Public input on rates rise

The public is yet to have its say on the whether Tauranga City Council's rates increase will this year be 2 per cent or 6.7 per cent.

The difference is the 4.7 per cent stormwater levy that got approval by a single vote to be included in the Annual Plan discussions at yesterday's council meeting.

The mobile library service is one of the items on the chopping block to raise funds for the Greerton Library.

So far cutting the rate is going to cost the city its mobile library service, and mean an increase of parking wardens in the suburbs.

When the mobile library service was last threatened by council in 2010, it sparked a huge public backlash with the council receiving 171 Annual Plan submissions protesting the move.

The mobile library is being sacrificed to help pay for the Greerton Library.

Speaking after the meeting councillor Matt Cowley says the council needed to find $60,000 for operational expenditure within the library budget or the project wouldn't have got in the plan.

'We explored other options, such as closing all libraries on Sundays or reducing technology support services, but councillors felt access to libraries and information is critically important,” says Matt.

The mobile library costs $104,000 per year to deliver only 2.7 per cent of the total library issues. A lot of people with disabilities cannot climb up onto the bus, says Matt.

'We're keeping $35,000 in the budget to have a home delivery service for those in need, those who can't leave their home.”

Schools that use the mobile library can instead get bulk loans.

Given the other options for finding operational expenditure within the library budget in order to deliver a new Greerton Library, councillors are happy for the community and library users to discuss the trade-off decision - a bigger Greerton Library or a mobile library, says Matt.

'Bang for buck suggests Greerton Library is the way to go, given that we're keeping the home delivery service,” says Matt.

Councillor Catherine Stewart says the proposal to raise money by unleashing more parking wardens, counters the council's stated aims of attracting more people into the city.

TCC transportation manager Martin Parkes says council receives complaints about the city parking bylaws not being enforced outside the city, Mount Maunganui and Greerton business districts.

The traffic department estimates there is enough parking work in the suburbs to pay for additional staff and still make money.

Mayor Stuart Crosby's call for a steady as she goes budget was rebuffed by councillor Steve Morris.

He says it's not a people pleasing budget. Council has been taking four times more than the community is earning.

'The patient is ill,” says Steve.

'The medicine is unpleasant but the patient requires it. This is what financial discipline looks like.”

The 4.7 per cent is intended to set aside $5 million for flood repair works that are said to cost anywhere between $40 million and $200 million.

The opposition says the figures aren't in, the true amount of work and money required is not known and because of the project's possible magnitude, they think it is better discussed as a Ten Year Plan issue.

Those supporting it see the measure as a prudent means of salting away funds from those who benefitted from council decisions that resulted in the mess.

Since they began working on the city finances in December the councillors have managed to trim $11.2 million from the city capital expenditure.

Spreadsheets made public yesterday show the Annual Plan options chosen so far still leave a rates increase of 8.3 per cent.

Staff have been directed to have another look at the figures including the removal of a $1.5 million debt retirement fund. Removing it will reduce rates another 1.3 per cent.

It is a strategy that is close to splitting the council. The decision putting the stormwater levy out for public consultation survived by one vote. Those in favour include Kelvin Clout, Steve Morris, John Robson, Catherine Stewart, Rick Curach, Bill Grainger. Those against are Stuart Crosby, Matt Cowley, Bev Edlin, Clayton Mitchell, Gail McIntosh.

The reviewed figures will be returned to council's final decision on March 14.

8 comments

Robust Debate

Posted on 11-02-2014 13:21 | By FunandGames

From the outside looking in, I don't see a council close to splitting. I do however see some robust debate forcing issues to be addressed and debated. Exactly what I want from my councilors.


Overit

Posted on 11-02-2014 14:32 | By overit

I hope the Council/Libraries have monitored how many people use the Libraries on a Sunday. This seems a bit over the top to me, especially with the modern age of computers for information.


Tui anyone

Posted on 11-02-2014 14:41 | By rayzgirl

"Councillor Catherine Stewart says the proposal to raise money by unleashing more parking wardens, counters the council's stated aims of attracting more people into the city." BUT we have always been told that parking tickets and meters are not a means of revenue gathering - yeah right


silly

Posted on 11-02-2014 15:13 | By rotovend

wouldnt b more cost effective for the over-paid councillors to drive people to the library rather than have a mobile library or get kindle into homes as everything will b electronic soon and libraries will b a thing of the past


Here's an idea.

Posted on 11-02-2014 16:26 | By Honki

How about TCC saves the $100k for the mobile library by trimming all councillors salaries by a few $k each? Bet that hasn't been considered


But will they take any notice?

Posted on 11-02-2014 16:47 | By Annalist

And if so, who will they take notice of? With 4 libraries around the city and public transport, the mobile library is a small sacrifice but isn't going to save much. Council pays large yearly grants to sports and arts groups. Will those grants be looked at? Maybe it really is time for a dose of Cr Morris discipline.


Unecessary spending.

Posted on 11-02-2014 19:01 | By Robert

Greerton Library is just another nice to have being pushed by a few. Lived in Greerton for years and have never been in there when there was a crowd. Given that books are moving to devices we could well go until our debts are paid to a low level before we need to spend more money on a white elephant. I am all for people reading, its to be encouraged but there are new and better ways. Just look at newspapers. Light bulb moment; they are on line now and less and less on dead trees.


Libraries

Posted on 11-02-2014 20:15 | By Accountable

Will go the way of video libraries.We are seeing more people with e-books and I-pads with as many free books available that anyone could wish for. Save money by not building the Greerton library as it won't be needed in five years time.Take a look at how many and the age of the people that are wanting the Greerton library upgrade and do the maths. It is not an economic proposition for Council. It would be cheaper to buy them all an e-book.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.