Jailed for Waihi Beach killing

A Waihi teenager who stabbed ex-pat Kiwi Robert Murray Wilkinson in the side of the head on New Year's Day, has been sent to jail for eight years.

Israel Kaihau, 19, was sentenced to the prison term with a minimum non-parole period of four years after being found guilty of the 64-year-old's manslaughter in October.


Robert Murray Wilkinson died after being stabbed in Waihi Beach.

Kaihau buried a knife 8.5 centimetres into the ex-pat's head after being asked to leave the Beach Road property.

Murray, as he was known to friends and family, was rushed to Waikato Hospital but died a couple of days after the stabbing.

Doctors say the knife had sliced through to the other side of his brain.

Kaihau was arrested following a police investigation earlier this year and was sentenced in the High Court in Hamilton yesterday.

Justice Robert Dobson ordered the teenager to complete the new prison term once he had finished serving his current sentence for other charges of assaulting two different women, to recognise the fact Kaihau was on bail when he committed the manslaughter.

During his sentencing, Kaihau's lawyer Paul Mabey, QC, raised the issue of totality and the argument Kaihau would be punished too severely for the same crimes was dismissed by Justice Dobson.

Justice Dobson told Kaihau that he dismissed his version of the attack, describing it as "implausible".

Murray's family feel the manslaughter verdict didn't serve justice for their loss.

In a statement read out by crown prosecutor Ross Douch, Murray's wife Luise said she had resorted to taking anti-depressants following the loss of the love of her life.

She said she no longer sleeps properly and since the trial in October has suffered panic attacks, anger and loneliness.

'I am serving a life sentence of pain and torture.”

15 comments

to short

Posted on 30-11-2013 08:57 | By whatsinaname

This sentence is far to short. He has taken a life, and after reading the article it seems as though he committed other crimes while on bail........He deserves Life in prison.....


An i for an i

Posted on 30-11-2013 09:26 | By The author of this comment has been removed.

He may do four years. In days past he would have been taken into town, flogged and put into stocks and be humiliated. Then sent overseas to never return to our shores. The namby pamby wishy washy justice system is no deterrent. Does anyone have a better answer though?


Disgusting!

Posted on 30-11-2013 09:31 | By monty1212

This country hasn't got a clue about justice! We continue to see time and time again idiotic unjust sentences when criminals virtually walk away from committing serious crimes with hardly any time to serve. This is such a case and for a criminal who has killed someone to probably walk free after 4 years is an absolute disgrace.


What a pathetic sentence?

Posted on 30-11-2013 10:57 | By Annalist

I can't help but wonder if those involved in the "justice" process ever suffered from a member of their family being killed what they would then think of light sentences. A good man's life is taken forever, but trash lowlife can infest the streets again potentially in 4 years time???? Come on government, time to act with mandatory sentences.


Pathetic sentence...

Posted on 30-11-2013 12:09 | By earlybird

The victims family have a life sentence and this waste of space gets 8 years with a possibility of being out in 4. There is no JUSTICE in NZ anymore. I know a longer sentence wont bring back the victim but it may just stop someone from carrying & using a weapon on a future victim. I'm not sure that a person such as Israel Kaihau should ever get out of jail to walk the streets again.


just wrong

Posted on 30-11-2013 14:49 | By gingerpussy

he has offended before and when let out he will offend again. Lock him up for good.....


unbelievable

Posted on 30-11-2013 15:07 | By whatsinaname

the justice system in nz is a JOKE. He will have three plus good cooked meals a day. lodgings etc and look forward to being free again in 4 years.... what has his victims family got to look forward to. bring in flogging etc like the others have mentioned. make the punishment fit the crime to deter others. worse thing of this case he was on Bail. I do not believe in Bail.


Kiwi Justice

Posted on 30-11-2013 15:49 | By zarak

The problem with this country is that the Law is made and applied by men living in safe environments, where crime is seldom experimented. The day their wives or daughters would become victims themselves of the crime statistics, then a new Law-Tune would be written.


So thats what a life is worth

Posted on 30-11-2013 16:01 | By lpm67

All I can say is Blo*dy H8ll!


Overit

Posted on 01-12-2013 07:47 | By overit

Get in behind the Sensible Sentencing Trust. Put your energies there people.


a joke

Posted on 01-12-2013 14:19 | By Capt_Kaveman

hes 19 then release him at the same age 64 even in this case 20yrs does not seem long enough


Pathetic

Posted on 02-12-2013 08:09 | By Starman

Yeah that will teach him a lesson - what a joke - a good man's life for 4 years on the tax payer - what next home D for killing someone? Absolutely disgusted with weak judiciary.


No justice

Posted on 19-12-2013 08:00 | By drgoon

Hopefully he ends up being someones girlfriend while inside....


This is becoming all to common...

Posted on 26-12-2013 08:52 | By kiwigrunt

Murder used to be so rare in new zealand, now its almost a daily occurrence, why? Because there is no real consequence. Life in prison is just a waste of money, better it spent on health, education etc. I think its time this country grew a pair and look at bringing back capital punishment. He will just come out worse, jail is in no way rehabilitative..


a joke

Posted on 26-12-2013 17:17 | By coffeman

got to laugh at NZ sentencing laws! LOL no seriously.. I mean NZ really is a joke when it comes to how we punish people! someone has been murdered! and the guy who did it will be out in 4 years! LOL ohhh NZ really is a playground for criminals!


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.