Sum total of NZ culture?

So a visitor from Denmark, Ms Marie Krarup has touched one of Dr Ranginui Walker's numerous raw nerves. Perhaps he should reflect on the words of the Scottish Poet and sage, Robbie Burns who in 1796 wrote; 'O wad some Pow'r the giftie gie us To see oursels as others see us...” or must such honest observations made by a visitor be damned as racist?
What other country in the world welcomes visitors with a physically threatening challenge followed by a war dance?
That the haka and the moko are perceived internationally as the sum total of New Zealand culture is completely unacceptable to most Kiwis today as is the necessity for groups of Maori to get free, tax-payer funded trips overseas to perform unintelligible rituals at the opening of any government building. The insidious way in which these practices have become almost mandatory should be curtailed. Performances that may have been novel, worthwhile and even inspirational in the eighteen hundreds are completely inappropriate in the modern era. But then there would be no koha.

Bryan Johnson, Omokoroa.

13 comments

National embarrassment

Posted on 12-04-2013 15:01 | By The Big Tomatosaurus

You hit the nail on the head! This rort and embarrassment has been costing us taxpayers for too long. Its a national embarrassment, not a national treasure.


Agreed

Posted on 12-04-2013 19:30 | By PLONKER

Yes indeed it is all SOOOO embarrassing and to call in NZ culture is so far off the mark, these ritualised prancing around only serve to show how little culture there was. Just take a look at Rome, at least they built a Collossem to butcher others and animals in a civilised manner, at least the otehrs had a sword and stood a little chance rather than butchered in bed at night by way of ambush. If I missed the "culture" part please do let me know where possibly to find it.


untitled

Posted on 13-04-2013 14:42 | By [email protected]

So true!It is not a greeting , but a challenge to potentially visiting enemies, and not a civilised manner in which to greet inncocent visitors and it is getting worst. Maoris have been given special rights under our separtist laws. Maori are not the indigenous people of New Zealand. you can't be indigenous if you are the 6th group of people to arrive here. Ian Brougham Wanganui


Intimidation

Posted on 14-04-2013 12:12 | By PLONKER

Nothing less is what it is intended to be. It is for sure refreshing ot hear from someone overseas with an untainted view of what it really is.


She was just being honest

Posted on 15-04-2013 07:36 | By Papamoaner

It might not have been wise diplomacy, but Marie's comments did no more than reflect the embarrassment the majority of Kiwis also feel. If it had been said about some other bare bummed culture, it would have gone un-noticed, but here in ultra sensitive touchy feely New Zealand where loud uncouth minority groups rule the majority, we get a storm in a teacup over anything silly.


Makes me cringe.

Posted on 15-04-2013 09:00 | By 1 FRE MN

Makes me embarrassed to be a New Zealand when I see that sort of performance being conducted at any time. For crying out loud we should be past all that sore of posturing and open public threatening that is displayed at the drop of a hat . I just hate to think that the rest of the world thinks that we all run around carrying on like that. Time for New Zealand to get out of the past and show some modern maturity.


Cringe culture

Posted on 15-04-2013 18:57 | By Papamoaner

Yes I agree, and if you look at most of the comments here, we are unanimous. But who is listening to the majority? Don Brash tried it, and look what happened to him. The problem is that most of us normal people are moderate and we don't jump up and down about stuff like the edge people do. It's called apathy, but we're not apathetic, we just don't know what to do about it. The long term outlook is not good for our country because resentment is gradually building up in an insidious way. We will all be dead when it boils over, but I worry about our young people and their future.


Cringe from the fringe

Posted on 16-04-2013 09:38 | By YOGI

Papamoaner, agree on all counts, the PC brigade over rate their imporance, often labeled as racists and whatever. When that is said there is clearly no basis to justify the point at all so they can only resort to desperate calls like that, these have nothing to do with reality.


embarrassment

Posted on 16-04-2013 09:54 | By Captain Sensible

The haka.....national treasure or national embarrassment? Definitely national embarrassment! Then there is the cost of paying these "culture" groups for their seemingly daily displays. Yawn, we are over it.


???

Posted on 17-04-2013 21:35 | By Johnnyredneck

Can you suggest an alternative that represents unique NZ culture? Probably not.


@ Johnnyredneck

Posted on 18-04-2013 15:58 | By Captain Sensible

Why is showing off our "culture" necessary? Most countries were far more advanced. Besides, maori only represent 15% of the population. What about the remaining 85%....do we ever get an opportunity? Probably not.


Capt S

Posted on 18-04-2013 23:32 | By Crash test dummies

Sorry mate Maori are about 7% not 15%. The factor you have not considered here is all about not perhaps considered is that advanced civilisations often consider it amusing to look on to the odd ways of much lesser cultures almost as a comic type show.


Johnyredneck

Posted on 19-04-2013 08:29 | By crazyhorse

How about a smile and hand shake like the rest of the world, what are you talking unique nz culture, some over weight guy with man boobs sticking his tongue out and shaking his fist at every one, get a life.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.