Te Puke man found not guilty

Te Puke man Gurcharan Singh has been found not guilty on all four charges relating to the stabbing of three men last year.

After an eight day trial a jury of 11 people took four hours to deliver the not guilty verdict this afternoon.


The jury in the trial of Tauranga man Gucharan Singh have returned a not guilty verdict.

The 37-year-old Indian national had denied one count of common assault, wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and two counts of wounding with reckless disregard.

Judge Robert Wolff agreed with the jury's decision saying he had come to the same conclusion after hearing the evidence in the trial in Tauranga District Court.

During the trial the defence argued that Singh had acted in self-defence when confronted by his ex-flatmate during a heated argument at a house the pair were living in at Te Puke.

On the night of June 27 Singh and former flatmate Manjinder Singh got into an argument about dinner.

Manjinder then left the Boucher Avenue property and a returned a short time later.

While Manjinder was gone, Singh grabbed the knife from the kitchen and went outside to hide. When Manjinder returned with two other men, Singh was hiding in a tree.

The defence said Singh came down from the tree and started to wave the knife around in an attempt to get the men to back off.

It's then that Manjinder was stabbed in the left side of his body with a 21cm blade.

Two men came to Manjinder's aid and were cut as Singh continued to wave the knife around.

All four men, including Singh who was beaten with a hockey stick, were taken to Tauranga Hospital.

During the trial the Crown argued Singh armed himself with the knife and laid in wait for Manjinder to return to the property with the intention of attacking him.

In their deliberations this afternoon, the jury of 11 unanimously decided Singh, who has been in police custody for the last 12 months, was not guilty on all four charges.

Judge Wolff believed had the police had the benefit of an interpreter at the time of the incident on June 27, 2012, the whole case would have been handled differently and statements at the time would have been clear.

1 comment

Cops

Posted on 05-09-2013 17:16 | By maildrop

The Judge says if the cops had an interpreter the case would have been handled differently - I thought the cops job was to gather the facts. How on earth can you do that impartially if you fail to get someone to intepret the guys side of the story. Sounds like he was a victim trying to defend himself. It never ceases to amaze me how the cops act as Judge before the facts are known. They get a theory and then make the case fit around it. Now they arrest him as an overstayer after keeping him locked up for 14 months! Give the guy a chance to get his visa sorted. The KGB had nothing on this crew.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.