Brown says no hybrid council, no Crown observer

TaTauranga city commissioners Shadrach Rolleston, Bill Wasley, Stephen Selwood, and Anne Tolley. Photos / NZME.

Local Government Minister Simeon Brown has confirmed Tauranga City Council will return to fully elected governance in July despite requests for continued central Government involvement.

He says the city’s success is critically important to New Zealand’s success.

Simeon’s statement comes after revelations the city’s Government-appointed commission had recommended a councillor/commissioner hybrid council, and twice asked for the appointment of a Crown observer, once its term ends at the election on July 20.

The Bay of Plenty Times revealed on Thursday the commission, made up of chairwoman Anne Tolley, Bill Wasley, Shadrach Rolleston and Stephen Selwood, asked the minister in December to change legislation to allow for a hybrid model of four commissioners and five elected councillors after the election.

The commission did not receive a response on this and last Friday wrote asking for a Crown observer — a request the minister in the previous Government, Kieran McAnulty, had already rejected.

In a statement to the Bay of Plenty Times on Thursday, Simeon says democratic council elections and representation would return and encouraged people to stand to be part of the new council to “lead Tauranga forward”.

“The people of Tauranga have been clear that they want to see a return to a fully elected and democratically accountable council. I am pleased to confirm that this will happen at the upcoming election in July,” he says.

“I want to confirm to the people of Tauranga and the commission that there will be no hybrid model of governance following the July election. Nor will there be Crown observers. Tauranga will return to being a full democracy.”

A council-commissioned report and the commission’s December 19 letter, both recommending the hybrid model, were released to the Bay of Plenty Times under the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act.

The report stated the 60-40 split would keep “the commissioners’ institutional knowledge” while avoiding the “significant risks” of an abrupt return to full democracy.

In late 2020, then-Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta appointed the commission to replace the city’s council, which was deemed too dysfunctional to continue.

The commission’s term was later extended until July 2024 to provide stability and deliver complex projects — preventing the city’s participation in the 2022 local body elections. The move prompted protests and community action.

This year five ratepayer groups came together to call on the minister to intervene and reduce the commission’s role to that of “caretaker” leading into the election.

Simeon yesterday made clear he has “no intention” of intervening in the commission’s role or that of the elected council after the election.

Tauranga residents will have the opportunity to elect a mayor and councillors to lead the city through to 2028, he says.

The four-year term will be a first for New Zealand, which usually sets three-year terms for local councils.

“Newly elected members will be given the opportunity to assume the full responsibilities of their role,” Simeon says.

“I want to encourage people who care about the future of Tauranga and the challenges this city faces in regards to infrastructure, housing, economic growth and productivity to stand to be elected and to be part of that new council which will lead Tauranga forward,” he says.

“The Government stands willing to work with the new council as we have with the commissioners, and to continue to support this city to grow and to unlock the potential that this city has because Tauranga’s success is critically important to New Zealand’s success.”

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Local Government Minister Simeon Brown. Photo / Mark Mitchell.

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon says last month Tauranga would probably be “one of the first” places involved in its plan to make “10-year city and regional deals” with councils on critical infrastructure.

Nominations for Tauranga’s election open on April 26.

Kiri Gillespie is an assistant news director and a senior journalist for the Bay of Plenty Times and Rotorua Daily Post, specialising in local politics and city issues. She was a finalist for the Voyager Media Awards Regional Journalist of the Year in 2021.

- Kiri Gillespie, Bay of Plenty Times

7 comments

Well….

Posted on 20-04-2024 12:10 | By Shadow1

wadayaknow, Simeon is listening when no one else is. The Commission’s turkeys have come home to roost. See ya later guys.
Now it’s time to get stuck in and elect the best Council we can. There must be plenty of people out there who will make great councillors and at least one who isn’t a spoilt multi- millionaire.
Personally I would like the new council to embargo new projects for 12 months and get the maintenance sorted. Tauranga has never looked so scruffy since the Commission was established and it has to be that the maintenance has been starved of money, money that has been used elsewhere. Then and only then should they look at “ nice to haves”.
Shadow 1


Great

Posted on 20-04-2024 13:01 | By an_alias

Now the job of reigning back this un-elected TCC "public servants" is needed.
Lets hope there hands are not tied, I just wish the 4 could be held accountable for the absolute terrible spending they have put in place.
16% tax increases every year in a recession environment, destroying local CBD business, I for one having lived here all my life will have to consider moving if the tax burden is not reduced.


Good!

Posted on 20-04-2024 15:09 | By Astradaz

I am delighted the commissioners are going. Local democracy may not always be pretty, but it is democracy.


You're outa here!!

Posted on 20-04-2024 15:14 | By OG-2024

Get out and stay out!

New Council you better be up for this


Drop a line...

Posted on 20-04-2024 17:26 | By morepork

... to Simeon Brown (I did, and I copied Chris Luxon, David Seymour, and Sam Uffindell...) expressing your relief that he has stood firm and done the right thing. [their emails are formatted as: name.name@parliament.govt.nz]. Minister Brown has had to deal with secret connivance, and some outrageous, undemocratic proposals. Whether you agree or not with this government (and I'm sure there will be many issues we can debate with them...) they were elected to ensure Democratic government, and it seems that is something they are determined to carry through. Mahuta's idea of Tikanga based government with no right of dissent or voice, where the Boss is always right and his whanau ride the gravy train, was rejected at the last election. Minister Brown has taken a hard decision and deserves credit for it.


@Shadow1

Posted on 22-04-2024 12:51 | By morepork

I don't think it matters whether Councillors are multi-millionaires or plain working people. The single MOST important criterion for working on Council (IMO) should be RESPECT FOR OPM. After that, a genuine desire to actually help the people of Tauranga, and submergence of personal ego into working as a team for the overall good. We need people who can communicate and don't just think that the one who shouts the loudest wins the argument. Most of the attributes you find in good managers are the same as we need in the new Council: Honest, approachable, sensible, prepared to listen as well as talk, and generally capable of seeing things through and motivating others to help them do that. I hope we will see much more community involvement (especially at the concept stage), with public voting on possible projects and priorities BEFORE they are started.


Further to Community transparency.

Posted on 22-04-2024 13:22 | By morepork

It might be a very good thing for the new Council to FREEZE all NEW projects (unless they are absolutely essential) for, say, 6 months, until the existing Works in Progress can be reviewed and rationalized. We need to have a clear picture of what is being inherited and MUST be done (whether we like it or not) and what we can have discretion over. (It may require Government help to cancel, decompose, or postpone, millstone vanity projects if the new Council decides to do that) We also need to establish current debt levels and plans for addressing them.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.