Fraudulent cleaner sentenced

A Mount Maunganui cleaner who spent more than $26,000 of benefit fraud on bills, food and court fines has avoided jail after defrauding Work and Income during a 17-month period.


Tracy-Lee Kilye Tucker, 30, obtained $26,807.53 by deception from Work and Income New Zealand.

Tracy-Lee Kilye Tucker, 30, was sentenced to seven months home detention and 200 hours community work in Tauranga District Court after admitting to three charges of dishonestly using a document, one charge of obtaining by deception, and one charge of forgery with intent it be acted upon.

In the 17 months from June 1, 2011, to December 10, 2012, Tucker claimed a total of $26,807.53 in overpayments from the Domestic Purposes Benefit while married to Karanpal Sandhu, an Indian resident.

On January 18, 2011, Tucker applied for and was granted the DPB through WINZ. On signing the agreement she agreed to immediately advise the Ministry of Social Development if there were any changes to her circumstances that could affect her entitlement to the benefit.

From information received, inquiries were carried out and it was established Tucker was married to Karanpal on June 1, 2011, and did not advise the Ministry she was living with him. She was still living with him on the day her benefit ceased.

On September 5, 2011, and January 23, 2012, Tucker completed and filed Temporary Additional Support Re-application forms; and on December 13, 2011, completed and filed a Work and Income Review form. On all three forms she stated she was single and did not have a partner.

As a result, the Ministry continued paying her the DPB.

When her partner made an application to New Zealand Immigration Service for residency based on his relationship with Tucker, she was asked to provide a letter from WINZ regarding her receipt of the benefit.

Tucker used a WINZ letterhead and typed and signed a letter outlining to be a case manager in Tauranga, advising she had been receiving the DPB from January 13, 2011, to May 30, 2011, when it was cancelled and she re-entered a relationship and employment.

This letter was presented to NZ Immigration Service on November 20, 2012.

When interviewed about the matter on March 13 this year, Tucker told officials she was aware of her obligation to advise the Ministry but failed to do so. She claimed this was because they were struggling financially due to immigration and lawyer's fees relating to her partner's immigration matters. The money was spent on bills, food and court costs.

In sentencing, Tucker's lawyer Jason Owers says an appropriate sentence is a term of home detention with community work something which aligns with the Ministry's stance – although the pre-sentence report indicates imprisonment.

Jason adds the real issue with imprisonment relates to personal circumstances surrounding her daughter and partner.

'She is dealing with a troubled daughter and is currently being home schooled. Her daughter is suffering from anxiety issues,” says Jason.

With 16 previous convictions of dishonest behaviour, these matters do paint a bad picture for his client, says Jason.

Tucker's previous convictions include using her parents' personal EFTPOS card in 2001, using an employer's visa card in 2009; and in 2010 transferred funds dishonestly.

Jason says his client has been paying off the significant debt at $50 per week since June 2013.

'She is someone who needs to change her lifestyle,” says Jason.

Judge Peter Rollo sentenced her to seven months home detention along with 200 hours community work to 'put something of value back into the wider community”.

She is also ordered to pay back $15,000 of the total amount, continuing at $50 a week.

1 comment

Overit

Posted on 08-09-2013 10:38 | By overit

16 previous convictions eh. So is struggling financially a reason to be dishonest and rob the taxpayer. There are thousands of people struggling too.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.