6:25:06 Friday 19 September 2025

School model 'political interference'

Former Tauranga Primary principal Jenny McNicol says today's 'political interference” of the Tomorrow's School model is rendering the model redundant because schools are powerless to make important decisions.

After more than 40 years in the education sector, Jenny retired from her 17-year stint as principal on July 12 and says one of the biggest changes to the country's education system, since her first teaching job in 1968, was the introduction of Tomorrow's Schools.

Former Tauranga Primary School principal Jenny McNicol retired on Friday, July 12. Photo: Daniel Hines.

Tomorrow's Schools was the result of 1989 reforms to the New Zealand education system designed to increase schools ability to self-manage.

The changes saw the replacement of the Education Department, education boards and school committees with an independent Ministry of Education, Education Review Office and board of trustees.

While the reforms were designed to allow schools to take more inside initiative, Jenny believes that power is now being pulled back to the Government.

'More recently we've seen what I would like to call the political interference to pull the power back to central Government. The responsibility still stays with the school, but the real decision making has gone back to politicians I think.”

Jenny's first job as principal was in 1986 under the old system governed by the Department of Education. In 1988 Jenny became principal of Te Puru School when school administration underwent major changes with the inception of Tomorrow's Schools.

An example of schools not having control is the recent debate to increase class sizes, says Jenny. She says her first class was small but grew to 42 students in her second year of teaching.

'We try and keep the class sizes down today, but they're still not at optimum size. Again that's a political call it's not something the schools have decisions over.”

As Jenny closes the door on more than 40 years in the education sector, she looks forward to a well-earned rest.

She and her husband have bought a house at Lake Rotoiti and next year the couple plan to visit Canada, where Jenny spent 2005 on a teaching exchange.

'I'd like to think I've done what I can to inspire and encourage kids to be the best they can be. It's a bit of give and take.

'I've had some wonderful experiences being a teacher and I would hope that other people would share that sentiment with me.

'I think it doesn't take you long to realise that you can make a real difference in someone's life and you work to do that. But what you get back in return is often greater than what you can give.”

Deputy principal Fiona Hawes is stepping into the role and says she is looking forward to starting her ‘dream job' as principal of Tauranga Primary School when Term 3 commences on July 29.

3 comments

Rant

Posted on 21-07-2013 11:06 | By Plonker

Them that does the paying does the saying, free wheeling education decisions at the school level have resulted in the dumbing down of the overall education results in NZ, the numbers clearly show NZ falling down the ladder at tertiary levels, the roots of the cause of that start at prima one!


@ Plonka

Posted on 21-07-2013 14:40 | By laugeo

So, you think that individual schools and teachers decide on the curriculum to be taught? You think they decide on what the latest and greatest 'thing to be changed or improved is going to be? Education in general is now a constantly moving feast of 'initiatives' and miracle cures - ALL decided at a national level and all without consultation with those actually delivering the outcomes of those decisions. There is little if any opportunity anymore for schools to actually cater directly for the needs of their clientele. The only thing that remains the sole domain of the school and the teacher is the blame for what is not being achieved. If it is working well, government want the acclaim, if it is not, blame the teachers. Despite what you obviously think, schools are NOT free to do what they know needs to be done. They are hamstrung, legislated to and then blamed."free wheeling education decisions at the school level" Chance would be a fine thing! Jenny McNicol is right, 'political interference'!


@laugeo

Posted on 22-07-2013 11:50 | By Sambo Returns

and on the flip side, (not the left wing one), teachers are all to ready to whinge and whine if things are not going their way,think back to "Novapay", which a Labour government signed off on!!!, I am all for less interference, but not for political gain, education should come first!!!, not point scoring, all teachers have got to be on one page and agree on a system that works, and educates, so stop complaining and do something about it!!!!, or simply comply and work with a system that has been put in place, and stop being so negative.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.