Memorial removals: “Frustrated with communication”

Mount Maunganui resident Matthew Henry (Harry) Oram, left, his father Matthew Oram, and his sister Alessandra Oram. Photo: Supplied/SunLive.

A place of deep sentimental value for one family is about to change forever.

Mount Maunganui resident Matthew Henry (Harry) Oram says his grandfather's memorial plaque, who is the son of a former Speaker of the House of Representatives, is being removed from Mauao this week.

Harry says he is frustrated with the "lack of communication" between the Tauranga City Council and families who own the plaques.

"We never even got the chance to say thank you to local iwi for our time using the space on Mauao. A discussion like this would have been great for closure."

Tauranga City Council is in the process of removing the remaining memorial plaques which sit on Mauao in the coming weeks, as part of the 'Mauao Placemaking Project” collaboration between Tauranga City Council and Ngā Poutiriao ō Mauao (Mauao Joint Administration Board).

According to Tauranga City Council, 'many” of the plaques have remained on the historic site for more than 20 years.

The removals have also sparked a conversation between the Mauao Joint Administration Board and Tauranga City Council on whether to remove the memorial of British backpacker Monica Cantwell, who was murdered on the landmark in 1989.

For Harry, the memorial plaque for his grandfather who he was named after is a place to reflect, as well as serve as a direct connection to the country he calls home.

Harry was named after his great grandfather, Sir Matthew Oram, who was knighted after becoming the 13th Speaker of the New Zealand House of Representatives from 1950 to 1957.

Harry Oram says the plaque is a place where he went to think about every major life decision. Photo: Taylor Rice/SunLive.

'I was born in Hong Kong. As much as I love Hong Kong I am not Chinese. When I lived in England, because my mother is Asian, I was sometimes not English enough. The memorial here is a symbol to me that I am a New Zealander,” says Harry.

When his grandfather was alive, Harry says he would always tell his father to make sure his children know 'they are New Zealanders”.

"It's significant for my whole family too. Both of my sisters were engaged on the mount. It became a destination for any family member to visit. It's akin to my grandfathers gravestone."

Harry says when the bench first went up in the mid-1990s, there weren't many benches around, and the spot was chosen because it was his grandfathers favourite place to sit.

"I want to make it clear we are really grateful for our time on Mauao, we don't want to put in dispute the iwi sovereignty over Mauao. It would have just been nice to talk with the decision makers to discuss options as it means a lot to our family.

"If they wanted us to upgrade the bench and pay for it, we would have. If it meant we had to pay regular rent we would have done it as it means so much to us.

"It was explained to me later on the phone it was about signage, and the decision makers don't want anything non-Māori on [Mauao] it.

"It would have been nice to have this explained properly, and at least give our family enough time to deal with it. My sisters are overseas and will be returning to New Zealand in January, so they won't get to see the bench again.

"It also hurts me the most because ever since I was about 11, I knew I was going to have a son named Matthew Henry too, and have a photo of myself, my dad, who is also named Matthew Henry, and my son on the bench."

Harry says although the bench can be moved anywhere, the specific spot is significant to his family due to the memories associated with the space. Photo: Supplied/SunLive.

The Mount Maunganui resident also believes there has been a miscommunication in regard to the time limit agreed upon for the memorials.

'Back when my father purchased the plaque to remember my grandfather, there was no time limit on the memorials,” says Harry.

Tauranga City Council spaces and places manager Sarah Pearce says prior to the plan to remove the memorials, plaques were to be maintained and remain on site for '10 years with no right of renewal”.

'Many of the seats have remained on the site for more than 20 years,” says Sarah.

Harry says at the time of his father's purchase of his grandfather's memorial, there was no such rule.

'My father even renewed the plaque a few years ago, and had it upgraded to look brand new. The council had the chance to tell us then the memorials had an expiry date, but they didn't."

Harry says he does not believe the issue of the memorial removals should incite racial discussion.

"The ongoing project is great for the local iwi. I am just frustrated at the lack of communication between the Tauranga City Council and the families with the memorials."

Harry adds the council told him they were finding it "difficult" to find the families associated with the memorials.

"They told me they even put my name into Google. If you Google my name right now there's lots of information that's right there and easy to access."

"When the council did call me, the way it was presented me it was as though our memorial should have never been allowed in the first place, and our sentimental value to the location was nothing but an inconvenience.

"I'm not pointing any fingers or trying to call anyone out. But this whole process does appear as disrespectful and insensitive."

A Tauranga City Council spokesperson says they have been in touch with some of those who have memorials on Mauao. Photo: John Borren/SunLive.

A Tauranga City Council spokesperson says since the first seat was removed, they have been "working hard" to gather the contact details for those who have memorials on the remaining seats.

"We are pleased to be in contact with a number of families to discuss alternative, long-term memorial opportunities," says the spokesperson.

As the large majority of these seats were installed over 20 years ago it is challenging to locate contact details that are accurate.

"All plaques that need to be removed will be stored safely until they can be collected by the families. We would like to work with the families to discuss the possibility of planting trees in memory of their loved ones.

"We encourage anyone with a memorial seat on Mauao that we haven't been able to make contact with to reach out to our Mauao Ranger, Josh Clark on 07 577 7000."

Harry spoke about this topic on the most recent Buzzworthy 'Future Buzz' podcast. To watch the full episode, visit the Buzzworthy website.

8 comments

Sensitivity.

Posted on 12-12-2022 12:31 | By morepork

Before any decision was taken, this issue and the arguments should have been discussed publicly and by iwi on the marae, with all sides examined. There is no physical need to remove ANY of the memorials and the psychological impacts can be dealt with across ethnicities, with respect and consideration. Sad that it hasn't happened.


Sad

Posted on 12-12-2022 13:07 | By Kancho

You are reminded and tell us your connections to this place as New Zealanders however it's iwi that call the shots on my Mt Maunganui?.


mount memorials

Posted on 12-12-2022 15:07 | By grayman

The Council has not done enough to find the relatives who have often paid to have these memorials placed on the mount.To say that they only want to have Maori things on the mount is un believable .


It's simply disgraceful.

Posted on 12-12-2022 15:42 | By Bruja

There are those who wouldn't be happy unless there was no non-Maori anything (including humans) in this beautiful country. Anyone who was born in this country is native and indigenous to this country. All native and indigenous New Zealanders have equal rights and responsibilities.


Absolute Disgrace

Posted on 12-12-2022 16:35 | By Yadick

This whole shamozle of ripping out loved ones memorials and the way it has been done is an absolute disgrace. It's just another appalling effort from TCC and yes, remember who sits at the top. As for Monica's memorial, LEAVE IT ALONE. You'd probably only end up buying another rock to put up there. How is a little silver plaque causing any problems. The alledged owners of the Mount haven't said much about all this apart from a little blurb from Buddy. Would be good to know their thoughts and Treaty twist on it all.


Appalling Decision

Posted on 12-12-2022 17:29 | By Mommatum

Considering the present “council” is unelected how is it that they still have the power to make these kinds of decisions on our behalf? As for this one it is absolutely heartless. There should’ve been a hui or some attempt to consult with these families in the proper manner. As for “nothing non Maori” on Mauao being Maori myself I find that logic laughable. Remembering those who’ve passed transcends all racial boundaries. To deny this Is the height of ignorance.


I support Mommatum.

Posted on 13-12-2022 11:14 | By morepork

This should not be allowed to become a racial issue. Most cultures in the world practise respect for the dead. I believe what we are seeing here is a short-sighted and ill-conceived attempt to reinforce "ownership" by a small section of iwi, probably stemming from years of being denied "ownership", and reinforced by a spineless Council doing what they consider to be PC. Remember, the Council are directed by our unelected Commissioners who are applying the party line (tikanga) from Mahuta. They will be seeking to appease iwi, rather than discuss the issue properly. It is very likely that most iwi are just as offended as the rest of us at the insensitivity being shown. Because there is no answerability, the Trust had no need for a public discussion before moving on it, and the different viewpoints and sensitivities of a diverse society were never expressed or discussed.


Wrong shoe

Posted on 14-12-2022 13:28 | By CliftonGuy

If the shoe were on the other foot, and a memorial to a Maori were being removed, there would be an iwi uproar and hell to pay. There should be one rule for all. Anything else is discrimination, which is illegal in NZ, so I am told.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.