Sister appealing prison sentence

A Tauranga woman serving a seven year prison sentence for violently beating her sister during a dispute also involving a pitbull is appealing her sentence.

Phillipa Bayley, 55, was sentenced to prison in November 2012 after being found guilty of wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm to Liz Smith.

Phillipa Bayley and her pitbull puppy at the city pound in June, 2012.

Bayley admitted to attacking her sister with a stone chess piece, leaving Smith with multiple tears to her scalp and face which required surgery. Bayley's pitbull puppy also attacked the victim.

Bayley is appealing her case to the Court of Appeal in Auckland, asking for a year off her sentence because she did not purposely set the puppy on her sister.

During her appearance yesterday, Crown lawyer Brett Tantrum said Bayley held her sister down while the dog attacked her, but Bayley is disputing this claiming the dog didn't cause the injuries.

Back in November, a 12-strong jury unanimously decided the pitbull was involved, but could not agree on whether Bayley deliberately made it attack.

Judge Robert Wolff at the time of sentencing said he was certain Bayley purposely made the dog attack.

Bayley was arrested and charged with wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm after the dispute on May 21, 2011. She claimed her sister provoked the attack by scratching her in the face and punching during the argument.

In Auckland yesterday, Justices Robert Dobson, Anthony Randerson and Patricia Courtney reserved their decision.

0 comments

Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.