Convicted salesman admits breaches

A Mount Maunganui car salesman convicted of assaulting a Fair Go reporter investigating his dealings has admitted to making false and misleading representation about cars sold at the yard.

Almost three years after the Commerce Commission launched its investigation into the operations of former Mount Auto Court director Alan Spiers and his finance company MAC Warranties Limited, a total of 28 charges have been laid for breaching the Fair Trading Act 1986.


Alan Spiers in Tauranga District Court in 2011.


Fair Go reporter Gordon Harcourt outside Tauranga District Court in 2011.

In Auckland District Court last week Spiers pleaded guilty through his lawyer to 11 charges of providing false and misleading representation about vehicles that breached the Fair Trading Act. His attendance in court was excused.

The charges, under section 13i of the Act, relate to information provided in documents sent to debtors and descriptions of vehicles sold from the Totara Street yard.

His finance company - MAC Warranties - was also convicted of 17 charges under the same Act for providing false and misleading representation. Two of those charges relate to false claims the vehicles were of a particular ‘standard, quality, grade, quantity, composition, style, or model'.

A Commerce Commission spokesperson confirmed the charges but could not provide further comment as the case is still before the courts.

SunLive also understands MAC Warranties has sent out letters to former affected customers offering compensation.

The letter states that in the context of the commission's investigation ‘MAC has made certain admissions that aspects of the repossession process and onward sale of vehicles breached the Fair Trading Act'.

As part of the arrangements made with the Commerce Commission – the government watchdog - ‘MAC has voluntarily agreed to make a compensatory payment to affected parties'.

TVNZ's Fair Go began investigating the dealings at the Mount car yard, and the finance company MAC Warranties, both owned by Spiers at the time, in 2011.

The basis for the investigation was the ‘closed system' operations between Spiers' finance company and car sales yard in the sale, financing, repossession and re-sale of vehicles from the yard.

One of the complainants Fair Go reported on had purchased a vehicle from the car yard, which targeted low income customers, on finance from MAC Warranties. But just before paying it off it was repossessed.

Fair Go reported the car had a Warrant of Fitness and registration but MAC Warranties told the customer it was an $800 ‘wreck'. The repossessed car was valued at $800 by Turners Auctions, and a claimed $3000 was spent on reconditioning the car, before it was back on the Mount Autos lot for $6995.

In July that year Harcourt went to confront Spiers about his dealings for a segment on Fair Go when Spiers, supported by his staff, began a confrontation with the television crew at his Totara Street yard that ended with the reporter being punched three times in the head.

Harcourt suffered a black eye, a bleeding nose and a suspected concussion.

Spiers then damaged the camera being used to film the segment.

The incident took place on public property on the footpath outside the dealership, and at the time Harcourt refuted claims he had gone into the dealership and was on private property.

In September 2011 Spiers was convicted in Tauranga District Court of assaulting Harcourt and intentionally damaging the camera equipment which had filmed him at the time.

Spiers was ordered to pay $1573 reparation to the reporter and $616.80 for the camera equipment. Read more about the assault conviction here.

The Fair Go reporter told SunLive he is pleased the business dealings of Spiers have finally come to a fore.

'It's extremely satisfying that this Commerce Commission investigation is finally coming into the open.

'I started looking into the way Alan Spiers does business more than three years ago, and I rapidly learnt the Commission was investigating too.

'I've learned a great deal of very troubling stuff. I think there's a lot of people in the Bay who need to know what's been going on.”

Spiers will be sentenced in Auckland on March 20.

2 comments

hope

Posted on 05-02-2014 08:28 | By mutley

Let's hope that the sentence will in some way equate to the pecuniary gain derived from the crime and perhaps compensate those who have been robbed.


No sympathy

Posted on 05-02-2014 11:07 | By dakota

I have no absolute sympathy for this person actions nor does he even repute for what he has done to people...i can say i see this guy walk around the Mount without a care in the world, your a disgrace to yourself and the certainly the people who had been foolish enough unbeknown to them to purchase. I hope justice is served with cream and a cherry on top.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.