 19. Is it not possible that a kid made a mistake, turned his life around and is now doing the right thing and facing the consequences? Not to mention he has already spent 3 years on bail which he obviously complied with. It is unfair to pass judgement so easily.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.