Thousands of mechanics could lose their jobs if changes to the country's vehicle licensing system including increasing the time between warrant of fitness checks on vehicles goes ahead, says a Mount Maunganui mechanic.
The owner of a Mount Maunganui automotive workshop says the Vehicle Licensing Reform proposed changes will have a significant impact on the industry as businesses will be forced to restructure - leading to job losses.
'We will be in a hell of a panic. People are going to lose jobs and it's in the thousands.”
The Motor Testing Association released a discussion document on Thursday as part of its Vehicle Licensing Reform proposing changes to the current system that will result in an increase in the time between warrant of fitness and certificate of fitness inspections for vehicles.
The four options to be considered are: yearly inspections for vehicles up to 12-years-old, six monthly thereafter; undertaking a first inspection at three years followed by annual checks thereafter; inspecting vehicles based on the distance travelled; inspecting vehicles when they change owners.
All include measures to encourage safe vehicles.
The changes will save motorists up to more than $200million a year.
The automotive shop owner, who does not wish to be named, says the scariest option is to only test when ownership changes. He says if the Government were to go ahead with this option some workshops would be forced to close.
Tauranga MP and Associate Transport Minister Simon Bridges says the Government is interested in gaining the public's opinion on how to improve vehicle testing.
'We want to hear from as many New Zealanders as possible about the options we have presented and any other ideas they may have to make it the best possible VLR in New Zealand.”
MTA spokesman Ian Stronach says the primary focus of the reform is the maintenance or improvement of road safety outcomes and all four options need to be considered with that in mind.
'Care now needs to be taken to ensure that this progress is not reversed through the introduction of changes that may carry considerable risk.”
Simon says there is a possibility the Government may need to implement safety requirements alongside the proposed changes.
'Although we inspect less we need more thorough inspections.”
He says another option will be to target where the dangers occur rather than just testing everyone every six months regardless of whether the vehicle poses any risks.
Ian says the Government is assuming vehicle defects currently make little contribution to road crashes and reducing the frequency of vehicle inspections will have no impact on crash rates.
'MTA consider this is overly optimistic and represents a considerable risk to all road users if those assumptions prove ill-founded.”
Simon says New Zealand inspects vehicles almost more than any other country within the Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development.
He agrees Australia has a substantially better safety record than New Zealand 'because they do other different things.”
Simon says the VLR could replicate Australia's system where police target unsafe vehicles and issue demerit points based on the vehicle's condition.
'We want to see if we can create a system that is cheaper, and saves time for Kiwis, while also having similar or even better safety outcomes.”
Ian says there should be no changes to the current system unless there is a stronger commitment to education on maintaining vehicles and significantly more police enforcement.
While that might be achievable in the longer term, it is likely to result in a transfer of costs from motorists to government thereby defeating the very aims the reforms set out to achieve.
NZTA Chief Executive Officer Mike Walsh says it's not the changes he is concerned with but more about 'looking at the options”.
'From our point of view our concern is around vehicle safety on our roads.”
Mike says what MTA is looking at would present higher risks in road safety and says the Ministry of Transport has admitted the four options present crash risks.
'If you take the worst case scenario - yes there would need to be sizable adjustments in the market and as a result that would impact a lot of businesses.”
There is a possibility the vehicle testing station on Hewletts Road will be closed before Christmas 2012.
A VTNZ spokesperson says the closure of the vehicle testing station is not due to the Vehicle Licencing Reform proposed changes.
Instead VTNZ says the closure is due to a number of reasons including the lease to the building ending just before Christmas 2012.



10 comments
MY PLAN WOULD BE
Posted on 21-09-2012 12:59 | By TERMITE
Must do: - VTNZ needs to stay as it is an independantly run outfit that carries out inspection, that we all need. But otherwise New vehicles after 20,000kms, 100,000kms, 150,000kms then six monthly after that until scrapped. If an important then a full inspection then kms etc as above. that would be good I reckon. The risky cars are the old ones + high kilometers so test them more.
WOF Checks
Posted on 21-09-2012 13:25 | By Donnaw
Im happy to get my car warranted every 6 months and i think it should stay that way.....if the govt really wants to help us save money in this area, like they say they do, why dont they cut the cost of car registration, i am sure everyone would be stoked if they did that.....People need to be aware that if they are trying to push the Australian system then yes they do not have to get a six monthly warranty check BUT their Rego charges are horrific, around about $100 per cylinder, per year, and i think this is exactly where the the govt are heading...... I assume the govt receive more revenue from car registrations than they do from WOF checks.....and i think this will end up biting us all the the arse....
In Europe...
Posted on 21-09-2012 13:30 | By SpeakUp
...WOF is every TWO years. New cars are first tested after THREE years. Age has no implication. The typical fee for a car is €50, trailer w/out brake €20, for a motorbike €40 and for trucks/trailer/bus 7t €65, 12t €80, 32t €100. NB: Trucks (3.5 -7.5 tons) have a top speed limit of 80 KpH on ALL roads, INCLUDING motorways. Anything over 7.5 tons has a speed limit of 60KpH (80 KmH only on motorways).
Rastus
Posted on 21-09-2012 14:27 | By rastus
It's about time we came into line - Testing a modern vehicle every six months is a joke - certainly make penalties for having a dangerous vehicle on the road very severe but a test once every 12 months at least until the car has done 150,000 km plus or say 10 years old should be quite sufficient. Another way would be to have a maximum number of Ks between tests rather than time between tests. - whatever - there has to be a better way than our present system.
Just the start to higher fees.
Posted on 21-09-2012 19:52 | By dgk
I was talking with someone from Sydney about this today. And yes, they are every year. But, they also have registration that is much higher than ours, along with compulsory insurance. So, you end up paying at least $800 a year for that yearly WOF etc.... And anyway, the only thing wrong with our system is mechanics who don't have a clue what the WOF rules are.
MTA?
Posted on 22-09-2012 00:25 | By tibs
Vested interests at work here, the MTA own VTNZ and have worked solidly in some cases to remove WoF issuing from garages. The Motor Trade Association, made up of all the garage owners, who are being stitched up by their own Association. So much arrogance in the VTNZ stations too. Not pleasant to deal with and remember the sexual harassment case from Hewletts Rd!
wof
Posted on 22-09-2012 09:19 | By Glen Clova
Nobody seem to be worried about the amount of people who will loose their jobs. The taxpayer will then have to pick up the tab for them and their family.
Don`t panic.
Posted on 23-09-2012 14:22 | By Vaughn
They can close the testing station on one end of Hewletts road.... (because the one at the other end is currently undergoing refurbishment and the addition of extra new lanes). The status quo should however remain with the testing every 6 months etc. I`d rather know cars coming towards me at 100kmph are safe thanks. Just keep the WOF check price reasonable or lower than currently (its a money making rip off!).
In the US . . .
Posted on 27-09-2012 19:43 | By nzforester
. . . no WOF. Registration $45 a year, although insurance a lot higher. People do tend to be a bit more responsible about maintaining their vehicles however. It does need to be relaxed, its very inconsistent depending on which place you go, and those who drive unsafe cars will do so regardless of whether they have a WOF or not. New Zealanders shouldn't be subsidizing the jobs of those who are adding nothing productive except cost, hassle and a 6 monthly gamble of the mood of the tester.
i agree with termite
Posted on 28-10-2012 16:09 | By blinky
apart from this new cars after 100ks should be subject to six months Heavy vehicles check I had a workshop before retiring dealing mainly with heavy vehicles and almost without exception owners would not repare trucks until the next inspection was due trying to save money
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.