Jury finds teen not guilty

A Waihi teenager has been found not guilty of the murder of an ex-pat Kiwi fatally stabbed outside a caravan on New Year's Day.

Israel Kaihau, 19, was on trial in the High Court in Hamilton for the murder of Robert Murray Wilkinson.


Robert Murray Wilkinson died of stab wounds he received in the driveway of a property he was holidaying at with his wife Luise on New Year's Day.

The 64-year-old was stabbed in the neck and head on January 1 and was taken to Waikato Hospital where he died two days later.

Kaihau has denied the murder charge.

The jury began deliberating at 1.30pm today before returning the unanimous verdict of not guilty on the charge of murder, but finding Kaihau guilty of manslaughter to Justice Robert Dobson at 5pm.

He will be sentenced early next month.

During the trial the court heard how Kaihau was on bail and supposed to be at home when he decided to attend a party in Waih Beach on New Year's Eve.

After leaving the party, and being asked to visit another one, Kaihau was avoiding police when he hid in bushes at the Beach Road property where Wilkinson, also known as Murray, and his wife Luise was staying.

At about 1am Luise exited the caravan where she found Kaiahu hiding in the bushes. They had a conversation before she returned to the caravan. A few minutes later she heard her husband tell Kaihau to leave the property or he would call police.

She then walked out to find her 64-year-old husband had been stabbed in the head and neck.

In his closing submissions, Crown prosecutor Ross Douch said Kaihau had shown no credibility on the stand, reports Waikato Times.

Kaihau had previously testified that he had not intended to kill Wilkinson, and had simply reacted quickly when Wilkinson had tried to wake him from a drunken stupor and stepped on his sore leg. That evidence was dismissed by the prosecution.

'The only thing [Luise Wilkinson] heard was her husband speaking and this terrible bang. No cursing, no swearing ... then he stabs out at somebody,” said Douch.

'Mr Wilkinson had no defensive wounds. Mr Wilkinson, in simple terms, didn't have a chance ... didn't see it coming.”

In his closing case, defence counsel Paul Mabey, QC, told the jury of 12 they were not here to 'take revenge” on behalf of Luise Wilkinson and a verdict of manslaughter must be returned.

'You're not here to put the record straight, but to determine whether or not this young man is guilty of murder.”

Kaihau had a knife on him the night of the killing, but "he's not on trial for carrying a knife", said Mabey.

'He hid evidence, he burnt some clothes, he's not here for burning evidence. He lied to police. He's not on trial for lying to police ... just because someone lies, doesn't mean they're guilty of the charge they face.”

Mabey said Kaihau was in good spirits on the night of the killing and Luise, who had spoken to Kaihau before her husband was stabbed, described him as polite and non-threatening.

It's not feasible that a "happy, drunk boy become a cold-blooded killer because a householder said, 'I'm going to report you', said Mabey.

'There was no sign of aggression or anything about his conduct that evening that would even suggest that he was out looking for trouble.

'All that's required here is that you have a reasonable doubt about the case and you must find him guilty of manslaughter.”

9 comments

Wake up!

Posted on 24-10-2013 19:15 | By VC

A smooth talking defense lawyer and a gullible jury. Kaihau was in good spirits all right, plus. Why carry a knife going to a party that he should not have been attending anyway. Wake up NZ!


guilty

Posted on 24-10-2013 19:47 | By Calm Gully

he might not be on trial for burning cloths and lying to police BUT isn't lying perjury? Why lie if you've got nothing to hide. If he had been doing the right thing by his bail conditions it could have all been avoided. Sad society.


Really?

Posted on 24-10-2013 20:06 | By compton

Don't understand how you can stab someone in the neck and head and think that they will not die.


Unbelievable

Posted on 24-10-2013 20:49 | By maildrop

Everyone might as well go around with a knife. If you use it and kill the only person who knows the truth just make up your version, get Mabey QC to defend you courtesy of the tax payer, and be out before you're 25. Easy.


Sorry Luise

Posted on 25-10-2013 09:16 | By Jerry66

Im so very sorry Luise for the total lack of justice shown by our Court system once again.We all know how quickly our moods can turn when intoxicated.This guy was not supposed to be on the streets in the first place. Nothing but total life in jail can begin to pay back the wrongs he has committed.


A person

Posted on 25-10-2013 09:37 | By Fonzie

who stabs someone who questions him is not out looking for trouble so says his lawyer!


Has killing someone become trivialised?

Posted on 25-10-2013 09:56 | By Councillorwatch

I feel for the family of the man who was killed. I wonder how the many participants in the so-called justice system (lawyers, juries etc) would feel if it was their family member who was dead? I wonder on what side of the argument they would then sit?


The law is an Ass

Posted on 25-10-2013 12:37 | By The Sage

Front page story on today's NZ Herald about this case. I am so sorry for Mrs Wilkinson and her family. This thug was drunk, carrying a knife and on a property that he had no right to be on. Then he stuck the knife in the head of Mr Wilkinson, he murdered him in my view.


So it's that easy

Posted on 25-10-2013 13:19 | By RawPrawn

Just drink to excess, become a "happy, drunk boy" and you can do what the hell you like! Simple!!


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.