A Tauranga man jailed for making false allegations against the police of sexually violating and assaulting him has seen his appeal against the sentence dismissed.
Andrew Francis Neilson, 42, is currently serving a two-year-and-two-months jail sentence after being found convicted of wilfully perverting the course of justice in Tauranga District Court on August 27.
But in the Court of Appeal's report released on Thursday, Neilson's claims of Judge Louis Bidois failing to give adequate regard to mitigating features were dismissed.
In June, Neilson elected trial after a police investigation earlier found he made false allegations of officers assaulting him on the roadside and in a police car during his arrest on New Year's Day in 2011.
Neilson and his partner were stopped by police on James Cook Drive in Welcome Bay at about 10pm on January 1, 2011.
Neilson's partner was driving on an expired licence and police impounded the car, leaving the couple and a friend to find other transport back to their Greerton home. When police informed Neilson the car was to be impounded he became angry and got into a heated argument with police.
More police arrived and Neilson was arrested, restrained and carried to a patrol car and forcefully placed inside.
Neilson complained he was assaulted and sexually violated by police, who he says stuck an item, perhaps a torch, through his jeans into his anus.
Read more about the trial here.
But in the Court's report, Justice Raynor Asher says the appeal is dismissed due to Neilson's culpability arising from his deliberately false claims of serious wrongdoing by the police, supported by fabricated evidence.
'While initial allegations may have been spontaneous, there was particular premeditation involved in Mr Neilson returning to the police station the next day and making a formal complaint.
'This was compounded by Mr Neilson harming himself to fabricate evidence to support his false claims.”
Justice Asher says Neilson persisted with the false claims for more than two years until his trial in June 2013.
'It would appear that, during the course of the trial, he abandoned his contention that he had been anally violated, but continued to maintain his false claim that he had his face smashed against the pavement and the car by the police officers.”
Justice Asher says the offending involved serious and unfounded allegations of misconduct by police – dealing with a violent and confused situation.
He adds the allegations were an attack on the integrity of the police and the administration of justice and includes causing suffering to the officers involved and wasting police resources.
'We consider the factors listed show a high degree of culpability on the part of Mr Neilson. Taking into account the aggravating features and culpability that we have summarised, we consider that the starting point of two-and-a-half years to be entirely within the available range.”

.jpg)

0 comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.