Action over deer theft 'unfair'

Two Waikato teenagers originally charged as part of an illegal poaching ring have been fined after admitting to stealing two deer worth $1000 each.

Matamata's Scott Darroch, 18, and Storm Panapa, 17, appeared in Tauranga District Court on Thursday where they pleaded guilty to one count each of theft.

Two teens have been fined for stealing two deer from a Pyes Pa farm.

The pair were arrested in March along with co-accused Maunganui Charlie Panapa, 24, and Bradley McKenzie, 19 following raids on properties in Matamata.

The raids were part of a police investigation into an illegal poaching ring operating in the Bay of Plenty.

At the time police alleged the pair were part of the illegal poaching ring responsible for the theft of 130 rusa, red and fallow deer, valued from $700 to $4500 each, from properties in Pyes Pa, Te Matai Road, Oropi and Rotorua between January and December last year.

Darroch was originally facing two charges of theft of an animal and one count of unlawful hunting but police prosecutor Sergeant Barry Woon yesterday withdrew the unlawful hunting charge, and one count of theft.

Storm Panapa had one count of theft of an animal withdrawn and pleaded guilty to the remaining count of theft and unlawful hunting.

According to the amended summary of facts, on December 7 around 10pm Darroch, Storm Panapa and a youth had driven from Matamata over the Kaimais to Tauranga.

Darroch parked the ute down the road from a Pyes Pa deer farm where Panapa and the accused youth, who is being dealt with in Youth Court, jumped the fence, shot two fallow deer and loaded them on the back of the ute.

They then drove back to Matamata with the deer.

Darroch's lawyer Paul Mabey, QC, argued police publicity about his client is 'wrong” and that his client had suffered after being named as part of an illegal poaching ring, which he was not.

Both were first time offenders and Paul says his client pleaded guilty to one charge of theft but there is no proof he was involved beyond that.

Judge Wolff fined the two each $750, plus court costs of $132.80. They were also ordered to pay reparation of $330.33.

Judge Wolff told the pair he hoped the publicity they received over their offending is enough to keep them clear from court in future.

'Hopefully this means you have had one brush with the law and this is your last.”

Paul told SunLive outside the courtroom that police have a responsibility to ensure their publicity is accurate and if people are named there is a good reason to justify the charge.

'The police had complaints about deer thefts, which may or may not be correct.

'But to name my client as part of a ring was completely unjustified and unfair.”

'Mr Darroch is an 18-year-old first time offender and not a major criminal as portrayed by police.”

Maunganui Panapa, 24, had his charges dropped when he appeared in court on June while Bradley McKenzie, 19, was convicted and discharged. A youth, who cannot be named due to age, is still being dealt with by the Youth Court.

Paul says if there is a major deer poaching ring the culprits have not been found.

2 comments

good for the goose good for the gander

Posted on 18-07-2013 12:47 | By truck

Maybe Paul Maybe and the rest of his merry band of defence lawyers might like to follow what he has said about the police and also tell the whole story instead of abridging the truth in order to help their clients evade the consequences of their actions. A bit more of these people being held accountable for their actions would go a long way helping the crime rate or do we go and enter his place and take something hard earned (which is not possible on what lawyers charge out on legal aid - hard earned that is) then listen to them squeal.


huh

Posted on 18-07-2013 20:29 | By Capt_Kaveman

130 rusa, red and fallow deer, valued from $700 to $4500 someone has their maths very wrong in reparation


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.