Jail threat forces re-think

A Tauranga woman appearing in court on her third drink driving charge has been stood down to consider her options after being told she was going to jail if she couldn't accept a community-based sentence.

Moira Erin Burke, 52, appeared in Tauranga District Court on Monday for sentencing on her third drink driving charge in as many years.

Photo: file.

Judge Peter Rollo says the recommended sentence of community detention, supervision and community work isn't acceptable for a third drink driving offence in three years.

When he asked if there was any good reason why she couldn't do home detention, the Judge was told Burke wishes to do a nursing degree next year, and that she's caring for a 17-year-old daughter.

Drink driving is not a victimless crime, says the Judge. Alcohol is a contributing factor in seven out of 10 recent deaths in the Bay of Plenty. In addition 27 per cent of drink drivers commit a third or subsequent offence within two-and-a-half years.

'And you are much less; three offences within a three year period.”

Trying to keep the knowledge of the offending from her employer was not the point, says the Judge. 'Her actions are against the law and anti-social.”

Following a drink driving conviction in 2010 Burke was sentenced to undertake several courses, which were not completed for various reasons.

'It does raise the prospect that had those courses been completed, you might not have been here today,” says the Judge.

Saying he was considering a nine-month jail sentence, Judge Rollo stood it down.

Burke was convicted and remanded on bail until Friday, December 20, for sentencing.

2 comments

not getting the message

Posted on 15-12-2013 14:45 | By vonnie

When is this woman going to learn that it is NOT cool to drink and drive and potentially put innocent peoples lives in danger..maybe a jail sentence is the only solution..


Pathetic sentences the real problem

Posted on 15-12-2013 18:35 | By Phailed1

Forget reducing the current alcohol limit observed my most drinkers, and get tough with repeat offenders. But by the looks of it much easier for the justice system to penalise the decent people by reducing the alcohol level but at the same time go easy on repeat offenders with sentences like home detention? Wow.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.